Wells Fargo has been involved in several high-profile lawsuits and financial scandals over the years. The bank's troubles began in 2016 when it was discovered that thousands of employees had opened fake accounts in customers' names without their consent.
This practice, known as "cross-selling", was a key part of Wells Fargo's business strategy, but it ultimately led to a massive scandal. The bank was fined $185 million by regulatory agencies and faced numerous lawsuits from affected customers.
Wells Fargo has also faced lawsuits related to its mortgage practices, including allegations of "robo-signing" and other forms of mortgage abuse. The bank has paid billions of dollars in settlements to resolve these claims.
The bank's financial scandals have had a significant impact on its reputation and bottom line.
History
Wells Fargo was founded in 1852 by Henry Wells and William Fargo, who had a vision to create a bank that would provide financial services to the American West.
The bank's early success was largely due to its innovative use of stagecoaches to transport money and mail between the East and West coasts.
The company's first headquarters was located in San Francisco, California, which was a major hub for trade and commerce at the time.
In the late 1800s, Wells Fargo expanded its services to include express delivery, which allowed customers to send packages and money quickly and securely across the country.
The bank's reputation for reliability and efficiency earned it the nickname "Wells Fargo Express."
The company continued to grow and evolve over the years, but it remained committed to its core values of innovation and customer service.
Wells Fargo played a significant role in the development of the American West, providing financial services to settlers, miners, and traders.
The bank's iconic black horse and carriage logo has remained largely unchanged since its introduction in the late 1800s.
Today, Wells Fargo is one of the largest banks in the United States, with a presence in over 35 countries around the world.
Environmental Record
Wells Fargo has set a goal to reduce absolute emissions from companies it lends to in the oil and gas sector by 26% by 2030 from 2019 levels. This goal is ambitious, but some critics argue it's hard to achieve given the bank's significant lending to fossil fuel companies.
The company has committed to net zero financed emissions by 2050. However, major environmental groups are skeptical about whether this goal will be achieved.
Wells Fargo has stated that it will not finance any hydrocarbon exploration projects in the Arctic. This is a notable commitment, especially considering the sensitive and fragile environment of the Arctic region.
The company has also provided financing to renewable energy projects. This is a positive step towards reducing its carbon footprint and supporting sustainable energy sources.
Lawsuits and Controversies
Wells Fargo has been involved in numerous lawsuits and controversies over the years. In 2016, the company agreed to pay $1.2 billion to settle allegations that it violated the False Claims Act by underwriting over 100,000 FHA-backed loans when over half of the applicants did not qualify for the program.
The company has also faced lawsuits related to mortgage servicing practices, including a $3.1 million fine in 2012 for improperly charging a homeowner $24,000 in mortgage fees. Additionally, Wells Fargo agreed to pay $4 million in 2015 for illegally taking an interest in the homes of borrowers in exchange for opening credit card accounts.
The company has also faced allegations of discriminating against African Americans in hiring, with the company agreeing to pay $7.8 million in back wages in 2020 for allegedly discriminating against 34,193 African Americans in hiring for various positions. Wells Fargo has also faced fines from the SEC, including a $6.5 million fine in 2012 for selling risky mortgage-backed securities without fully realizing their dangers.
Here is a list of some of the notable lawsuits and fines faced by Wells Fargo:
- $1.2 billion settlement for violating the False Claims Act (2016)
- $3.1 million fine for improper mortgage fees (2012)
- $4 million fine for illegally taking an interest in borrowers' homes (2015)
- $7.8 million in back wages for discriminating against African Americans in hiring (2020)
- $6.5 million fine for selling risky mortgage-backed securities (2012)
- $350,000 fine and $10 million in restitution for failing to supervise registered representatives (2020)
1981 Maps Embezzlement Scandal
The 1981 MAPS Wells Fargo embezzlement scandal was a massive financial scandal that shook the banking industry. In 1981, a Wells Fargo assistant operations officer named Lloyd Benjamin "Ben" Lewis was found to have perpetrated one of the largest embezzlements in history through the bank's Beverly Drive branch.
Lewis had successfully written phony debit and credit receipts to benefit boxing promoters Harold J. Smith and Sam "Sammie" Marshall, chairman and president of Muhammad Ali Professional Sports, Inc. (MAPS), of which Lewis was also a director. Over $300,000 was paid to Lewis, who eventually pled guilty to embezzlement and conspiracy charges and received a reduced five-year sentence.
Here are the key players involved in the scandal:
This scandal highlights the importance of internal controls and oversight in preventing financial malfeasance. It also underscores the need for transparency and accountability in financial institutions to prevent similar scandals from occurring in the future.
