
Retirement compensation arrangements can be a complex topic, but let's break it down simply. Employers have the option to offer a defined benefit plan, which guarantees a specific benefit amount to employees upon retirement. This type of plan is often more expensive for employers to maintain.
Employees, on the other hand, have the option to contribute to a 401(k) or other defined contribution plan, which allows them to save for retirement on a tax-deferred basis. Employers may also match a portion of employee contributions to encourage participation.
For more insights, see: Workers Compensation Employers Liability Coverage
How RCAs Work
RCAs offer a lot of flexibility, making them a great option for businesses. They're also creditor-proof, which means your employees' retirement savings are protected in case the company goes bankrupt.
One of the key benefits of an RCA is that it's exempt from payroll taxes. This can be a significant cost savings for employers.
Taxation only occurs at the time of withdrawal, and it depends on the employee's place of residency at that time. This means that taxes won't be withheld from contributions or earnings throughout the year.
Explore further: First Time Home Buyer Plan Rrsp

RCAs can take two main forms: a Defined Benefit Plan (DBP) or a Defined Contribution Plan (DCP). A DBP provides a yearly defined pension amount, while a DCP distributes only what was contributed, plus any earnings.
In a DBP, investment losses are borne by the employer, whereas in a DCP, the risk is transferred to the employees. To ensure a DBP is properly funded, actuaries must be involved.
Here are the main types of RCAs:
- Defined Benefit Plan (DBP)
- Defined Contribution Plan (DCP)
It's worth noting that RCAs can help reduce the amount of taxes paid by lowering the participant's tax rate. This can be a significant advantage for employees.
RCA Insights
Retirement compensation arrangements can be a game-changer for employees and employers alike.
In Canada, for example, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) allows employers to provide retirement compensation arrangements to their employees, which can help reduce tax liabilities.
These arrangements can be especially beneficial for high-income earners who may be subject to a higher tax rate in retirement.
Related reading: Individual Retirement Arrangements Iras News

The CRA has specific rules and guidelines for retirement compensation arrangements, which must be followed to avoid any tax implications.
Employers can contribute up to 18% of an employee's salary to a retirement compensation arrangement, with a maximum annual contribution limit of $25,500.
This can help employees save for retirement and reduce their tax burden.
The CRA also requires employers to report any contributions made to a retirement compensation arrangement on the employee's T4 slip.
This reporting requirement can help ensure that employees are aware of the contributions being made on their behalf.
Retirement compensation arrangements can be a valuable tool for employers looking to attract and retain top talent.
By providing a tax-efficient way for employees to save for retirement, employers can demonstrate their commitment to their employees' long-term financial well-being.
Here's an interesting read: Edible Arrangements Gluten Free
RCA Regulations
The regulations surrounding retirement compensation arrangements (RCAs) are quite complex, but I'll break it down for you.
RCAs are defined under subsection 248(1) of the Canadian Income Tax Act, which allows 100 per cent tax-deductible corporate dollars to be deposited into an RCA, on behalf of the private business owner and/or key employee.

To qualify as an RCA, contributions should not exceed what is required to fund the "entitlement" under the "generally accepted guidelines" for pensions. This means that the RCA should provide a normal level of benefits, which is typically around 2% x years of service x final three-year average earnings or about 70% of pre-retirement income for an employee with 35 years of service.
The entitlement calculation must be reviewed and recalculated periodically as circumstances change, such as salary, RRSP and RCA investment performance. Failure to follow the guidelines increases the risk that CRA could deem the RCA not to be an RCA, but rather a salary deferral arrangement (SDA) with substantial tax and penalties payable.
Here are the eligibility requirements for RCAs:
- On or after December 15, 1994, being required to contribute to the Superannuation Account or Public Service Pension Fund;
- On or after December 15, 1994, being required to contribute to the Canadian Forces Superannuation Account or the Canadian Forces Pension Fund;
- On or after December 15, 1994, being required to contribute to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Superannuation Account or the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Pension Fund;
- Being a deputy head with not less than 10 years of pensionable service and electing to become subject to the retirement compensation arrangement;
- Immediately before December 15, 1994, being deemed by section 14 of the Public Service Superannuation Act to be employed in the public service.
RCA Setup
To set up a retirement compensation arrangement, you'll need to meet certain eligibility criteria. If you're a deputy head with at least 10 years of pensionable service, you can elect to participate before leaving the public service.

