Association Captive Insurance Company: A Group Solution

An association captive insurance company is a type of insurance company that's formed by a group of individuals or organizations with a common interest or goal.

It's a group solution that provides a way for members to pool their risks and resources, reducing the financial burden of insurance costs.

Association captives are often used by industries or professions that have unique or high-risk exposures, such as healthcare or construction.

This can lead to significant cost savings and improved risk management for the members.

A different take: Group Captive Insurance Company

Group captive insurance companies offer several benefits that make them an attractive option for organizations.

One of the key benefits is pricing stability, which is achieved through the law of large numbers, allowing for a higher degree of confidence in overall claim experience.

By pooling resources, group captives can assume greater retentions, ultimately lowering the long-run cost of insuring the group's risks.

Reduced overhead is another advantage, thanks to economies of scale, resulting in a lower per-member cost of administering the group captive.

The range of probable losses is narrower in a group captive, requiring lower levels of combined surplus to operate, providing an added layer of financial stability.

Curious to learn more? Check out: Benefits of a Captive Insurance Company

Captives are a prudent, affordable alternative to traditional insurance for association members.

Savvy leaders have created programs to meet their members' unique needs, such as professional liability for legal and medical associations, property and casualty coverage for contractors, or healthcare needs for golf course owners.

Captives involve establishing a legitimate, licensed insurance company with actuarily sound management, which is regulated just like other insurance companies.

Association members invest a specified amount of money each year based on actuarial calculations, rather than paying traditional premiums.

The captive manages those funds and uses them to pay claims, providing a unique solution for association members.

Joining a group captive can be a game-changer for organizations with limited capital resources, as it provides a feasible alternative to forming a single-parent captive.

One of the key benefits of group captives is pricing stability, which is just as important as it is for single-owner captive insurers.

Group captives also offer improved services, a benefit that's hard to put a price on, but can make all the difference in the long run.

Insurance coverage stability is another advantage of group captives, providing peace of mind for organizations that need it most.

The group captive approach is a great option for organizations that want to take control of their insurance needs without breaking the bank.

Group captives offer improved loss forecasting due to the law of large numbers, allowing for a higher degree of confidence in predicting overall claim experience.

With reduced variation in loss levels, group captives can assume greater retentions, ultimately lowering the long-run cost of insuring the group's risks.

A narrower range of probable losses in a group captive means lower levels of combined surplus are required to operate.

This allows group captives to take on more risk and potentially save on insurance costs in the long run.

The sharing of losses among group captive members creates a sense of accountability and peer pressure to enforce safety practices and control claims.

This can lead to improved loss control and a healthier risk-taking environment within the group.

One of the most significant benefits of a group captive insurer is the reduced overhead costs. With economies of scale, the per-member cost of administering a group captive is decidedly lower than if the identical coverage is obtained in a single-owner arrangement.

This means that businesses can save money on administrative costs, which can be a significant burden on small to medium-sized companies.

Effective profit retention is a crucial aspect of group captives. According to Example 4, the majority of group captive insurance companies pay dividends or otherwise distribute underwriting profits and interest to their owners or insureds.

The group captive can be financially advantageous, as compared to a noninsurance risk retention program or commercial insurance, depending on how the captive program has been set up. This is because the captive can distribute underwriting profits and interest to its members.

A predetermined earnings distribution plan can avoid many problems related to profit retention and distribution. This is evident from Example 6, which states that many problems are avoided when a predetermined earnings distribution plan is in place before the captive begins to operate.

By retaining profits and distributing them effectively, group captives can provide a stable and predictable financial benefit to their members.

Readers also liked: Insurance Underwriting Companies

A captive insurance company in Utah can provide all lines of insurance allowed by the insurance code, except for workers compensation insurance, personal motor vehicle, and homeowners' insurance, or any component of these coverages.

A pure captive can only insure the risks of its parent, affiliates, or controlled unaffiliated business.

An association captive can insure the risks of association member organizations and affiliates of the association member organizations.

To get started, you'll need to obtain a valid Certificate of Authority from the commissioner, specifying the types of insurance authorized.

Here are the key types of insurance a captive can write:

You'll also need to hold regular meetings, maintain a principal place of business in Utah, and appoint a resident board member and registered agent.

Group captives present several challenges, particularly regarding tax issues.

One major challenge is the potential for tax problems if the captive is unable to meet the Internal Revenue Service's test regarding risk shifting and distribution.

Premium tax deductibility could be in jeopardy if the captive fails this test.

Recommended read: Captive Insurance Company Tax Benefits

Group captives are subject to a number of potential difficulties that don't plague their single-owner counterparts. One of the main issues is the inherent problems that come with having multiple owners.

Having multiple owners can lead to conflicting goals and priorities, which can create tension and make decision-making more challenging.