Sec Settlement for Insider Trading
In May 2015, a stock analyst at Wells Fargo agreed to pay $75,000 to settle allegations of insider trading. Gregory T. Bolan Jr. was involved in the case, which involved giving insider information to a stock trader.
The stock trader, Joseph C. Ruggieri, was not convicted of any crime despite receiving the insider information. This highlights the complexity of insider trading cases, where individuals may be accused but not necessarily convicted.
New York Credit Card Laws Violation
Wells Fargo agreed to pay $4 million in 2015 for violating New York credit card laws. This settlement included a $2 million penalty and $2 million in restitution.
The company was accused of taking an interest in the homes of borrowers in exchange for opening credit card accounts for the homeowners. This practice was deemed illegal.
In February 2015, the settlement was reached, marking a significant outcome for those affected by the company's actions.
Regulatory Issues
Wells Fargo has been the subject of several investigations by regulators, resulting in reputational damage and significant fines.
The Federal Reserve barred Wells Fargo from growing its asset base in 2018 due to internal problems. In 2021, the company incurred fines from the US Justice Department for fraudulent behavior in foreign-exchange currency trading.
Wells Fargo was also the only major lender in 2020 to reject more home refinance applications from Black applicants than it approved. The US levied a $3.7 billion loan-management fine upon Wells Fargo in December 2022.
Dakota Access Pipeline Financing
The Dakota Access Pipeline has been a contentious issue due to its potential environmental impact.
Wells Fargo is a lender on the pipeline, which spans 1,172 miles underground in North Dakota.
The pipeline's length is 1,886 km.
In 2017, Seattle and Davis, California city councils voted to move $3 billion of deposits from Wells Fargo due to its involvement with the pipeline and another scandal.
SEC Fine for Inadequate Risk Disclosures
Wells Fargo agreed to pay around $6.5 million to settle U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charges that in 2007 it sold risky mortgage-backed securities without fully realizing their dangers.
This fine was a result of inadequate risk disclosures, a serious issue that can have far-reaching consequences for investors and the financial industry as a whole.
In 2012, Wells Fargo agreed to pay a significant sum to settle these charges, demonstrating the importance of transparency and honesty in financial dealings.
The SEC took action against Wells Fargo for failing to properly disclose the risks associated with these mortgage-backed securities, which can have devastating effects on investors who are not aware of the potential dangers.
Wells Fargo's actions in this case highlight the need for companies to prioritize transparency and honesty in their dealings, and to take responsibility for any wrongdoing that may occur.
Financial Products
Wells Fargo offers a wide range of financial products to its customers, including deposit accounts, credit cards, and investment services.
You can open a savings account with as little as $25 and enjoy features like automatic savings transfers and overdraft protection. The Way2Save Savings Account has a low minimum deposit of $25 and waives the monthly service fee for account holders under 24.
The bank also offers a Platinum Savings account with the option to write checks and no restrictions on monthly withdrawals. However, it comes with a $12 monthly fee that can only be waived by maintaining a $3,500 minimum daily balance.
Here are the details of Wells Fargo's savings accounts:
In addition to savings accounts, Wells Fargo offers other financial products such as car loans, mortgages, and business loans.
Other Financial Products
Wells Fargo offers a wide range of financial products beyond deposit accounts and credit cards.
The bank provides car loans to its customers, making it easier for them to purchase a vehicle.
You can also get a purchase mortgage or refinance your existing mortgage through Wells Fargo.
In addition to mortgages, the bank offers IRAs, which can help you save for retirement.
If you're interested in investing, Wells Fargo offers self-directed trading and managed investment portfolios.
The bank also provides private banking services and financial advisors to help you manage your finances.
For business owners, Wells Fargo offers business loans to help them grow their business.
If you need personal financial assistance, you can get a personal loan from the bank.
Student loans are also available through Wells Fargo, making it easier for students to fund their education.
Here's a list of some of the other financial products offered by Wells Fargo:
- Car loans
- Purchase mortgages
- Refinance mortgages
- IRAs
- Self-directed trading
- Managed investment portfolios
- Private banking
- Financial advisors
- Business loans
- Personal loans
- Student loans
Credit Cards
Wells Fargo offers a wide range of credit cards to suit different needs, from cash-back cards to rewards cards to balance transfer cards.
Their cash-back credit card, the Wells Fargo Active Cash Card, is a great option for those who want to earn rewards on their purchases.
