Debt covenant compliance is a critical aspect of managing debt for business owners. Debt covenants are contractual agreements that lenders require borrowers to adhere to, typically involving financial ratios and metrics.
Business owners must carefully review their loan agreements to understand the specific covenants that apply to their debt. This includes identifying the relevant financial metrics, such as debt-to-equity ratios and interest coverage ratios.
Compliance with debt covenants can have significant consequences for businesses, including the potential for loan default or even bankruptcy. Therefore, it's essential for business owners to prioritize debt covenant compliance.
Regular financial monitoring and reporting can help business owners stay on top of their debt covenant obligations. By doing so, they can avoid costly penalties and ensure ongoing access to capital.
You might like: Working Capital for Startup Business
What Are Debt Covenants?
Debt covenants are restrictions that lenders put on lending agreements to limit the actions of the borrower. They are also called banking covenants or financial covenants.
Lenders structure secured debt, such as corporate loans, with debt covenants to protect their downside risk. This means they require borrowers to operate within certain rules set by the lenders.
Debt covenants are conditional terms in lending agreements to ensure the borrower's financial performance remains steady and management continues to be responsible when making corporate decisions. They are agreements between a company and its lenders that the company will operate within certain rules set by the lenders.
These rules can limit the borrower's actions, such as restricting their ability to take on more debt or sell off assets. Debt covenants are essential for lenders to ensure they get their money back and for borrowers to manage their debt responsibly.
Here are the different types of debt covenants:
- 1. Affirmative Covenants (or Positive)
- 2. Restrictive Covenants (or Negative)
- 3. Financial Covenants: Maintenance vs. Incurrence Covenants
Debt covenants can be categorized into three main types: affirmative, restrictive, and financial covenants.
Consequences of Non-Compliance
Breaching a debt covenant can lead to severe consequences, including the lender declaring the borrower in "technical default." This can result in the lender taking legal action, including bringing the issue to court.
The severity of the consequences depends on the lender and the relationship between the parties involved. If the borrower has a good relationship with the lender, they may be able to negotiate a waiver of the breach.
However, if the breach is severe or the lender is unwilling to negotiate, the consequences can be more severe. The lender may request collateral, such as a lien, or increase the interest rate on the loan.
In extreme cases, the lender may terminate the loan agreement, requiring the borrower to pay the principal immediately, plus fines. This can lead to a lengthy and complex restructuring process, potentially involving the Bankruptcy Court.
Here are some possible outcomes of breaching a debt covenant:
- The lender may agree to a simple amendment of the loan agreement with new covenants based on projected financial information.
- The lender may enter into a forbearance agreement, restricting new borrowing, CapEx, and owner distributions.
- The lender may require more collateral, refinancing with another bank, or initiate foreclosure/liquidation proceedings.
- The lender may require the retention of a restructuring consultant to act as an advisor to the company.
Types of Debt Covenants
Debt covenants can be categorized as either positive or negative. Positive covenants are obligations to do something, while negative covenants are promises not to do something.
Positive covenants, also known as affirmative covenants, require borrowers to perform certain specified activities. These can include maintaining good standing with the SEC, filing financials on time, and getting financial statements audited regularly.
Negative covenants, on the other hand, are restrictions on the company's actions. For example, a lender might require a borrower to remain in compliance with the SEC on all filing requirements.
Financial covenants are a type of debt covenant that refer to pre-specified credit ratios and operating performance metrics. These can include maintaining an interest coverage ratio or not paying annual cash dividends exceeding a certain percentage of net earnings.
Here are some examples of debt covenants:
- Interest coverage ratio of 3.70 based on cash flow from operations
- Not paying annual cash dividends exceeding 60% of net earnings
- Not borrowing debt that is senior to this debt
Ratios and Financial Health
Financial covenants are imposed to ensure the borrower maintains a certain level of operating performance and financial health. These covenants can be separated into two types: maintenance covenants and incurrence covenants.
Maintenance covenants require the borrower to avoid breaching specified credit ratios, such as a leverage ratio of less than 5.0x. Examples of maintenance covenants include leverage ratio, senior leverage ratio, interest coverage ratio, and downgrade in credit rating.
Incurrence covenants, on the other hand, are tested only if the borrower takes a specific action, such as raising more debt financing. These covenants are designed to protect the lender from potential risks.
For your interest: Operating Ratio
Here are some common financial ratios that lenders often require borrowers to maintain:
By maintaining these financial ratios, borrowers can demonstrate their ability to manage their finances and reduce the risk of defaulting on their loans.
Service Coverage Ratio
The Debt Service Coverage Ratio is a cash flow measure that reflects a borrower's ability to service its debt obligations. It's a crucial metric for lenders, who often require a covenant equal to or greater than 1.20x.