This can result in a lack of clear direction and a sense of uncertainty, which can be detrimental to the captive's overall performance and success.

Group captives are also more susceptible to decision-making paralysis, where no single owner is willing to take the lead and make a decision.

Formation/Capitalization Delays can be a major hurdle for group captives.

It can take years to convince potential members that there is no better option.

The time required to form and capitalize the venture increases proportionately with the number of potential members.

In fact, it's not unusual for a new group captive to go through the first few years with only a fraction of the participants that were anticipated.

Profits and earnings distribution conflicts are a major area of potential disagreement in group captives.

Having a predetermined earnings distribution plan in place before the captive begins to operate can avoid many problems. This plan should clearly outline how profits and earnings will be allocated among members.

Disagreements can arise between members as respects the rating process, which can impact their share of profits and earnings. Some members may fare significantly better or worse than others, depending on the rating plan devised.

Unless the captive is able to withstand the Internal Revenue Service's test regarding risk shifting and distribution, premium tax deductibility could be in jeopardy.

Different growth rates can create tension among group captive members. This is because owners who experience rapid growth may want to increase their retention levels and coverage amounts, while others may be hesitant to make these changes.

Members who have grown larger may desire higher retentions to manage their increased risks. The initial consensus on retention levels and risk insurance may no longer be suitable for these owners.

Readers also liked: With Disability Income Insurance an Insurance Company May Limit

Different growth rates among owners can lead to disagreements on how to manage the group captive. This can be a challenge for the group to overcome.

The group captive's initial agreement on retention levels and risk insurance may not be sustainable as owners grow at different rates. This can create uncertainty and tension among members.

Ultimately, group captives need to find a way to accommodate different growth rates among owners. This may involve revisiting and updating the initial agreement to ensure it remains fair and effective for all members.

Withdrawal of Participants can be a major challenge for group captives. This is because large-scale capital withdrawal by members can severely impair the captive's financial well-being.

Clear procedures must be developed to deal with potential withdrawals. These procedures should be clear and unambiguous to avoid confusion.

Withdrawal formulas that impose significant penalties for premature departure can help mitigate the risk of large-scale withdrawal. This is because penalties can discourage owners from leaving the captive early.

Group captives need to be prepared for the possibility of large-scale capital withdrawal. This requires careful planning and consideration of potential risks and consequences.

In Utah, there are specific types of captives that are available. Pure Captives and Group Captives are the two main types, with several group captive options including Association Captives and Industrial Insured Captives.

An Association Captive is owned by members of a common industry or trade association and is designed to insure the risks of that industry among its members. Participation is limited to members of the association.

An Industrial Insured Captive is formed to insure the risks produced by a group of industrial entities. Industrial entities may form a group and insure the risks produced by that group through an Industrial Insured Captive.

Readers also liked: Types of Captive Insurance

In Utah, there are two main types of captives: Pure Captives and Group Captives.

A Pure Captive is a type of captive that is owned by a single company or individual. Group Captives, on the other hand, are formed by a group of companies or individuals with similar interests.

There are several types of Group Captives available under Utah statutes. Here are a few examples:

The benefits of a Group Captive include access to specialized insurance coverage and the ability to control costs.

In Utah, captives are required to file an annual report with the commissioner before March 1 of each year. This report must be verified under oath by two of the executive officers.

The form of the report is specified by the commissioner, and it includes a "Captive Insurance Company Annual Statement Form" for pure captives, sponsored captives, industrial insured captives, and producer reinsurance captives.

For association captives and industrial insured captives, a report using the applicable NAIC Annual Statement Blank must be submitted to the commissioner annually.

In addition to the annual report, captives must also submit a Statement of Economic Benefit to the State of Utah and a Statement of Actuarial Opinion before March 1 of each year.

For another approach, see: Industrial and General Insurance Company

Each Utah captive is due for examination at least once every five years by the Utah Insurance Department, and the cost of that examination will be borne by the captive being examined.

Here is a summary of the annual filing requirements in Utah:

Utah has specific investment restrictions for certain types of captives. Association Captives, Sponsored Captives, and Industrial Insured Groups must comply with the same investment restrictions as traditional insurance companies.

These restrictions are outlined in Utah Code Annotated (U.C.A.) § 31A-18-105 and U.C.A. § 31A-18-106. A Pure Captive, on the other hand, has no restrictions on allowable investments, except that the Department will not allow investments that threaten the solvency of the captive.

Each captive insurer must file a description of their investment strategy as part of the initial application. This is a requirement for all captives, regardless of type. The captive must also notify the Department of any future changes to that investment strategy.

A Pure Captive may make loans to the parent company or an affiliate of the captive, but not from the minimum capitalization required by U.C.A. § 31A-37-204(1) and U.C.A. § 31A-37-205(1). It's essential to consult with tax advisors before making such loans.