The arrangement is established for individuals who are required to contribute to specific funds, such as the Superannuation Account or the Canadian Forces Pension Fund, as of December 15, 1994. There are also specific rules for deputy heads who have a certain amount of pensionable service.
To be eligible, you must meet one of the following conditions:
- (a) You're required to contribute to the Superannuation Account or Public Service Pension Fund on or after December 15, 1994.
- (b) You're required to contribute to the Canadian Forces Superannuation Account or the Canadian Forces Pension Fund on or after December 15, 1994.
- (c) You're required to contribute to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Superannuation Account or the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Pension Fund on or after December 15, 1994.
- (d) You're a deputy head with at least 10 years of pensionable service and elect to participate before leaving the public service.
- (e) You were deemed to be employed in the public service before December 15, 1994.
Investment Account
The investment account is managed by plan trustees and directed by the company or the principal plan member.
Investments in the account are relatively unrestricted, but it's a good idea to stick with non-distributing investments.
50% of all dividends, realized capital gains, and interest income less expenses must be remitted annually to the RTA.
This means you'll need to keep track of your account's income and expenses to ensure you're meeting this obligation.
For another approach, see: Reits for Retirement Income
No Required Date
One of the most attractive features of an RCA is the flexibility it offers. You can begin withdrawals at any age you choose, provided you've had a change in employment status.

This means you're not locked into a specific retirement date, like you would be with a Registered Plan. You can take control of your finances and make decisions that work best for you.
With an RCA, you can withdraw funds at any time, as long as you've had a change in employment status. This gives you the freedom to make choices about your financial future.
Here are some key facts to keep in mind:
- No required retirement date
- Withdrawals can begin at any age, provided there's a change in employment status
- Assets can remain in the Trust Fund throughout the lifetime of the member
- Subsequent withdrawals can be made for the benefit of spouses and beneficiaries
Designation of Arrangement
The designation of arrangement is a crucial aspect of setting up a retirement compensation arrangement (RCA). It's designated under section 15 of the Act.
For the purposes of section 15, the retirement compensation arrangement is a designated arrangement. This means it meets specific requirements and is subject to certain regulations.
The designation of arrangement has undergone changes over the years, with notable updates in 1997, 2002, and 2016. These updates have refined the requirements and regulations for designated arrangements.
Here are the key updates to the designation of arrangement:
- SOR/97-520, s. 1
- SOR/2002-73, ss. 2, 33
- SOR/2016-156, ss. 4, 11(E)
These updates have helped to clarify the designation of arrangement and ensure that RCAs are set up in compliance with the Act.
Establishment of Arrangement

To establish an RCA, you must meet certain eligibility criteria. Specifically, you must be required to contribute to one of the following accounts or funds: the Superannuation Account, the Public Service Pension Fund, the Canadian Forces Superannuation Account, the Canadian Forces Pension Fund, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Superannuation Account, or the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Pension Fund.
If you're a deputy head with at least 10 years of pensionable service under the Public Service Superannuation Act, you can elect to become subject to the RCA before you cease being employed in the public service.
The RCA is established for the payment of benefits to or in respect of any person who meets one of the following conditions: they're required to contribute to one of the specified accounts or funds on or after December 15, 1994, or they were deemed to be employed in the public service immediately before December 15, 1994.
Explore further: Fidelity Managed Retirement 2025 Fund

Here are the specific eligibility conditions for establishing an RCA:
RCA Contributions
RCA contributions can be made by both the employer and the employee, but it's essential to understand the tax implications.
Employer contributions are tax-deductible and subject to a 50 per cent withholding tax, which is refundable. This means that if the employer contributes $1, they can recover $0.50 in taxes.
The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) will accept deductions that recognize years of service in previous years, allowing for significant contributions to the plan when the RCA is first created.
Contribution Amounts
Contribution amounts can greatly impact the effectiveness of an RCA. A reasonable Defined Contribution Plan (DCP) contribution is 18 per cent, which is the amount used to create yearly RRSP deduction room.
Contributions above this amount may be considered unreasonable, as it could result in the plan being recategorized as a salary deferral arrangement, which may lead to immediate tax liabilities for the employee.
Explore further: Australian Retirement Trust Voluntary Contribution
The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) will accept deductions that recognize years of service in previous years, which can result in significant contributions to the plan when the RCA is first created.
A certain amount needs to be accessible within the Defined Benefit Plan (DBP) program to fund future pension obligations, and the future pension amount must be deemed reasonable. This amount depends on various factors specific to each company.
Here are some key contribution amount considerations:
It's essential to consult with a tax advisor to determine the appropriate contribution amounts for your RCA, as tax liabilities could arise if the plan doesn't meet certain tax criteria.
Withdrawals
Upon retirement or a change of employment status, the beneficiary will draw from the assets of the RCA Trust.
Withdrawals are flexible and not subject to any restrictions on maximum or minimums.
Withholding tax applies to withdrawals at a rate of 30% if located in Canada.
Money contributed at today's tax rates may be withdrawn in the future at lower rates, depending on current rates decreasing or the beneficiary moving to a lower tax jurisdiction.
RCA Types

