VBS Mutual Bank: The R2.3bn Heist and Its Aftermath

Author

Reads 1.9K

Facade of Bank of Morocco Building
Credit: pexels.com, Facade of Bank of Morocco Building

VBS Mutual Bank was at the center of a massive R2.3 billion heist in 2016.

The bank's management was accused of orchestrating the scheme, which involved siphoning off funds from the bank's coffers.

The looting was allegedly done in collaboration with several high-ranking officials and business associates.

A forensic investigation led by the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) uncovered a complex web of transactions and shell companies used to launder the stolen funds.

The investigation found that the money was used to fund lavish lifestyles and business ventures for those involved in the heist.

VBS Mutual Bank Scandal

The VBS Mutual Bank Scandal was a major financial scandal that rocked South Africa in 2018. It was a massive case of looting that involved the bank's top officials and politicians.

The scandal was first uncovered in 2017 when it was discovered that R2 billion had gone missing from the bank's coffers. The money was meant to be used for various infrastructure projects, but instead, it was siphoned off by the bank's officials.

Credit: youtube.com, VBS Corruption | VBS Mutual Bank scandal

The bank's CEO, Andile Ramavhunga, was at the center of the scandal. He was accused of being involved in the looting of the bank's funds, along with other top officials.

A forensic report later revealed that the looting was a well-orchestrated scheme that involved the bank's officials and some politicians. The report found that the money was used to fund various projects, including a luxury hotel in Polokwane.

The scandal led to the arrest of several high-profile individuals, including the bank's CEO and other officials. It also led to the collapse of the bank, which was subsequently placed under curatorship.

The VBS Mutual Bank Scandal was a major blow to the South African economy and highlighted the need for stronger regulations and oversight in the banking sector.

Investigations and Lawsuits

Investigations into VBS Mutual Bank are ongoing, with the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) working to bring those responsible to justice.

Credit: youtube.com, Hawks in the middle of an investigation into VBS Mutual Bank

Crime-fighting bodies have updated MPs on the status of the investigations, but results have been slow to materialize.

The ANC's integrity commission will review Justice Minister Thembi Simelane's involvement in a loan from a fixer for the now-defunct VBS Mutual Bank.

A trial for the alleged bank looters is expected to start soon, with the state having finalized its charge sheet and ready to prosecute.

The National Prosecuting Authority believes it has a very strong case, and the trial is expected to begin in 2022, although it may take 16 weeks to complete.

More arrests are expected in the R2.3bn VBS heist, with prosecutors planning to add additional charges to the seven accused and charging more people.

Justice Minister Disciplinary Matter

The Justice Minister's disciplinary matter is a complex one. The presidency has stated that the decision regarding Justice Minister Thembi Simelane is more than a disciplinary matter, as it involves the minister and may affect the cabinet.

The ANC's integrity commission will review her involvement in a R575 600 loan from a fixer for the now-defunct VBS Mutual Bank. This loan is a significant factor in the disciplinary matter against the minister.

Lawsuits

Illuminated Wells Fargo bank branch at night showcasing modern architecture and signage.
Credit: pexels.com, Illuminated Wells Fargo bank branch at night showcasing modern architecture and signage.

Lawsuits have been a significant part of the VBS Mutual Bank scandal, with several lawsuits filed against KPMG, the bank's auditor.

KPMG was sued by the liquidators for 863.5 million rand (~US$59 million) in February 2021, which was later settled for Rand 500 million (~$27 million) in a confidential out-of-court agreement in February 2024.

The Public Investment Corporation (PIC) also sued KPMG for 144 million rand (around US$9.5 million) in July 2021, claiming it lost money due to KPMG's audit of the VBS bank's financial statements.

The PIC's claim is centered on the rights issue and a revolving credit facility it participated in at VBS, which relied on KPMG's audit.

The National Prosecuting Authority is also ready to prosecute the alleged bank looters, believing it has a very strong case.

In related news, a former PIC executive, Paul Magula, was dismissed in April 2018 for poor performance and failing to protect the PIC from risk and financial loss at VBS.