An association captive insurance company is a type of captive insurance company owned by members of a common industry or trade association. It allows these members to share the risks of their industry among themselves.

A pure captive insurance company, on the other hand, insures only the risks of its parent and affiliated companies or controlled unaffiliated business. This is a key distinction to understand when considering the various types of captive insurance companies.

Some other types of captive insurance companies include the agency captive, which is controlled by an insurance agency or brokerage, and the industrial insured captive, which is owned by multiple, non-related organizations. These types of captives can be used to manage risks in various ways.

Here are some key types of captive insurance companies:

Group captives can be formed by either a homogeneous or a heterogeneous group of insureds. In a homogeneous group, the member/owners are engaged in the same or similar industries.

A homogeneous group doesn't necessarily mean all members have the same coverage needs. This is especially true when members operate in different areas of the country.

Members of a group captive may have varying sizes, ownership structures, or engage in slightly different aspects of the same basic industry. For example, a contracting firm that specializes in single-family residential construction may have different needs than one that builds office buildings.

It's impossible to design a one-size-fits-all captive, as there will be unavoidable differences of opinion on necessary limits, breadth of required coverage, and retention amounts.

Captives are not covered by guaranty funds, as they are prohibited from contributing financially to such funds.

In fact, captive insurance companies are specifically prohibited from contributing to plans, pools, associations, guaranty funds, or insolvency funds not covered by guaranty associations in Utah or elsewhere.

This means that captives are not eligible for the financial protection offered by guaranty funds, which can provide coverage for policyholders in the event of an insurer's insolvency.

A captive is a type of insurer that is owned by a single entity or group, and is typically used to insure the risks of that entity or group.

A Protected Cell Company is a type of captive insurance company that's particularly attractive to smaller organizations.

It consists of a core and an indefinite number of incorporated or unincorporated cell entities that are kept segregated from each other.

Each cell has its own dedicated assets and liabilities, which cannot be used to meet the liabilities of any other cell.

This setup allows companies to insure their own risk without establishing their own captive insurance company, making it a convenient risk management strategy.

Smaller organizations often find this type to be an efficient and convenient way to manage their risks.

A Special Purpose Captive Insurance Company is a type of captive insurance that doesn't fit into any other category. It's designated as such by the Commissioner.

It's essentially a structure that can be licensed as a Special Purpose Captive Insurance Company, similar to an agency or group captive. This type of company doesn't meet the definition of any other type of captive insurance company.

The North Carolina Captive Insurance Act defines different types of captives, but a Special Purpose Captive Insurance Company is a unique case. It's not a traditional captive insurance company, but rather a specialized one that meets specific requirements.

An association company is a type of captive insurer that's owned by members of a common industry or trade association. It's designed to share the risks of that industry among its members.

These captives are often formed to provide specialized insurance coverage that's tailored to the unique needs of the association's members. For example, an association of motorsports organizations might create a captive to provide liability insurance to regional members who host events.

Association captives can be formed in various states, including Utah, where they're regulated by the state's insurance department. In Utah, an association captive requires a minimum capital of $750,000, which is significantly higher than other types of captives.

Here are some key characteristics of association captives:

Association captives offer several benefits to their members, including the potential to reduce insurance costs and gain more control over their risk management. By pooling their resources, association members can share the costs and risks associated with insurance, making it more affordable and effective.

A captive insurance company is a type of insurer that's owned and controlled by a single entity, such as a corporation or association. This entity uses the captive to insure its own risks and those of its affiliates.

A captive can be formed for various purposes, including to reinsure related commercial insurance companies or to share the risks of a specific industry among its members. There are different types of captives, including pure captives, association captives, and industrial insured captives.

Some captives are formed to provide insurance coverage to high-risk industries or professions that would otherwise be difficult for a single-owner captive to write. Group captives can also offer catastrophic coverage limits that commercial markets may not be willing or able to provide.

Here are some examples of types of captives:

A captive insurance company has the potential to accumulate a significant amount of equity over time, allowing it to reduce the members' future total costs. This can be a significant advantage for companies that want to take financial control and manage risks by underwriting their own insurance.

Starting a captive insurance company can be a complex process, and it's essential to have the right team on board to ensure success.

Associations interested in pursuing the captive strategy need to work with a team of experts, including captive insurance and healthcare industry specialists, as well as actuarial, tax, and legal professionals.

The laws and details surrounding captive insurance companies can be intricate, making it crucial to have professionals who understand the nuances of the industry.

A captive insurance company will only provide the desired benefits if it's structured correctly and managed professionally.

The Hylant captive team has extensive experience helping association organizations develop effective and affordable captive programs.