Private equity fees charged to portfolio companies can be a complex and often misunderstood topic. Typically, these fees are a percentage of the company's EBITDA, with a range of 1-3% being common.
Private equity firms often charge a management fee, which can be a flat rate or a percentage of the fund's size. For example, a fund with $1 billion in assets under management might charge a 1.5% management fee, resulting in a $15 million annual fee.
One of the most significant fees charged to portfolio companies is the carried interest, which can range from 20-30% of the fund's profits. This means that if the fund generates a $100 million profit, the private equity firm might take home $20-30 million as carried interest.
Private equity firms also charge transaction fees, which can range from 1-3% of the deal size. These fees are typically paid by the portfolio company.
Intriguing read: Hedge Fund vs Private Equity vs Venture Capital
Private Equity Fees
Private equity funds have a fee structure similar to hedge funds, consisting of a management fee and a performance fee.
Here's an interesting read: Taxation of Private Equity and Hedge Funds
Typically, private equity firms charge annual management fees of around 2% of the committed capital of the fund, which can be a significant amount. A $2-billion fund charging a 2% management fee results in the firm earning $40 million every year.
The performance fee is usually in the region of 20% of profits from investments, and this fee is referred to as carried interest in the world of private investment funds.
This carried interest is only earned after the investors have received their capital back, plus a minimum percentage rate of return, typically set at around 8%.
The distribution waterfall specifies the carried interest percentage that the general partner will earn, and also outlines the order in which proceeds from asset sales are distributed between the GP and the LPs.
Recommended read: Private Equity Fund
Equity Basics
Private equity is an investment class that acquires ownership of or an interest in private companies. It's composed of funds and investors that directly invest in these companies.
Recommended read: Why Do Companies Outsource
Private equity firms work to increase the value of the companies they invest in by providing capital, operational guidance, or other expertise. They aim to sell their ownership or interest in the company at a profit.
Private equity firms typically charge a management fee of around 2% of the committed capital of the fund, which can be a significant portion of the firm's earnings. A $2-billion fund charging a 2% management fee results in the firm earning $40 million every year.
For another approach, see: Pledge Fund
What Is Equity?
Equity is a type of investment that involves acquiring ownership or an interest in a private company.
Private equity firms are the ones that directly invest in these private companies, and they work to increase the value of the companies by providing capital, operation guidance, or other expertise.
To invest in private equity, you need to commit significant amounts of capital over a long time frame, which is why investors in this type of asset are usually institutions or accredited with a high net worth.
Private equity firms may also engage in buyouts of public companies with the intention of taking them private, and then sell their ownership or interest in the company at a profit.
For more insights, see: Property Preservation Companies Charge
Equity Performance Basics
Private equity funds have a fee structure similar to hedge funds, consisting of a management fee and a performance fee. The management fee is around 2% of the committed capital of the fund, which can be a significant amount, as seen in a $2-billion fund earning $40 million every year.
The performance fee, also known as carried interest, is usually around 20% of profits from investments. This fee is only paid after the investors have received their capital back, plus some element of return on capital, typically around 8%.
Asset sales in private equity funds occur over a period of years, making it impossible to know the overall investment appreciation until all assets have been sold. The waterfall schedule determines how the proceeds of asset sales will be distributed between the fund manager and the investors.
If the fund manager receives more of the sales proceeds than their prescribed share, a 'clawback' provision requires them to return part of their performance fees to the investors. This ensures that the fund manager's earnings are aligned with the investors' interests.
Private equity firms charge annual management fees, which can lead to situations where the management fee earnings exceed the performance-based earnings, raising concerns about the fairness of the fee structure.
Take a look at this: Performance Fee
Portfolio Company
Private equity firms typically charge a management fee to their portfolio companies, which can range from 1.5% to 2.5% of the company's EBITDA per year. This fee is usually paid quarterly or annually.
These fees can add up quickly, and in some cases, they can even exceed the company's net income. For example, a company with $100 million in EBITDA and a 2% management fee would pay $2 million per year.
Portfolio companies may also be charged a monitoring fee, which can range from $50,000 to $200,000 per year. This fee is often paid to cover the costs of monitoring and advising the company.
In addition to these fees, private equity firms may also charge a performance fee, which is typically a percentage of the company's profits. This fee can range from 15% to 25% of the company's EBITDA.
Readers also liked: Which of the following Best Describes a Company's Business Portfolio?
Compliance and Tax
Carried interest tax rate controversy surrounds the fact that fund managers' management fee income is taxed at income tax rates, the highest of which is 37%.
The tax code provision that makes long-term capital gains relatively low was intended to spur investment, but critics argue it's a loophole that unfairly benefits fund managers.
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 slightly addressed this loophole by requiring investment funds to hold assets for more than three years for carried interest to be taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate.
If assets are held for three years or less, gains allocated to investment managers are treated as short-term gains, taxed at up to 40.8% including tax on net investment income.
Taxing carried interest at ordinary rates could generate about $180 billion, according to law professor Victor Fleischer's estimate.
