Adverse selection is a concept that can have serious consequences in business and finance. It occurs when individuals or businesses with certain characteristics, such as high-risk investments, are more likely to enter a market or engage in a particular activity.
This can lead to a skewed outcome, where the average risk level of the market or activity increases, potentially harming other participants. For instance, in the insurance industry, adverse selection can happen when only high-risk individuals buy insurance, causing premiums to rise.
The result is a self-reinforcing cycle where high-risk individuals are more likely to participate, and the market becomes less attractive to lower-risk individuals. This can lead to a market failure or inefficiency.
In the context of insurance, adverse selection can cause insurance companies to raise premiums, making it even less attractive for lower-risk individuals to buy insurance, further exacerbating the problem.
Check this out: Characterizes Clonal Selection
Definition
Adverse selection is a concept in economics that occurs when individuals with a higher risk of a negative outcome are more likely to participate in a market or activity.
It can lead to a skewed pool of participants, making the overall risk higher for everyone involved.
For example, in the health insurance market, people who are already sick are more likely to buy insurance than healthy people.
This can cause insurance companies to raise premiums for everyone, making it even less affordable for healthy people to buy insurance.
Examples
Adverse selection is a real issue that can affect various types of insurance, including life, health, and auto insurance. It occurs when an applicant withholds or provides false information to obtain coverage at lower premiums than they would have paid if the insurance company had known their actual risk.
Concealing a nicotine dependency can lead to adverse selection in life or health insurance, as a smoker must pay higher premiums due to the increased risk of health issues. This is exactly what happened in the example of someone who obtained insurance coverage as a non-smoker when they actually had a nicotine dependency.
Expand your knowledge: Natural Selection
Providing a false residence address can also lead to adverse selection in auto insurance, as the risk of theft or damage to the vehicle is higher in a high-crime area. For instance, an applicant might state that their vehicle is parked in a garage every night when it's actually parked on a busy street.
The lemons problem, first described by economist George A. Akerlof, is another example of adverse selection. It occurs when the only products left on the market are of poor quality, such as defective used cars, due to the seller's lack of information about the product's quality.
Insurance companies can fight adverse selection by strategically managing their risk and keeping rates competitive. However, concealing vital information, such as a health condition, can lead to adverse selection and disadvantage the insurance company.
Related reading: Information Literacy
How Markets Are Impacted
Adverse selection can lead to excessive private investment, causing projects with lower expected returns to receive funding due to information asymmetry in the market.
In capital markets, the presence of adverse selection results in debt being cheaper than equity as a source of external capital, forming a "pecking order". This is because debt offerings act as a signal to outside investors that the firm's management believes the current stock price is undervalued.
The market can gain access to information that was previously unknown, such as company reports, which can remove the presence of information asymmetry and alleviate adverse selection.
In the lending market, collateral can reduce the negative effects of adverse selection, but increasing levels of adverse selection can have significant effects on bond markets and lenders' spirits.
Adverse selection arises from information asymmetries, where some have more information than others, allowing them to take advantage of those less-informed to their detriment.
The utilization of collateral can mitigate adverse selection issues and adjust borrower's financial behavior into a positive direction, especially under diversification lending strategies.
Adverse selection can lead to market inefficiencies that increase prices or prevent transactions from occurring, making it essential to address this issue in public policies and market regulations.
A different take: Affects Consumers Retail Outlet Selection
Related Concepts
Adverse selection is closely related to other economic concepts that involve information asymmetry and market dynamics.
In the context of health insurance, adverse selection is often linked to moral hazard, which occurs when individuals take on more risk because they have insurance coverage.
Another concept related to adverse selection is signaling, where individuals may choose to reveal information about themselves to influence the decisions of others.
Moral Hazard
Moral hazard is the reckless behavior of someone who is insured. This happens because they feel protected by their insurance, so they're more likely to take risks they wouldn't normally take.
Adverse selection and moral hazard are two distinct concepts that can both lead to problems in insurance. Adverse selection occurs before purchasing insurance, while moral hazard occurs afterward.
Insurance can sometimes encourage people to be less careful, leading to reckless behavior. This is especially true if the insurance policy doesn't have high enough deductibles or if the policyholder doesn't feel personally responsible for their actions.
Moral hazard can be costly for insurance companies, as they end up paying out more claims than they would if their policyholders were more careful. This can drive up premiums and make insurance less affordable for everyone.
Signalling and Screening
Signalling and Screening are two related concepts that help mitigate adverse selection in various markets. In online marketplaces like eBay, reputation mechanisms act as a signal of quality, allowing buyers to filter high-quality sellers from low-quality ones.
Buyers naturally prefer to purchase from high-quality sellers, creating an incentive for sellers to enhance their reputation. This reputation system helps reduce adverse selection by providing a reliable signal for buyers.
Screening games, on the other hand, are better suited when the uninformed party needs to make the initial decision in participating in a contract. This is because screening methodologies suggest not participating in the contract at all if the risk of the worst possible outcome is too great.
Investors in financial markets often screen possible outcomes before making an investment, weighing the risk of poor returns against the cost of consulting a trading specialist.
Practical Applications
Adverse selection can have real-world consequences, especially in industries where people are hiding information to get better deals. In the example of life insurance, a diabetic person might conceal their health condition to get similar treatment as a healthy person.
Concealing health information is a form of adverse selection, leading to unfair agreements between the insurance company and the policyholder. This can be seen in the case of the diabetic person who doesn't disclose their condition.
The insurance company will be at a disadvantage if it doesn't have information on the health status of its policyholders. This can lead to financial losses and poor risk management.
In the example of the two potential policyholders, the diabetic person is aware that disclosing their condition will attract high premiums. This awareness can lead to concealment of information, resulting in adverse selection.
The insurance company requires potential clients to be truthful and disclose all relevant information, including health conditions. However, if a policyholder conceals their health information, it can lead to adverse selection and unfair agreements.
You might enjoy: Highest Global Warming Potential
Key Takeaways
Adverse selection is a phenomenon where one party in a transaction has more information than the other, leading to an unfair advantage.
In the insurance industry, adverse selection occurs when an applicant gains insurance at a lower cost than their true level of risk. This can happen when someone with a nicotine dependency gets insurance at the same rate as someone without a nicotine dependency.
Insurance companies have three main options to protect against adverse selection: accurately identifying risk factors, verifying information, and placing caps on coverage.
Here are some examples of adverse selection:
- Someone in a dangerous job purchasing life or disability insurance where they're more likely to collect on it.
- A seller having better information about a product's quality than the buyer.
- Adverse selection can be seen in markets for used cars or insurance.
These examples illustrate how adverse selection can occur in various contexts, often to the disadvantage of the buyer.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_selection
- https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/wealth-management/adverse-selection/
- https://www.healthinsurance.org/glossary/adverse-selection/
- https://www.investopedia.com/articles/insurance/082516/examples-adverse-selection-insurance-industry.asp
- https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/adverseselection.asp
Featured Images: pexels.com