Wells Fargo also offers rewards cards, such as the Hotels.com Rewards Visa Credit Card, which allows customers to earn points or miles for their hotel bookings.
The Wells Fargo Reflect card is another popular option for those looking to transfer balances from other credit cards.
Here are some of the credit cards offered by Wells Fargo:
- Wells Fargo Active Cash Card
- Hotels.com Rewards Visa Credit Card
- Wells Fargo Reflect
These credit cards can help customers manage their finances and earn rewards on their purchases.
Long-Term Overhang
Wells Fargo faced significant pressure from shareholders and regulators in 2017, with 9 out of 15 directors receiving less than 75% support at the company's annual meeting.
In particular, board chairman Stephen Sanger received only 56% support, while head of the risk committee Enrique Hernandez and head of the corporate responsibility committee Federico Peña received 53% and 54% support, respectively.
Cynthia Milligan, who headed the credit committee, received 57% support, indicating widespread discontent among shareholders.
The bank responded to these concerns by announcing the resignations of 6 directors, including Sanger, who was replaced by Elizabeth Duke as board chair.
Wells Fargo's troubles continued, with the company increasing its estimate of potentially unauthorized consumer accounts to 3.5 million in August 2017.
This led to an additional $2.8 million in refunds being issued to affected customers.
The bank's efforts to reexamine its business also uncovered sales practice violations in its auto and mortgage lending divisions.
As a result, the Federal Reserve Board took the unprecedented action of placing a strict limit on the company's asset size in February 2018.
The limit prohibited Wells Fargo from growing past the $1.95 trillion in assets it had at year end until it demonstrated improvement in corporate controls.
The company ultimately agreed to a $1 billion settlement with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency to resolve auto and mortgage lending violations in April 2018.
It also agreed to pay $480 million to settle a securities class action lawsuit over cross-selling two weeks later.
Acquisitions and Mergers
Wells Fargo has a history of making numerous smaller acquisitions each year, with a notable example being the 13 companies it acquired in 1999, totaling $2.4 billion in assets.
The largest acquisition of 1999 was the purchase of Mercantile Financial Enterprises, Inc., a Texas-based company with $779 million in assets. In 2000, Wells Fargo expanded its retail banking into two more states: Michigan and Alaska.
Wells Fargo's acquisition pace picked up in 2000, with notable deals including the purchase of First Commerce Bancshares, Inc. of Nebraska, which had $2.9 billion in assets, and a Seattle-based regional brokerage firm, Ragen MacKenzie Group Incorporated. The company also acquired First Security Corporation, a $23 billion bank holding company based in Utah, for nearly $3 billion in stock.
The acquisition of First Security Corporation in 2000 made Wells Fargo the largest banking franchise in terms of deposits in New Mexico, Nevada, Idaho, and Utah, as well as the largest banking franchise in the West overall. Following the completion of the acquisition, Wells Fargo had total assets of $263 billion with some 140,000 employees.
Acquisitions in 1999-2000
In 1999, Wells Fargo made 13 acquisitions with total assets of $2.4 billion. The largest acquisition that year was Mercantile Financial Enterprises, Inc. with $779 million in assets.
Wells Fargo's acquisition pace picked up in 2000, expanding its retail banking into two new states: Michigan and Alaska. It acquired Michigan Financial Corporation with $975 million in assets and National Bank of Alaska with $3 billion of assets.
Wells Fargo also acquired First Commerce Bancshares, Inc. of Lincoln, Nebraska, with $2.9 billion in assets, and a Seattle-based regional brokerage firm, Ragen MacKenzie Group Incorporated. The company made its largest deal since the Norwest-Wells Fargo merger in October 2000, paying nearly $3 billion in stock for First Security Corporation.
Following the acquisition, Wells Fargo became the largest banking franchise in terms of deposits in New Mexico, Nevada, Idaho, and Utah, as well as the largest banking franchise in the West overall. The company had total assets of $263 billion with some 140,000 employees after the completion of the First Security acquisition.
Wachovia Acquisition
Wells Fargo acquired Wachovia Corporation in 2008 for $15.1 billion. This acquisition created a coast-to-coast super-bank with $1.4 trillion in assets and 48 million customers.
The acquisition expanded Wells Fargo's operations into nine Eastern and Southern states, with big overlaps only in California and Texas. There would be much less overlap in Nevada, Arizona, and Colorado.
Wachovia initially accepted a deal with Citigroup, but later chose to go with Wells Fargo's offer. A New York state judge issued a temporary injunction blocking the transaction, but it was later overturned by the appeals court.
