
Churning credit cards is a strategy where individuals apply for multiple credit cards in a short period to take advantage of sign-up bonuses and other perks. This practice has gained popularity in recent years.
Credit card companies offer generous sign-up bonuses to attract new customers, often in the form of cashback, travel points, or other rewards. These bonuses can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars.
However, churning credit cards can have a negative impact on your credit score, especially if you're applying for multiple cards in a short period. This is because credit inquiries can make up a significant portion of your credit report.
To avoid this issue, it's essential to manage your credit card applications carefully and consider the potential impact on your credit score before applying.
For another approach, see: Does Having More Credit Cards Hurt Your Score
What is Churning Credit Cards
Credit card churning is a strategy where you apply for multiple credit cards in a short period, earn the introductory bonus, and then close the account before the annual fee kicks in. This can be a lucrative way to earn rewards, but it's not for everyone.
The key to successful churning is paying off balances before being charged interest. If you have a history of getting in over your head with credit cards, churning may be a recipe for trouble.
Churners beware: mortgage lenders don't like to see lots of opened and closed accounts on your credit history, so if you want to take out a home loan soon, churning isn't a good idea.
Many credit card issuers have updated their terms and conditions to stop or make churning harder and less lucrative. Some of these restrictions include the Chase 5/24 policy, which prohibits people who have opened five or more cards in the past two years from opening a new Chase consumer credit card.
To avoid these restrictions, you'll need to be organized and keep track of your spending requirements, due dates, and fee schedules. If you're not organized, things can go south quickly.
Some credit cards have rules that limit how many intro bonuses you can earn, such as American Express's once per lifetime policy or the one intro bonus every so many months rule.
Here are some examples of credit card churning restrictions:
Benefits and Drawbacks
Credit card churning can be a great way to earn rewards, but it's not without its risks. You could jeopardize your credit score by applying for multiple cards in a short period, which can lead to hard inquiries and a temporary dip in your credit score.
Frequent account openings can also lower the average age of your accounts, another factor that can negatively impact your credit score. Additionally, having too many credit cards can make it difficult to keep track of payments and rewards.
Here are some potential drawbacks to consider:
- Can negatively affect your credit: If you apply frequently for new cards, you will notice a dip in your credit score.
- Encourages high spending: Most credit card welcome offers include minimum spending requirements.
- Time-consuming: Credit card churning requires you to keep up with multiple credit card accounts to ensure you're making payments on time.
However, with careful planning and management, credit card churning can be a valuable strategy for earning rewards and saving money.
Pros
Credit card churning can be a great way to earn rewards, but it's essential to understand the benefits and drawbacks.
Earning points and miles quickly is one of the best advantages of credit card churning. Credit card welcome offers are the quickest way to accumulate points and miles, with some offers worth an international first-class plane ticket or free hotel nights at a luxury property.
For more insights, see: Chase Sapphire Points to United Miles
Most rewards credit cards offer additional benefits, including monthly or annual credits toward food, ride-hailing services, or streaming services. Complimentary airport lounge access is another sought-after perk.
Having multiple credit cards open can boost your credit score by increasing your overall credit limit, which may result in a lower credit utilization ratio.
Diversifying your points and miles currencies by earning points and miles on different cards provides flexibility, especially if you can transfer your points between rewards programs.
Here are some specific benefits of credit card churning:
- Earn points and miles quickly
- Receive other card benefits
- It may boost your credit score
- Diversify your points and miles currencies
By applying for new cards regularly, you can ensure your card strategy matches your lifestyle and take advantage of changing market conditions.
The Drawbacks of
Banks may close your accounts if they think you're gaming their program, and you'll forfeit your rewards in the process.
Closing your accounts can also damage your credit score, particularly if you have multiple credit cards and close them all at once.
You risk damaging your credit score by opening too many credit accounts in a short period, which can lead to a dip in your credit score due to hard credit inquiries.
Each hard inquiry can temporarily trim a few points off your credit score, and an inquiry remains on your credit report for up to two years.
Frequent account openings can signify desperation to lenders, making them worry that you're in financial distress and may not be able to pay back your debts.
Opening too many accounts can also lower the average age of your accounts, another factor that can drag down your credit score.
Having a lot of available credit can actually help you maintain a low credit utilization ratio, but only if you pay your bills on time and keep your debts low.
