Hipaa Violation Lawsuit: Understanding the Consequences

Author

Reads 184

Close-Up View of System Hacking in a Monitor
Credit: pexels.com, Close-Up View of System Hacking in a Monitor

A Hipaa violation lawsuit can be a serious matter, with severe consequences for individuals and organizations involved. The fines for non-compliance with HIPAA regulations can be substantial, ranging from $100 to $50,000 per violation, with a maximum penalty of $1.5 million per year.

The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is responsible for enforcing HIPAA regulations and can impose fines for violations. In addition to fines, a Hipaa violation lawsuit can also result in reputational damage and loss of patient trust.

The HHS can also impose civil monetary penalties for willful neglect of HIPAA regulations, which can be up to $50,000 per violation. This highlights the importance of taking HIPAA compliance seriously and having proper policies and procedures in place.

Types of HIPAA Violations

Accessing patient files without authorization is a serious HIPAA violation, even if the information is not used for any wrong reasons. This includes doctors or healthcare staff accessing health records without patient consent.

Credit: youtube.com, Another Example of a HIPAA Violation Lawsuit

Sharing PHI using non-secure methods, such as texting, video conferencing applications, phone calls, personal emails, and common file-sharing services, is also a HIPAA violation. This leaves patient information vulnerable to security breaches and attacks.

Posting PHI on social media, including online reviews and rating platforms, is strictly prohibited and considered an unauthorized disclosure of PHI.

What Is Considered

Accessing patient files without authorization is a HIPAA violation, even if the information is not used for any wrong reasons. This includes doctors and healthcare staff accessing health records without patient consent.

Sharing patient information using non-secure methods, such as texting, video conferencing, or personal emails, is also a HIPAA violation, as it puts patient data at risk of security breaches.

Collecting sensitive health information and sharing it with third-party companies, like Facebook, can be a HIPAA violation, especially if it includes identifiable health information like IP addresses.

Unauthorized access to patient records can lead to severe consequences, including prison time and fines, as seen in the case of Dr. H, who was charged with HIPAA and served four months in jail with a $2000 fine.

If this caught your attention, see: Medical Information Bureau Mib

Improper E-PHI Disposal

Credit: youtube.com, 10 Common HIPAA Violations to Avoid in 2022

Improper E-PHI disposal can be a costly mistake. Failing to securely dispose of patient information can result in expensive violation fines.

Medical institutions must remove expired or unnecessary patient records permanently and securely. Secure disposal means the information should not be readable or accessible, whether it's digital or paper records.

Shredding or pulping can be used to dispose of hard copies, while degaussing, physically destroying portable devices, or data wiping may be used for e-PHI.

Consequences of HIPAA Violations

A HIPAA violation can have serious consequences, including steep fines and even jail time. Individuals can face HIPAA violation fines from $50,000 to $250,000, plus restitution for willfully violating rules.

If you're a healthcare provider, you've likely heard of the Minnesota Health Records Act, which outlines specific violations, including releasing medical records to unauthorized third parties without consent. This can lead to civil fines for individuals starting at $100 and up to $25,000 for multiple infractions.

If your medical records or sensitive information has been disclosed without your consent, you may be entitled to monetary damages to compensate you for the harm caused by the disclosure.

Is a Crime?

Credit: youtube.com, HIPAA violations: What are the consequences?

A HIPAA violation is a serious offense that can have severe consequences. Yes, a HIPAA violation is a crime, and individuals can face stiff penalties.

Even seemingly minor infractions can result in significant fines. HIPAA violation fines for willfully violating rules can range from $50,000 to $250,000, plus restitution.

Individuals can also face jail time for HIPAA violations. Jail time for willful HIPAA violations can be up to ten years.

Civil fines for HIPAA violations by individuals start at $100 and can be as high as $25,000 for multiple infractions.

Minnesota Health Records Lawyer

In Minnesota, patients have extra protections for their health care records thanks to the Minnesota Health Records Act, which provides additional privacy safeguards beyond the federal HIPAA law.

If a healthcare provider in Minnesota discloses a patient's medical records without consent, the patient can sue them for negligence or intentional release of sensitive information.

Minnesota patients have the right to keep their medical records private, and healthcare providers must respect that right.

Credit: youtube.com, Does HIPAA Prevent the Disclosure of Medical Records and Mental Health Records? | Learn About Law

Healthcare providers in Minnesota must follow the state's health care records privacy law, which prohibits them from disclosing sensitive medical information without a patient's permission.

If a healthcare provider in Minnesota fails to protect patient records, they may face lawsuits and other consequences under the Minnesota Health Records Act.

