How Does Preferred Equity Work: A Comprehensive Overview

Preferred equity is a type of financing that allows investors to participate in a project's potential gains while minimizing their risk.

It's often used in real estate development, where investors provide capital to a project in exchange for a preferred return on their investment.

In this type of financing, investors are typically paid a fixed rate of return, usually in the form of dividends, before the project's equity holders receive any distributions.

This structure provides a predictable income stream for investors, making it an attractive option for those seeking a relatively low-risk investment opportunity.

Curious to learn more? Check out: Preferred Return Private Equity

Preferred equity is a type of financing that gives investors a higher claim on assets than common stockholders in the event of liquidation.

It essentially represents a hybrid of debt and equity, offering a higher return than traditional debt but with less risk than common stock.

Preferred equity investors are typically paid a fixed dividend or interest rate, which can range from 5-12% per annum.

Consider reading: Common Equity vs Preferred Equity

This type of financing is often used in real estate investments, where it can provide a steady income stream for investors.

In a real estate investment, preferred equity investors may receive a fixed dividend of 8% per annum, paid quarterly or annually.

The dividend amount can be adjusted based on the performance of the investment, such as a 10% increase in property value.

Preferred equity investors usually don't have voting rights, which means they have no say in the decision-making process of the company.

However, they may have some degree of control over the company's operations, such as the right to approve major transactions.

Worth a look: Preferred Equity Real Estate Term Sheet

Preferred equity works by giving investors a claim on assets and dividends, but not control over the company. This can be beneficial for some investors who prioritize regular income over potential long-term growth.

Investors buying preferred shares can realize some advantages, such as a higher claim on assets and dividends in case of liquidation or bankruptcy.

Preferred equity comes in various forms, each with its own set of characteristics.

Convertible preferred stock allows the holder to receive either the preferred proceeds or the post-conversion equity value, whichever is of greater value. This gives the investor a chance to receive higher returns.

Participating preferred stock, on the other hand, allows the investor to receive both the preferred proceeds and a portion of the residual proceeds for common equity shareholders, essentially giving them a chance to "double-dip" in the exit proceeds.

Here are the basic types of preferred stocks:

Convertible preferred stock is a type of preferred equity investment structure that allows the holder to receive either the preferred proceeds or the post-conversion equity value, whichever is of greater value. This structure is often chosen because it brings higher returns to the investment firm.

The convertible value of preferred stock equals the implied ownership multiplied by the exit proceeds. This means that if the exit equity value is less than the preferred investment, the investors cannot receive the initial amount back in full.

Check this out: What Is Convertible Preferred Stock

In practice, convertible preferred stock comes with a pre-negotiated conversion ratio, which determines the number of common shares received per preferred share upon conversion. This conversion ratio is crucial in calculating the number of convertible common shares.

The conversion price can be calculated by dividing the par value of the convertible preferred stock by the number of common shares that could be received. For example, if the par value is $100 million and the conversion ratio is 20%, the conversion price would be $5 per common share.

Once past the break-even point, convertible shares are considered “in-the-money” and profitable to convert. This break-even point is typically an exit valuation in excess of $500 million, which is 5x the initial investment.

Here's a brief summary of the key characteristics of convertible preferred stock:

In the example given, the convertible value is $200 million, which represents a 2.0x multiple on invested capital (MOIC). This means that for every dollar invested, the investor receives $2 in return.

Soft pay terms are more acceptable to lenders because they don't require the operating entity to make payments if there's no cash flow.

In a soft pay scenario, preferred equity holders may not have punitive remedies if payments are missed, but they can still require the sponsor or operating entity to make payments when there's sufficient cash flow.

Hard pay, on the other hand, functions more like a debt instrument, where non-payment can lead to remedies such as wiping out subordinate equity and taking over control of the partnership interest.

Soft pay terms also allow for a preferred interest reserve to be set aside, which preferred equity holders can be paid out of, even if common equity holders receive distributions first.

Preferred equity offers a unique investment opportunity with attractive returns. In fact, it's not uncommon for preferred equity to earn double-digit returns in today's real estate climate.

One of the key benefits of preferred equity is that it allows investors to be repaid sooner than common equity shareholders, reducing their risk in case a deal goes sideways. This is because preferred equity investors collect their share of the project profits ahead of common shareholders earning their dividends.

For another approach, see: Preferred Stock Has Preference over Common Stock in the _____.

The returns from preferred equity can be significant. For example, in a scenario where the exit value falls to $50mm from an initial valuation of $500mm, the convertible value is $10mm, while the preferred value is $50mm. This reflects the downside protection of preferred stock.

The multiple on invested capital (MOIC) is another important metric to consider. For instance, if the exit proceeds are $1bn, the convertible value is $200mm, which represents a 2.0x MOIC. This means that the investor has doubled their initial investment.

Here's a comparison of the MOIC for convertible and participating preferred stock investments:

As you can see, participating preferred stock investments tend to outpace the returns earned on convertible preferred investments. However, it's worth noting that companies often limit the percentage share of proceeds that preferred investors have in common shareholders, and/or place a liquidation preference cap on the return multiple to prevent investors from generating returns beyond a certain level.

Preferred equity can be a powerful tool in venture investing, but it's essential to understand its unique characteristics. Preferred equity offers greater protection and priority in the event of an exit event.