Banks and sureties typically look for this ratio to ensure the borrower has a stable financial foundation. A higher ratio indicates a borrower's ability to meet its debt obligations is strong.
If a borrower's Debt Service Coverage Ratio falls below 1.20x, it may indicate financial strain, and the lender may take action. This could lead to a breach of covenant, which can have serious consequences.
To maintain a healthy Debt Service Coverage Ratio, borrowers should focus on managing their cash flow and debt obligations carefully. This may involve reducing expenses, increasing revenue, or renegotiating debt terms.
Curious to learn more? Check out: Debt Service Coverage Ratio Covenant
Equity Ratio
The Equity Ratio is a key indicator of a company's financial health, and it's calculated by dividing total debt by total stockholder's equity. This ratio determines the extent of non-equity capital used to finance assets.
In the construction arena, lenders and sureties may vary on this ratio depending on the contractor. One specific ratio is the Debt to Equity Ratio, which is a crucial metric for evaluating a company's financial stability.
This ratio helps lenders and investors understand how much debt a company is carrying relative to its equity. The goal is to ensure that a company has a healthy balance between debt and equity to avoid financial risks.
For example, in the construction industry, a specific Debt to Equity Ratio might be used to assess a contractor's financial health.
Recommended read: Swap Ratio
Compliance and Violation
A debt covenant violation can have serious consequences for borrowers. Lenders can demand a penalty payment for the breach.
If a debt covenant is violated, the lender can take several actions, including increasing the predetermined interest rate. This can significantly increase the borrower's debt burden.
In some cases, lenders may also demand the immediate repayment of the loan. This can be a significant financial strain on the borrower.
The severity of the violation determines the lender's response. More severe breaches may result in more severe consequences.
Here are some possible lender actions in the event of a debt covenant violation:
- Demand penalty payment
- Increase the predetermined interest rate
- Increase the amount of collateral
- Demand full immediate repayment of the loan
- Terminate the debt agreement
Getting Started
First, you'll want to start with a financial health checkup, which typically begins with a 13-week cash flow forecast.
This cash flow forecast will help establish your company's near-term cash position and determine its ability to manage cash and liquidity.
A cash flow forecast can be completed in a few weeks if no major issues are found, but if issues arise that could trigger a covenant violation, the engagement may be extended.
Covenant sensitivities testing is the next step, using financial forecast models to determine how close you are to a loan default based on current and projected business conditions.
This analysis will also identify which covenants you're in danger of tripping and when a default is likely to occur based on "what-if" scenarios.
Each financial health check is situation-dependent, so the scope and duration of the engagement will vary depending on the specific needs of your company.
Suggestion: Forecast Period (finance)
Financial Impact and Management
Debt covenant compliance can be a stressful and overwhelming experience, especially when you're already struggling financially. What may feel like adding another burden to an already stressful situation can actually alleviate stress and help you in the long term.
In fact, restructuring experts can often identify solutions that deliver cost savings sufficient to recoup the expense of their services, especially if they're brought in early. This can be a game-changer for businesses looking to get back on their feet.
Financial covenants are a crucial aspect of debt covenant compliance, and they come in two main types: maintenance and incurrence covenants. Maintenance covenants require the borrower to maintain certain credit ratios and operational metrics, ensuring the company's financial health is kept under control.
Examples of maintenance covenants include a leverage ratio of less than 5.0x, a senior leverage ratio of less than 3.0x, and an interest coverage ratio of greater than 3.0x. Additionally, borrowers may be required to avoid a downgrade in their credit rating from a reputable agency like S&P or Moody's.
Consider reading: Financial Leverage and Capital Structure
Incurrence covenants, on the other hand, are tested only if the borrower takes a specific action, such as raising more debt financing. For example, a potential incurrence covenant might state that the borrower cannot raise more debt financing if doing so causes the debt-to-EBITDA ratio to exceed 5.0x.
Here are some key differences between maintenance and incurrence covenants:
By understanding the different types of financial covenants and how they work, borrowers can better manage their debt and stay compliant with their loan agreements. This can help alleviate stress and ensure long-term financial stability.
Sources
- https://www.plantemoran.com/explore-our-thinking/insight/2019/01/concerned-about-your-companys-loan-covenant-compliance-your-bank-is
- https://www.wallstreetprep.com/knowledge/debt-covenants/
- https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/commercial-lending/debt-covenants/
- https://www.lightercapital.com/blog/what-are-debt-covenants-on-a-loan
- https://www.withum.com/resources/understanding-bank-loan-covenants/
Featured Images: pexels.com