A successful corporate carve out private equity deal requires careful planning and execution. Corporate carve outs involve separating a business unit or division from a larger company, which can be a complex process.
The goal of a corporate carve out is to create a standalone business that can be sold or operated independently. This is often achieved by separating the assets, liabilities, and employees of the business unit from the parent company.
A key consideration in corporate carve outs is the valuation of the business unit. This involves determining the fair market value of the assets and liabilities, as well as the business's revenue and profit streams. According to the article, a corporate carve out can result in a 20% to 50% increase in value for the business unit.
Effective communication is crucial in a corporate carve out, as it involves multiple stakeholders, including employees, customers, and investors. Transparency and clear communication can help to minimize disruption and ensure a smooth transition.
For more insights, see: A Corporate Financial Manager Trying to Maximize Shareholder Value
Why Corporate Carve Out Private Equity
Corporate carve outs are a way for private equity firms to acquire a specific business or division from a larger company. This can be a lucrative opportunity for both the private equity firm and the larger company.
By carving out a specific business, private equity firms can focus on a particular market or industry that they have expertise in. This allows them to maximize their returns on investment.
According to a study, 70% of corporate carve outs are in the industrial and manufacturing sectors. This is likely due to the fact that these sectors often have distinct businesses that can be easily separated from the rest of the company.
Private equity firms can also use corporate carve outs to acquire businesses that are not strategic fits for the larger company. This can be a win-win for both parties, as the private equity firm gets a new business to invest in and the larger company gets to divest a non-core asset.
In some cases, corporate carve outs can be used to acquire businesses that are in distress or have significant liabilities. Private equity firms can then use their expertise to turn the business around and generate returns on their investment.
The largest corporate carve out on record was a $5.4 billion deal for the chemicals division of a large multinational company. This deal highlights the size and scope of corporate carve outs, which can be significant transactions.
Key Considerations
A corporate carve out private equity deal can be a complex process, but understanding the key considerations can help you navigate it more effectively.
A carve-out involves selling shares in a subsidiary to the public through an initial public offering (IPO), establishing the subsidiary as a standalone company.
Here are some key considerations to keep in mind:
- A carve-out can be beneficial for a company that wants to capitalize on a business segment that's not part of its core operations.
- A carve-out establishes a new set of shareholders in the subsidiary, which can impact decision-making and control.
- A carve-out is similar to a spin-off, but with a key difference: a spin-off involves transferring shares to existing shareholders, whereas a carve-out involves selling shares to the public.
By understanding these key considerations, you can better evaluate the potential benefits and risks of a corporate carve out private equity deal.
Aligning Management Incentives
Aligning management incentives is crucial for a carve-out's success. This involves tying management's annual compensation to the company's key performance indicators.
With private equity ownership, weak executive officers are often let go and replaced by the PE firm's new hires. This ensures that management is held accountable for the company's performance.
Management's personal net worth and earnings are now tied to the business performance, which leads to a significant shift in their behavior. They become laser-focused on growth and cash flow generation.
PE firms often allocate a common option pool, giving management teams a cut of the gains on the investment. This can result in management making millions if the investment goes well.
Duplicative Expenses
You'll incur duplicative expenses when a carve-out business separates from a larger parent company, which can artificially suppress profit margins for the first few years.
These expenses are due to the business paying the parent company for transition services while also building its own corporate infrastructure and back office.
You'll need to start building your own finance team during the transition period to learn from the parent company's team, which can mean hiring and training costs.
This duplicative expense burden can be minimized by starting to build the team and infrastructure during the transition period, so the business is already standing on its own feet by the time transition services end.
The profit margins for the first few years can be artificially suppressed due to these duplicative expenses, which is not a reflection of the business's underlying earnings power.
You should add these duplicative expenses back to the model to reflect the business's true underlying earnings power for valuation purposes.
These duplicative expenses represent real cash outflow, but they're not a reflection of the business's long-term potential.
In addition to duplicative expenses, there are also significant one-time operating expenses and capital expenditures to facilitate the carve-out, which can impact year one cash flow.
Understanding the Process
A corporate carve-out private equity involves a complex process that requires careful planning and execution. In a carve-out, the parent company sells some of its shares in its subsidiary to the public through an initial public offering (IPO), establishing a new set of shareholders in the subsidiary.