RCAs can take the form of a Defined Benefit Plan (DBP) or a Defined Contribution Plan (DCP). A DBP provides employees with a yearly defined pension amount, whenever they retire.
In a DBP scenario, investment losses are borne by the employer. This means the employer takes on the risk of market fluctuations.
A DCP, on the other hand, will only distribute what was contributed to the plan, plus whatever has been earned. This means employees take on the risk of investment losses.
Actuaries need to be involved with a DBP to ensure the plan is funded properly.
Expand your knowledge: Buying Gold for Retirement
RCA Planning
An RCA can be a flexible and creditor-proof way to save for retirement, with the ability to reduce the amount of taxes paid by lowering the participant's tax rate. This can result in significant savings over time.
One of the key benefits of an RCA is that it's exempt from payroll taxes, which can save the business owner and/or key employee a substantial amount of money. This can be especially beneficial for those who are self-employed or have a high income.

RCAs can take the form of a Defined Benefit Plan (DBP) or a Defined Contribution Plan (DCP), both of which have their own unique characteristics. A DBP provides employees with a yearly defined pension amount, while a DCP distributes only what was contributed to the plan, plus any earnings.
To qualify as an RCA, the plan must adhere to the "generally accepted guidelines" for pensions, which dictate that contributions should not exceed what's required to fund the "entitlement" under the plan. This entitlement is typically calculated using the "integrated final earnings" method.
An RCA can be funded using various investments, including securities, mutual funds, and life insurance. This provides business owners and key employees with a range of options to choose from when it comes to investing their retirement savings.
Here are the key guidelines to follow when setting up an RCA:
- Contributions should not exceed what's required to fund the "entitlement" under the plan.
- The entitlement should be calculated using the "integrated final earnings" method.
- The plan should be reviewed and recalculated periodically as circumstances change.
By following these guidelines, business owners and key employees can ensure that their RCA is properly set up and will provide the desired benefits in retirement.
RCA for Employers
As an employer, setting up a retirement compensation arrangement (RCA) can be a great way to attract and retain top talent. RCAs offer flexibility for both you and your employees.
One of the key benefits of an RCA is that it's creditor-proof, meaning that your employees' contributions are protected in case of bankruptcy or other financial difficulties.
An RCA also allows you to exempt your employees from payroll taxes, which can be a significant cost savings for both you and your employees.
By lowering your employees' tax rate, you can also reduce the amount of taxes they pay, which can help increase their take-home pay.
Taxation of an RCA only occurs at the time of withdrawal, which means that your employees won't have to pay taxes on their contributions while they're still working.
The tax implications of an RCA depend on your employees' place of residency at the time of withdrawal, so it's essential to consider this when setting up your RCA.

Here are some key benefits of an RCA at a glance:
RCA for Employees
RCAs can be used to assist employers in retaining employees considered key to the business, as these employees must stay on board for a certain length of time before contributions vest.
Employers can provide a retirement package using Retirement Compensation Arrangements (RCAs), which can be a more cost-effective option than a Retirement Pension Plan (RPP) or Individual Pension Plan (IPP).
Employees must stay with the company for a certain length of time before contributions vest, providing a strong incentive for employers to retain key staff.
RCAs can help employers keep their top talent on board, which is especially important for businesses that rely on a few key employees to drive success.
Recommended read: Tax Deferred Pension and Retirement Savings Plans on 1040
Frequently Asked Questions
What is compensation for retirement plans?
For retirement plans, compensation is typically defined as an employee's W-2 wages minus certain reimbursements and benefits. This calculation helps determine the amount eligible for retirement plan contributions.
Who is an ideal candidate for an RCA?
Ideal candidates for an RCA are high-income earners, typically those with incomes over $150,000, such as business owners, executives, and incorporated professionals. They're looking to maintain their lifestyle in retirement.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retirement_compensation_arrangements
- https://gblinc.ca/products-services/business-owners/retirement-compensation/
- https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/sor-94-785/page-1.html
- https://rsmcanada.com/insights/services/business-tax-insights/all-about-retirement-compensation-arrangements.html
- https://cardinalpointwealth.com/2018/12/15/retirement-compensation-arrangements-are-they-right-for-you/
Featured Images: pexels.com