The proposed merger was approved by the Federal Reserve as a $12.2 billion all-stock transaction on October 12, 2008. The acquisition was completed on January 1, 2009.
Management and Leadership
Wells Fargo has had its fair share of leadership changes over the years. John Stumpf was named chief executive officer of the company in June 2007.
Richard Kovacevich remained as chairman after Stumpf took over as CEO.
Culture and Management
John Stumpf was named chief executive officer of the company in June 2007.
This change in leadership marked a significant shift in the company's management structure. Richard Kovacevich remained as chairman, overseeing the company's overall direction.
John Stumpf took the reins as CEO, bringing his own vision and leadership style to the role.
Executive Compensation
Wells Fargo's CEO, John Stumpf, was paid 473 times more than the median employee. This puts the company at number 33 among the S&P 500 companies for CEO-employee pay inequality.
In 2014, a Wells Fargo employee emailed the CEO, suggesting that all employees be given a $10,000 per year raise taken from corporate profits to address wage stagnation and income inequality.
Publicly traded companies, like Wells Fargo, are required to disclose the median total annual compensation of all employees other than the CEO.
Government Involvement
Wells Fargo received a $25 billion bailout from the U.S. Treasury in the form of a preferred stock purchase on October 28, 2008.
This investment was made under the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, which was a key part of the government's response to the 2008 financial crisis.
Wells Fargo needed an additional $13.7 billion in capital to remain well-capitalized, according to the Federal government's stress test scenarios.
The bank raised $8.6 billion in capital through a stock offering in May 2009, and planned to raise the remaining $4.9 billion through earnings.
Wells Fargo redeemed the $25 billion of series D preferred stock issued to the U.S. Treasury on December 23, 2009, and paid accrued dividends of $131.9 million.
U.S. Treasury Investments During 2008 Crisis
In October 2008, the U.S. Treasury invested $25 billion in Wells Fargo through the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act.
This investment was a result of the 2008 financial crisis, which had a significant impact on the economy.
The U.S. Treasury's investment in Wells Fargo was part of a larger effort to stabilize the financial system.
On May 11, 2009, Wells Fargo announced an additional stock offering to raise capital.
This offering was completed on May 13, 2009, and raised $8.6 billion in capital.
Wells Fargo needed an additional $13.7 billion in capital to remain well-capitalized, according to federal government tests.
The remaining $4.9 billion in capital was planned to be raised through earnings.
The U.S. Treasury redeemed the $25 billion of series D preferred stock issued to Wells Fargo on December 23, 2009.
As part of the redemption, Wells Fargo paid accrued dividends of $131.9 million to the U.S. Treasury.
Tax Liability and Lobbying
Wells Fargo spent $11 million on lobbying during 2008-2010 while increasing executive pay and laying off workers.
The company had no federal tax liability during this time due to losses from the Great Recession.
In 2013, Wells Fargo paid $9.1 billion in income taxes, a significant change from their previous tax liability.
Public Campaign criticized Wells Fargo for their lobbying efforts and tax practices, highlighting the disconnect between their actions and their tax obligations.
Fees and Practices
Wells Fargo has faced criticism for its overdraft practices, with a 2010 fine from a US district court judge for "gouging" consumers and "profiteering" at their expense. The bank was also ordered to pay $203 million in 2013 to settle class-action litigation over excessive overdraft fees.
Wells Fargo has also been involved in mortgage servicing controversies, including a 2012 National Mortgage Settlement that required the bank to provide $5.4 billion in relief to distressed homeowners. In 2012, a federal judge ordered the bank to pay $3.1 million in punitive damages for improperly charging a homeowner $24,000 in mortgage fees.
Wells Fargo has also been accused of steering customers into more expensive retirement plans, with a 2018 probe launched by the US Department of Labor. However, the bank offers some affordable savings options, including the Way2Save Savings Account, which has a low minimum deposit of $25 and no minimum balance requirement to earn interest.
Bank Account Closure
Bank account closure can be a stressful and frustrating experience, especially if you're not prepared. Between 2011 and 2016, Wells Fargo was found to have been freezing entire consumer deposit accounts based on automated fraud detection.
This freeze extended to the entire account, not just the suspicious amount, and all access to funds was blocked. Customers were unable to access their funds until the accounts were closed and the funds were returned.
In 2022, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau mandated that Wells Fargo provide $160 million in compensation to more than a million individuals, addressing the significant harm caused by its aggressive tactic of freezing and closing bank accounts during this period.
Overdraft Fees
Overdraft fees can be a major source of financial stress for consumers. In 2010, a United States district court judge fined Wells Fargo for its overdraft practices, calling them "gouge" tactics designed to profiteer from consumers.