The carve-out process separates a subsidiary or business unit from its parent as a standalone company with its own board of directors and financial statements. However, the parent company usually retains a controlling interest in the new company and offers strategic support and resources to help the business succeed.
The new entity may still rely on the parent company for general infrastructure and operational factors, requiring continued provision of services from the parent company for a defined time period. This can involve a range of activities, including data migration, system testing, and final system cutover.
Here are the key steps involved in a carve-out:
- Clone relevant parent company systems and apps to set up copies in the new entity’s environment.
- Identify and migrate all relevant and specific data from parent’s environment to new entity environment.
- Data validation checks must be implemented to ensure that parent data is not migrated as part of the carve-out.
- Test systems and apps of the new entity to ensure proper system functionality on day one of separation.
- Multiple rounds of testing will be conducted to simulate day-to-day system interactions and identify issues.
- Execute the final system cutover plan to begin business operations in the new business unit environment.
By carefully executing a separation that maintains the operational integrity of parent and new entity, the carve-out process can achieve significant value for both parties involved.
How a Works
A carve-out is a way for a parent company to sell some of its shares in a subsidiary to the public through an initial public offering (IPO). This process establishes a new set of shareholders in the subsidiary.
The new company will have its own board of directors and financial statements, but the parent company usually retains a controlling interest and offers strategic support and resources. This is different from a spin-off, where the parent company would give shares to its own shareholders, making the business unit an independent company.
A carve-out is often used when a company wants to maintain some control over the business unit, or if it doesn't believe a single buyer is available for the entire business. The parent company may also receive a cash inflow through a carve-out.
To be tax-free, the parent company must relinquish 80% of control or more in the future. This is known as the 80% control requirement.
Here are the key differences between a carve-out and a spin-off:
A carve-out can be a complex process, involving the migration of data, systems, and apps from the parent company to the new entity. This requires careful planning and execution to ensure a smooth transition.
The goal of a carve-out is to create a standalone business unit that can operate independently, while still maintaining some connection to the parent company. This can be achieved through the provision of general infrastructure and operational factors from the parent company for a defined time period.
Create a Road Map
Creating a road map is a crucial step in turning ideas into action. It should outline the new organizational setup based on activities reviewed, opportunities identified, and the program conceived for IT simplification.
A robust road map encompasses all functions, highlights key milestones, and identifies interdependencies critical to achieving a business-ready CarveCo. It can also define spans of control, reporting lines, and how different functions should interact with each other.
Any practicable road map should set forth FTE sizing at the level of an individual employee or specific activities and roles they should undertake. This level of detail is essential to ensure a smooth transition.
Better practice is to anticipate what could come next and plan for scenarios under a next-generation organizational setup. This involves defining changes that can be implemented in premarketing, preclosing, and postclosing phases.
The more detailed the road map, the more likely that RemainCo and CarveCo will create more value. This is especially true when considering the likely exit route, such as a spin-off, IPO, or divestiture to a strategic buyer.
Petiole
Petiole is a company that has invested in several corporate carve-outs in the last three years. They've partnered with KKR to acquire companies like Upfield, Hitachi Koki, and Hensoldt.
Petiole's most recent partnership with KKR was in November 2020, where they invested in the acquisition of Wella from Coty Inc. Wella is a professional hair company headquartered in Germany.
Petiole's investment in Wella is significant, considering it's the second-largest global professional hair player, just behind L'Oréal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a spin-off and a carve-out?
A spin-off involves distributing shares of a new subsidiary to existing shareholders, while a carve-out involves selling shares of the new subsidiary via an IPO after the parent company divests some of its stake. This key difference affects how ownership and control are transferred in each scenario.
What are the disadvantages of equity carve out?
Equity carve-out disadvantages include loss of full control over the subsidiary and reduced decision-making authority for the parent company
Sources
- Private Equity Carve Out 101 - Lessons in PE (10xebitda.com)
- Follow us on Linkedin (linkedin.com)
- 26 IRC § 368(c) (govinfo.gov)
- 26 IRC § 355(a) (govinfo.gov)
- The power of goodbye: How carve-outs can unleash value (mckinsey.com)
- Fission's Strategic Approach Simplifies Corporate Carve Out (fissionconsulting.com)
Featured Images: pexels.com