The Minnesota Health Records Act provides patients with more protection for their health care records than the federal HIPAA law, making it a crucial law for patients in the state to know about.

Additional reading: Hipaa Law in Nj

Reporting and Notification

Reporting a HIPAA violation is a crucial step in protecting sensitive information and preventing further harm. You can report a HIPAA violation to HHS through their online complaint portal.

To report a HIPAA violation anonymously, you can download the complaint form and mail it to OCR without your contact information, but this may result in no action taken against the covered entity. Stipulating that OCR keeps your information private is a better option, as it protects you from potential backlash.

Credit: youtube.com, HIPAA Breach Reporting: Protecting Patient Information in Healthcare

The HIPAA Breach Notification rule requires covered entities to notify affected parties without delay and within 60 days of discovering a breach. This includes providing details about the type of information leaked, protective measures taken, and contact information.

Delaying breach notification can incur substantial fines, as seen in the case of OSU-CHS, which paid $875,000 for failing to provide notification in a timely manner. The breach was initially reported to have occurred on November 7, 2017, but it was later revealed that it began on March 9, 2016.

Breaches that demand reporting under HIPAA involve unsecured PHI accessed in a way that violates the privacy rule. Business associates and individuals must report breaches to covered entities within 60 days, and covered entities have 60 days to report breaches involving fewer than 500 records to HHS.

Prevention and Compliance

Providing sufficient HIPAA compliance training to employees is a crucial step in avoiding HIPAA violations. This training should cover areas such as authorization requirements, discussing patient information, and protecting digital PHI.

Credit: youtube.com, Experience a HIPAA Violation? This HIPAA Summary Explains the Privacy Rule and What to Do Next!

A proper risk management system is also essential for healthcare operations to avoid financial penalties. This includes having a protocol to check authorization requirements before disclosing medical information.

Designating a privacy and compliance officer to help manage questions, training, reports, and risk analyses is also a good practice. Even small organizations can benefit from having a dedicated officer.

Here are some key steps to prevent HIPAA violations:

  • Establish a protocol to check authorization requirements before disclosing medical information.
  • Train contractors to not share login credentials, not to leave physical files or devices unattended, and never to share patient information on unencrypted devices.
  • Limit social media and address removing current patients as contacts from social media platforms.

Grounds for Termination?

A HIPAA violation can indeed be grounds for termination, but it's not always a straightforward decision. Yes, HIPAA breach penalties can result in termination.

The outcome depends on several factors, including the results of an internal investigation, the scope of the breach, and the employee's role in it.

Accidental breaches that occur in good faith may not be reportable under HIPAA rules.

How to Avoid

To avoid HIPAA violations, it's essential to provide sufficient HIPAA compliance training to employees in a healthcare entity. This training should cover the PHI responsible for violations, so employees can mitigate them.

A different take: Hipaa Training

Credit: youtube.com, Medicaid Provider Compliance Program and Provider Self Audits, Fraud Prevention and Compliance Unit

Having a proper risk management system is also crucial for healthcare operations to avoid further financial penalties. This includes establishing a protocol to check authorization requirements before disclosing medical information.

One way to ensure your organization avoids HIPAA violations is to train employees on common violations. This should include establishing a protocol to check authorization requirements before disclosing medical information, addressing where discussions of patient information can occur, and training contractors to not share login credentials.

Contractors should also be trained not to leave physical files or devices unattended, and never to share patient information on unencrypted devices. Limiting social media is also important, as employees posting hallway pictures in a healthcare facility can compromise patient privacy.

Designating a privacy and compliance officer to help manage questions, training, reports, and risk analyses is also beneficial, even for small organizations. This officer can help ensure that employees are aware of the PHI responsible for violations.

Here are some crucial steps to avoid HIPAA violations:

  • Establish a protocol to check authorization requirements before disclosing medical information
  • Address where discussions of patient information can occur
  • Train contractors to not share login credentials, not to leave physical files or devices unattended, and never to share patient information on unencrypted devices
  • Limit social media
  • Designate a privacy and compliance officer

Securing access to critical infrastructure is also key to preventing HIPAA breaches. This can be achieved with an infrastructure access platform that provides just-in-time access to needed records, auditing of sessions, and granular control of vendor and employee access.

Examples and Case Studies

Credit: youtube.com, An Example of A HIPAA Violation Lawsuit

HIPAA violations can be costly and damaging to patients and healthcare organizations alike. One example of a HIPAA violation is when a healthcare provider releases medical records to a third party without the patient's authorization.

Accidental HIPAA violations can occur, such as losing a personal cell phone that allows access to workplace applications, but they are still considered serious breaches. For instance, one organization was fined for having a third party convert x-rays to a digital format without a business agreement in place to ensure HIPAA regulations were met.