Wells Fargo was also accused of misleading customers about how it processed transactions and assessed overdraft fees. This led to a $203 million settlement in 2013 to resolve class-action litigation against the bank.
Consumers need to be aware of these practices to avoid unnecessary fees.
Independent Investigation Report
The Independent Investigation Report revealed some disturbing facts about Wells Fargo's practices.
The report found that Wells Fargo employees were opening over 1.5 million fake accounts in customers' names without their knowledge or consent.
The bank's employees were motivated by bonuses and pressure to meet sales targets, which led to a culture of deception and dishonesty.
In some cases, customers were even charged fees for accounts they never opened or used.
The report's findings were based on a thorough examination of internal bank documents and testimony from former employees.
Wells Fargo's CEO at the time, John Stumpf, was forced to resign in response to the scandal.
Banking and Services
Wells Fargo offers a range of banking services, including online banking and a mobile app, making it easy to manage your accounts on the go.
You can open a new account online or in a bank branch, and get an instant application status response. This convenience is a big plus for those who value efficiency and streamlined banking.
Wells Fargo has a large geographic footprint, making it a great option for those who need a bank present in the majority of the United States, including the District of Columbia.
To avoid fees, you'll need to keep a minimum balance in your checking and savings account. This is a common requirement for many banks, but it's essential to note if you're looking for a low-maintenance banking experience.
Wells Fargo also integrates well with popular accounting and financial tools like Mint, QuickBooks online, and TurboTax online, making it a great fit for those who already use these services.
Savings Accounts
Savings Accounts are a great way to stash your cash and earn some interest. You can open a Way2Save Savings Account with just $25 and earn 0.15% APY.
Wells Fargo's Way2Save Savings Account has a low monthly service fee of $5, but it can be waived with a $300 minimum daily balance or by setting up automatic transfers from a linked checking account.
The Save As You Go transfer feature is a nice touch, moving $1 from your checking account to your Way2Save account with each qualifying transaction.
To avoid the monthly fee, you can also take advantage of the automatic savings transfers or maintain a $300 minimum daily balance.
If you're under 24, your monthly fee will be waived, making it an even better option for young savers.
Here's a comparison of Wells Fargo's Savings Accounts:
The Platinum Savings account also offers the option to write checks and has no restrictions on the number of monthly withdrawals.
How to Bank
To bank with Wells Fargo, you can open a new account online or in a bank branch. Applying for an account online also provides an instant application status response.
Once you're set up with a Wells Fargo account, you can take care of your banking needs online and with the mobile app.
Wells Fargo is a well-established financial institution with a large geographic footprint, offering every type of account, product, and service you may need. This makes it a one-stop banking shop.
However, Wells Fargo's reputation has been dented due to past fraudulent practices, and it's working to correct its course. It's agreed to pay $3 billion in fines to settle a civil lawsuit and resolve a Justice Department criminal prosecution.
To avoid fees, you can maintain a minimum balance in your account or set up automatic transfers from linked Wells Fargo checking accounts. Wells Fargo also automatically waives the monthly fee for account holders under the age of 24.
Wells Fargo offers two savings accounts: Way2Save and Platinum Savings. The Way2Save account has a low minimum deposit of $25 and a monthly service fee of $5, which can be waived with a $300 minimum daily balance or automatic savings transfers.
The Platinum Savings account comes with the option to write checks and has an APY of 0.25%. However, there is a $12 monthly fee that can only be waived by maintaining a $3,500 minimum daily balance.
Here's a comparison of Wells Fargo's savings accounts:
Wells Fargo will appeal to customers who want a well-established traditional bank with a large geographic footprint. It's a great fit for those who can easily keep a minimum balance in their checking and savings account to avoid fees.
CDs
CDs can be a great way to save money, especially if you're willing to lock your funds in for a set period of time.
Wells Fargo offers a variety of CD options, including a Fixed Rate CD with different terms to choose from.
The Fixed Rate CD has a minimum opening deposit of $2,500, which is a relatively low barrier to entry.
Here's a breakdown of the different terms and their corresponding APYs:
If you're a Portfolio by Wells Fargo account-holder, you might be eligible for a bonus APY on your CD.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo
- https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/02/06/the-wells-fargo-cross-selling-scandal-2/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Wells_Fargo
- https://www.investopedia.com/wells-fargo-bank-review-5024853
- https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2024/12/11/opportunity-for-wells-fargo-stock-if-the-asset-cap-is-lifted/
Featured Images: pexels.com