One of the key benefits of preferred equity is that it shares characteristics with debt instruments, making it an attractive option for investors. This is because preferred stock often has a fixed-income payment, which can be higher than what bonds offer.

Preferred stock also has a callable feature, which allows the issuing corporation to cancel outstanding shares for cash. This can be a significant advantage for the corporation, but it may not be ideal for investors.

Corporations that receive dividends on preferred stock can deduct a portion of the income from their corporate taxes. The exact amount can vary, but it's typically between 50% to 65%.

Here are some key features of preferred equity:

Investors and issuers have distinct considerations when it comes to preferred stock. Preferred stock is attractive to investors as it typically offers higher fixed-income payments than bonds with a lower investment per share.

Preferred stockholders have a priority claim over common stocks for dividend payments and liquidation proceeds, making it a more stable investment option. Its price is usually more stable than common stock, and it's more liquid than corporate bonds of similar quality.

Individual investors may not be eligible for the same tax treatment as institutions, but that shouldn't exclude preferreds from their consideration as a viable investment. The dividends received deduction can be a significant advantage for institutions, allowing them to deduct up to 65% of the income from their taxes if they own more than 20% of the dividend payer.

Issuers may appreciate the flexibility in payments offered by preferred stock, as preferred dividends can be suspended in case of corporate cash problems. However, issuers do not receive an immediate tax deduction for the income paid on preferred stock.

Here are some key differences between investors and issuers:

Preferred stock is an attractive investment option for many reasons. It typically offers higher fixed-income payments than bonds, with a lower investment per share. This makes it a great choice for those looking for a steady income stream.

One of the key benefits of preferred stock is its priority claim over common stock for dividend payments and liquidation proceeds. This means that preferred stockholders are essentially guaranteed to receive their dividends before common stockholders.

Its price is usually more stable than common stock, making it a less volatile investment. This stability is due in part to the fact that preferred stock often has a fixed dividend rate.

Preferred stock is also more liquid than corporate bonds of similar quality. This means that investors can easily buy and sell preferred stock, making it a more accessible investment option.

Institutional investors, such as corporations, can benefit from a tax advantage when investing in preferred stock. The IRS allows them to deduct up to 50% of the income from their taxes if they own less than 20% of the dividend payer. If they own more than 20%, they can deduct 65%.

Additional reading: Preferred Stock Usually Carries a Preference for Dividends Meaning That

As an issuer, you'll want to consider the benefits and drawbacks of preferred stock. Preferred stock offers flexibility in payments to issuers, which can be a plus in times of corporate cash problems.

One of the advantages of preferred stock is that it's easier to market. Typically, institutional investors buy and hold it, making it simpler to sell during an initial public offering.

However, there are some trade-offs to consider. Preferred stock often has a callable feature that allows the issuing corporation to cancel outstanding shares for cash, which can limit investors' potential for future price appreciation.

This callable feature also means that the maturity date is not specified, leaving uncertainty about the recovery of the invested principal.

Investing in real estate can be a smart move, especially when you consider the benefits. It's a way of investing in real estate without taking on the responsibility of direct ownership.

Preferred equity is a great option for investors who want to shoulder less risk. This is because preferred equity investors get repaid sooner than common equity shareholders.

In today's real estate climate, prices have continued to climb, making preferred equity a highly attractive opportunity. It's not uncommon for preferred equity to earn double-digit returns.

Here's an interesting read: A Few Consideration When Investing for Preferred Stock Equity

Preferred stock can provide a steady income stream, which is beneficial for individual and institutional investors alike.

Individual and institutional investors can both benefit from the steady income that they can be paid.

Institutions may receive a highly attractive tax advantage in the dividends received deduction on that income that individuals do not.

Preferred stockholders typically have a higher claim on assets and dividends than common stockholders, making it a more secure investment.

The tax advantage for institutions can make preferred stock an even more attractive investment option for them.

The American Institute of CPAs (AICPA) and International Private Equity and Venture Capital Valuation Guidelines (IPEV) have issued guidance to harmonise views of industry participants, auditors, and valuation specialists.

These guidelines suggest that amounts accruing to each financial instrument should be reflected and liquidation preferences should be reviewed for impact on investment value.

The Current Value Method (CVM) allocates equity value to different classes of preferred equity based on their liquidation preferences or conversion values as at today.

Readers also liked: What Is Equity Valuation

This method is appropriate when a liquidity event is imminent.

The Option Pricing Model (OPM) models the expected future cash flows of the enterprise and the expected future payoffs of the different classes of preferred equity using OPM.

This method is appropriate when the future of the enterprise as a going concern is relevant.

The Scenario-based Method involves creating a range of explicit future outcomes for a company and assigning probabilities to each outcome.

This method is useful when valuing equity interests in a portfolio company that is expected to have an exit event in the near future.

The Fully Diluted Method assumes that all classes of shares are the same, which may not always be the case.

This method is sometimes used as a simplified assumption where the value of the business has significantly exceeded the liquidation preference and there is no meaningful expectation that the liquidation preference will be used.

Here are the key methods suggested by the guidelines:

Consideration of each approach and which is relevant given the facts and circumstances of the investment being held is key to ensuring that an appropriate valuation is derived.