Equity Regulation
Private equity regulation has undergone significant changes in recent years. The modern private equity industry has operated largely unregulated since its emergence in the 1940s.
The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act was signed into federal law in 2010, marking a major shift in regulation. This law was drafted to address the problems that contributed to the financial crisis of 2008.
Prior to Dodd-Frank, general partners in private equity funds had exempted themselves from the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. This exemption allowed them to avoid registration with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as long as they had fewer than 15 clients.
Dodd-Frank erased this "private adviser exemption" and requires all private equity firms with more than $150 million in assets to register with the SEC as "Investment Advisers." Registration with the SEC began in 2012.
Private equity funds are now required to report information about their size, services offered, investors, employees, and potential conflicts of interest. This increased transparency is a key aspect of the new regulatory landscape.
Widespread Compliance Violations
Widespread Compliance Violations have been uncovered in the private equity industry. The SEC has found that many private equity firms pass on fees to clients without their knowledge.
The SEC has highlighted the need for the industry to improve disclosure. This is a critical issue that requires attention.
Andrew Bowden, the former director of the SEC’s Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations, made a striking observation in 2014. He said that examiners have identified violations of law or material weaknesses in controls over fees and expenses in more than 50% of the firms they examined.
Compliance staffing at both small and large private equity firms has grown significantly to adapt to the post-Dodd-Frank regulatory environment. This is a response to the increasing scrutiny and expectations from regulatory bodies.
Explore further: Top Middle Market Private Equity Firms
Carried Interest Tax Rate
Carried interest is taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income, but that rate has been a subject of controversy. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 curtailed some of the tax advantages enjoyed by carried interest.
Investment funds must hold assets for more than three years for carried interest to be taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate. If the assets have been held for three years or less, then any gains are treated as short-term gains.
Recommended read: Internal Rate of Return Private Equity
Taxing carried interest at ordinary rates would generate about $180 billion, according to law professor Victor Fleischer. This highlights the significant revenue that could be raised by closing this tax loophole.
The long-term capital gains rate is much lower than the highest income tax rate, which is 37%. This has led to criticism that fund managers are paying an unfairly small tax rate on much of their earnings.
Fee Structure and Incentives
Private equity fees charged to portfolio companies are often tied to the fund's performance, creating an alignment of interests between the fund manager and investors. This is achieved through a combination of management fees and performance fees, also known as carried interest.
Fund managers charge a management fee, typically 2% of the investment, to cover expenses and administrative responsibilities. This fee is charged annually and is paid regardless of the fund's performance.
A performance fee, or carried interest, is a percentage of the profits generated by the fund. This fee is typically 20% of the profits and is only paid if the fund manager successfully invests and divests a profit-generating investment.
For your interest: Why Am I Being Charged a Cash Advance Fee
The performance fee is structured so that fund managers keep 20% of all profits generated if they deliver at least an 8% net annual return to investors. This means that if the fund generates a 15% net return, the manager is entitled to 20% of the profits, or €1,400 in this example.
The industry-wide expression “2 & 20” refers to the market standard for private equity funds charging a 2% management fee and 20% performance fee to investors. This fee structure has been widely adopted across the private equity industry as a way to achieve a compensation plan for GPs that aligns their interests with those of the LPs.
Here is a breakdown of the typical fee structure:
Note that the performance fee is only paid if the fund manager successfully invests and divests a profit-generating investment, and that investors receive their capital back, plus some element of return on capital, typically set at around 8%, before the fund manager can start to share in the profits.
Performance and Returns
Private equity funds use a performance fee structure to incentivize fund managers to maximize investment value.
This performance fee is taken from the proceeds of asset sales, following a predetermined waterfall schedule outlined in the investment agreement.
Investors receive their capital back, plus an 8% return on capital, before fund managers can participate in profits.
Fund managers then receive distributions until they've caught up with their percentage of carried interest, typically 20%.
As asset sales occur over time, the overall investment appreciation can't be known until all assets are sold.
The investment agreement includes a clawback provision, requiring fund managers to return part of their performance fees if they receive more than their prescribed share.
Private equity fund managers are paid through annual management fees and profit-sharing arrangements aligned with fund performance.
Investors pay higher fees when performance is good, unlike passive public markets strategies where fees are paid regardless of performance.
Gross returns to investors are reduced by fees, but private equity funds have historically exceeded public equity benchmarks in net returns.
Investors can use measures like Multiple on invested capital (MOIC) and Internal rate of return (IRR) to compare private and public equity returns on a net after-fee basis.
Private equity is an active investment management strategy, making it more expensive for investors, but potentially generating outsized returns.
For another approach, see: Private Equity Returns vs Public Markets
Sources
- https://www.moonfare.com/blog/private-equity-fees
- https://www.roycgroup.com/post/demystifying-private-equity-fees---what-are-you-paying-for-and-why
- https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/072115/private-equity-management-fees-regulation.asp
- https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2016/01/13/private-equity-portfolio-company-fees/
- https://icapital.com/insights/private-equity/an-explanation-of-private-market-fund-fees/
Featured Images: pexels.com