Most credit card welcome offers include minimum spending requirements, which can encourage high spending and isn't great for your finances.
Credit card churning requires you to keep up with multiple credit card accounts to ensure you're making payments on time, which can be time-consuming.
Here's a list of potential downsides to consider:
- Banks may close your accounts.
- The card issuer can take back your rewards.
- You risk damaging your credit.
- You could accrue debt.
- You could jeopardize future loan applications.
Strategies
Credit card churning is a strategy that involves opening and closing credit cards to maximize rewards and benefits.
You can earn valuable sign-up bonuses by applying for credit cards that offer them, like hotel credit cards with a sub-$100 annual fee.
The Chase ecosystem is a good place to start building your credit card portfolio, thanks to its 5/24 rule.
Make sure to choose cards that you can justify paying the annual fee for, and consider downgrading to a free version if you can't afford it.
Targeting a reward currency that's beneficial to you is a key part of a strategic approach to earning points and miles.
The Chase Trifecta, which includes cards with no application limits, is a good starting point for building your credit card portfolio.
To avoid impacting your credit score, make sure to only apply for cards that you plan to keep for the long term.
On a similar theme: Is Credit One Bank a Good Credit Card
Impact on Credit Score
Credit card churning can have a significant impact on your credit score. Each time you open a new card, your credit score can dip by about five to 10 points.
Multiple hard credit inquiries can lower your credit score, and carrying high balances from meeting bonus spending requirements can increase your credit utilization, further damaging your score.
You can expect to see a temporary dip in your credit score due to hard inquiries, which can stay on your credit report for up to two years.
Here are some key facts to keep in mind:
Closing credit cards can also ding you on two fronts: your credit utilization and your average age of accounts. Instead of closing a card you no longer use, it's typically better to simply stow it away in a sock drawer so that you retain both the credit line and history.
Issuer Restrictions and Application Process
Issuer restrictions are in place to prevent credit card churning, making it more challenging to churn. Many credit card companies have implemented measures to limit the number of cards you can open in a given period of time.
Chase's infamous 5/24 rule is a notable example, where you cannot have opened more than five cards across all banks in a 24-month period to qualify for certain cards. American Express limits you to five personal or business credit cards at a time.
Some card issuers have rules around canceling credit card accounts too soon. If you try to cancel your credit card accounts too soon, some card issuers have been known to take back any bonus points earned and not approve you for future cards. This can make it difficult to churn.
Here are some notable issuer restrictions around credit card sign-up bonuses:
Citi has a 48-month rule, where you won’t be eligible to get the bonus again for 48 months if you apply for a card now and then cancel later. Bank of America operates under the 2/3/4 rule, which limits the number of cards you can apply for within certain timeframes.
For another approach, see: 5 24 Rule Credit Cards
Banks Put Up Guardrails Against
Banks have implemented measures to prevent credit card churning, a practice where individuals apply for multiple credit cards in a short period to earn sign-up bonuses.
Chase has a rule called 5/24, which prevents you from opening a new Chase credit card account if you've opened more than five personal cards in the past 24 months.
American Express offers a welcome offer on most of its credit cards only once per person, once per lifetime, meaning you won't be eligible for a welcome offer if you've had a specific card previously.
Bank of America operates under the 2/3/4 rule, which limits you to two credit cards per rolling two months, three cards per rolling 12 months, and four cards per rolling 24 months.
Citi has a 48-month rule, where you won't be eligible to get the bonus again for 48 months if you apply for a card and then cancel later.
Here's a breakdown of some notable issuer restrictions around credit card sign-up bonuses:
Frequently Asked Questions
Is card churning illegal?
No, card churning is not illegal, but it can have negative consequences for your credit and future financial opportunities.
What is the 5 24 rule for credit card churning?
The 5/24 rule is a Chase credit card policy that prevents approval for most new accounts if you've opened 5 or more personal credit cards from any issuer in the past 24 months. This rule affects credit card churning, making it essential to understand before applying for new Chase cards.
Sources
- https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/credit-cards/credit-card-churning
- https://thepointsguy.com/credit-cards/credit-card-churning/
- https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/what-is-credit-card-churning/
- https://www.bankrate.com/credit-cards/advice/what-is-credit-card-churning-and-how-does-it-affect-your-credit-score/
- https://www.lendingtree.com/credit-cards/articles/churning/
Featured Images: pexels.com