
Having two of the same credit cards can be a double-edged sword. While it might seem convenient to have multiple cards with the same benefits, it's essential to consider the potential drawbacks.
You can have two of the same credit cards, but it's crucial to check the issuer's policy on multiple cards. Some issuers may limit the number of cards you can have or charge a fee for additional cards.
Having two of the same credit cards can lead to duplicate rewards, which might not be the best use of your rewards potential. For example, if you have two credit cards with a 2% cashback on groceries, you'll earn 4% cashback on groceries, but only up to the spending limit on each card.
Pros and Cons of Multiple Credit Cards
Having multiple credit cards from the same company can be beneficial, especially if you're concerned about having a backup in case one is lost or stolen.
The better your credit scores, the better your chances of being approved for a second card from the same issuer.
Having two credit cards from the same company may offer benefits such as rewards programs, sign-up bonuses, and other perks that can be maximized with multiple cards.
In general, it's a good idea to have at least two credit cards, regardless of the financial institution they're from, to ensure you have access to credit for necessities if one is lost or stolen.
Pros of Multiple Credit Cards
Having multiple credit cards from the same company can expand your access to credit.
Your credit scores play a role in determining whether you'll be approved for a second card, and generally, the better your scores, the better your chances.
Having two credit cards from the same issuer can help you maximize rewards.
You can compare different credit cards from the same company, such as Capital One, to see if there's a second card that interests you.
Checking to see if you're pre-approved for a second card won't harm your credit scores.
Having multiple credit cards from the same company can make it easier to manage accounts.
If one card is lost or stolen, you'll still have access to credit for necessities.
Cons of Multiple Credit Cards
Having multiple credit cards can lead to a higher risk of overspending, as you may be more likely to use credit cards for discretionary purchases when you have multiple accounts to draw from.
You'll also be responsible for keeping track of multiple due dates, interest rates, and payment amounts, which can be a real challenge.
This increased complexity can lead to missed payments and late fees, which can further add to your debt burden.
Carrying multiple credit cards can also make it harder to get out of debt, as you'll have more accounts to pay off and more interest to pay.
You may be tempted to apply for more credit cards in pursuit of rewards or cashback, which can further exacerbate the problem.
In the long run, having multiple credit cards can actually decrease your credit score, as it may appear to lenders that you're not able to manage your credit responsibly.
Rewards and Benefits
Having two credit cards from the same issuer can be a great way to maximize your rewards and benefits.
You can earn rewards from different categories, such as cash back and travel miles, by having multiple cards from the same company.
For example, if you have a card that offers unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, you could also get a card that earns elevated rewards related to travel.
This could give you a one-two rewards punch, allowing you to earn rewards in multiple categories.
Other perks you might enjoy with a second card could include cellphone insurance, travel insurance, and airport lounge access.
Applying for Multiple Credit Cards
Having two credit cards from the same issuer can be beneficial, as it expands your access to credit and makes it easier to manage accounts.
You can compare credit cards from the same company to see if there's a second card you're interested in, and check if you're pre-approved without harming your credit scores.
Some issuers allow you to apply for the same credit card again, provided you follow their guidance and waiting periods.
It's essential to check your card agreement and issuer information before applying, as these rules can vary from card to card.
Applying through targeted offers from certain issuers might help you circumvent their "lifetime language" restrictions.
Specific Credit Card Companies
Capital One has a hard rule limiting you to two of its personal credit cards open at once, effective January 23rd. This rule does not apply to co-branded store cards.
Some users have reported being told by customer service representatives that the limit is credit profile dependent, but the official rule is a hard limit of two cards.
I've seen reports of people having up to five credit cards from Capital One in the past, but it seems that the company has since enforced this new limit.
Bank of America
Bank of America has a flexible policy when it comes to multiple credit cards, but there are some restrictions in place.
You can have multiple Better Balance Rewards and Cash Rewards cards, making it a great option for those who want to earn rewards on their purchases.
However, if you try to apply for the Bank of America Alaska card, you'll be out of luck if you've had the card in the past 24 months.
The Better Balance Rewards card is no longer available for new applications, but Bank of America didn't always enforce this rule, and I was able to apply for multiple cards at the same time in the past.
American Express
American Express has a unique policy regarding intro bonuses, where you won't receive the bonus again if you apply for the same product. This is due to the "once in a lifetime" rule.
Applying for multiple American Express cards at once can be a mistake, as the system may view them as duplicate applications and automatically reject them. Space out your applications by a few months to avoid this.
Upgrading a card is different from applying for a new one, and there are often upgrade offers after meeting certain spending requirements. If you currently have or have had the card for the intro bonus in the past, you can consider upgrading, but only if you qualify for the future.
American Express also lets you apply for the same product again, but only if you're upgrading or changing a card, not if you're applying for a new one. This is a key thing to keep in mind when managing your American Express cards.
Re: Capital One
Capital One has a hard rule limiting personal credit cards to two open at once, as of January 23rd. This rule applies to most personal credit cards, but not co-branded store cards.
You might be wondering if this rule is absolute, but it seems to be the case. A post mentions that Customer Service Representatives (CSRs) don't know what they're talking about or are lying when they say it's credit profile dependent.
Capital One's two-card limit has been in place for a while, and it's not just a rumor. The company has officially stated this policy, making it clear that you can only have two of its personal credit cards open at the same time.
If you have multiple credit cards from Capital One, you might be wondering how this affects you. For example, if you have two QS cards that you got within a year of your bankruptcy, and you also applied for a Savor card recently, it's possible that your credit profile is the determining factor in how many cards you can have.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 2/3/4 rule for credit cards?
The 2/3/4 rule limits new credit card approvals to two within 30 days, three within 12 months, and four within 24 months, primarily applying to Bank of America credit cards. This rule may vary depending on your credit card issuer.
Sources
- https://www.capitalone.com/learn-grow/money-management/can-you-have-two-credit-cards-from-same-company/
- https://www.bankrate.com/credit-cards/advice/apply-for-credit-cards-again-same-twice/
- https://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Credit-Cards/Capital-one-same-card/td-p/6645281
- https://www.asksebby.com/faq/two-same-card
- https://www.chase.com/personal/credit-cards/education/basics/two-credit-cards-from-same-bank
Featured Images: pexels.com