Losing medical records can be a HIPAA violation if it exposes patient records to unauthorized actors. Patients have a right to their medical records within 30 days of a request, and failure to provide them is a HIPAA violation.

Law enforcement and military agencies can face HIPAA violation fines, but only if they operate their own medical service. The military exception allows care providers to disclose PHI to military personnel to determine fitness for duty or a particular mission.

Credit: youtube.com, Real-World HIPAA Violations That Led to Jail Sentences

Healthcare employees can commit a HIPAA violation by divulging patient information without consent. In 2008, 13 employees at UCLA were fired for looking at Britney Spears's medical records without consent, and 6 physicians were suspended.

Sharing patient information without consent is a common HIPAA violation committed by healthcare professionals. It can also lead to potential jail time.

The following table shows 7 high-impact HIPAA violation email examples:

In some cases, HIPAA violations can lead to significant fines, such as the $2.75 million fine paid by the University of Mississippi Medical Center (UMMC) for failing to respond to breaches and notify affected individuals.

Lawsuits and Penalties

Civil Monetary Penalties can be issued by the HHS' Office for Civil Rights, with a maximum annual penalty of $1.5 million for repeated violations. The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center was fined $4,348,000 in 2018 for impermissible disclosure of ePHI without encryption.

In 2018, Massachusetts fined McLean Hospital $75,000 for violating patient privacy, affecting 1,500 individuals. New Jersey fined EmblemHealth $100,000 for a similar violation, affecting 6,443 individuals.

Penalties for HIPAA violations can range from $100 to $50,000 per violation, with an annual maximum of $1.5 million for repeated violations.

Penalties

A medical professional in scrubs and mask examines documents in a clinical setting.
Credit: pexels.com, A medical professional in scrubs and mask examines documents in a clinical setting.

Penalties

Civil Monetary Penalties Issued by the HHS’ Office for Civil Rights can be substantial, with a maximum amount of $4,348,000, as seen in the 2018 case of the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center.

In 2017, Children’s Medical Center of Dallas was fined $3,200,000 for impermissible Disclosure of ePHI.

The HHS’ Office for Civil Rights has issued significant fines for HIPAA violations, with a total of $4,348,000 in 2018 for the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center.

Lincare, Inc. was fined $239,800 in 2016 for Failure to Safeguard PHI.

State Attorneys General also have the authority to pursue financial penalties for HIPAA violations, although only a handful have issued fines solely for HIPAA violations.

Some notable fines issued by State Attorneys General include a $230,000 fine to UMass Memorial Medical Group / UMass Memorial Medical Center in Massachusetts in 2018 for failing to provide patients with access to their medical records.

Here's an interesting read: Washington Hipaa Laws

Black-and-white photo of a medical professional holding a tablet, focusing on digital health technology.
Credit: pexels.com, Black-and-white photo of a medical professional holding a tablet, focusing on digital health technology.

In 2018, Aetna was fined $365,211.59 in New Jersey for failing to provide patients with access to their medical records.

The largest fine issued by State Attorneys General in 2018 was $1,150,000 to Aetna in New York for failing to provide patients with access to their medical records.

Here are some notable fines issued by State Attorneys General for HIPAA violations:

Note that these fines are just a few examples of the penalties that can be imposed for HIPAA violations.

U.S. Citizen Lawsuit Filing

As a U.S. citizen, it's essential to know your options if your healthcare provider or insurance company has compromised your private information.

There is no private cause of action in HIPAA, which means you can't file a HIPAA violation lawsuit directly.

Several states, however, do allow patients to sue providers for unauthorized disclosures of their medical records, including New York, Massachusetts, and Missouri.

You may need to file a lawsuit under state laws or other federal laws where there is a private cause of action.

Take a look at this: Private Student Loan Lawsuit

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average HIPAA settlement?

The average HIPAA settlement is $1.5 million, based on publicly available data from the HHS Office for Civil Rights' HIPAA settlement board. This significant fine highlights the importance of HIPAA compliance in the healthcare industry.

How much money can you get for suing for a HIPAA violation?

Civil monetary penalties for HIPAA violations can range from $141 to $2,134,831 per incident, depending on the level of culpability. If you're considering a lawsuit, the actual damages may be higher, but this range gives you an idea of the potential financial impact.

Vanessa Schmidt

Lead Writer

Vanessa Schmidt is a seasoned writer with a passion for crafting informative and engaging content. With a keen eye for detail and a knack for research, she has established herself as a trusted voice in the world of personal finance. Her expertise has led to the creation of articles on a wide range of topics, including Wells Fargo credit card information, where she provides readers with valuable insights and practical advice.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.