Kabelo Matsepe, a former ANC youth leader, was arrested by the Hawks and is set to protest his innocence after being accused of looting R35m from the VBS bank.

Steinhoff Investigations Near Conclusion

Two professionals in suits discussing documents outside a corporate building in daylight.
Credit: pexels.com, Two professionals in suits discussing documents outside a corporate building in daylight.

The Steinhoff investigations are reportedly at an advanced stage, according to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the Special Investigating Unit (SIU).

This is a promising development, as it suggests that progress is being made in uncovering the truth behind the Steinhoff scandal.

The NPA and SIU have been working together to investigate Steinhoff, and it's likely that their collaboration has led to the significant progress made so far.

The ANC's integrity commission will review Justice Minister Thembi Simelane's involvement in a R575 600 loan from a fixer for the now-defunct VBS Mutual Bank, which may affect the cabinet.

This is a serious matter, and it's clear that the ANC is taking it seriously by involving their integrity commission.

The presidency has stated that President Ramaphosa needs time to consider the matter, which suggests that it's a complex issue that requires careful consideration.

Arrests and Sentencing

Senior ANC officials Danny Msiza and Kabelo Matsepe are facing charges for their alleged role in the VBS looting scandal.

Credit: youtube.com, Ex-Fetakgomo-Tubatse Municipality Manager Sentenced in VBS Mutual Bank Scandal

They will become the first politicians to be charged in connection with the scandal.

More arrests are expected in the R2.3bn VBS heist, with prosecutors planning to add additional charges to the seven accused in a new charge sheet.

Phillip Truter, the former chief financial officer of VBS, has been sentenced to seven years in prison for his role in the scandal.

Not Guilty R35m Looter

Kabelo Matsepe, a former ANC youth leader, has been arrested by the Hawks for his alleged role in looting R35m from VBS.

He's set to protest his innocence.

Paul Magula, a former PIC executive, was dismissed in April 2018 for poor performance.

His dismissal was due to failing to protect the PIC from risk and financial loss at VBS.

More Arrests Expected in R2.3bn Heist

Prosecutors are confident they have a strong case against the accused, with more people expected to be charged in the R2.3bn VBS heist.

The National Prosecuting Authority believes it has a very strong case against the accused.

More arrests are expected in the R2.3bn VBS heist, with additional charges to be added to the seven accused in a new charge sheet.

Haunted Executive Sentenced to Seven Years

Bank in classic building on street
Credit: pexels.com, Bank in classic building on street

Phillip Truter, the former chief financial officer of the defunct mutual bank, was sentenced to seven years for his role in the alleged heist.

He pleaded guilty to fraud and other charges, and will now work with authorities to uncover how the alleged heist took place.

Bank's Administration and Liquidation

VBS Mutual Bank's administration was put in place by the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) due to the bank's severe liquidity crisis.

The bank's management team was relieved of its duties, and a curator from the auditing firm SizweNtsalubaGobodo took over.

The bank was fined R500 000 in 2017 for a weakness in its control measures to prevent money laundering and combatting the financing of terrorism.

VBS was unable to meet its obligation to a municipality on 16 February, which marked the bank's effective last straw.

The bank had lent out the money it received from municipalities, making it difficult for them to get their money back.

Into Administration

Bank of Spain Building in Madrid
Credit: pexels.com, Bank of Spain Building in Madrid

The South African Reserve Bank (SARB) put VBS under administration after the bank was unable to repay money it owed to municipalities.

A curator from the auditing firm SizweNtsalubaGobodo took over the bank's management team, relieving them of their duties.

VBS will stay open and retail depositors' money is guaranteed.

The bank's severe liquidity crisis led to this official action, according to SARB governor Lesetja Kganyago.

The bank was fined R500,000 in 2017 for a weakness in its control measures to prevent money laundering and combat terrorism.

VBS's financial struggles came to a head when it couldn't meet its obligation to a municipality on 16 February.

KPMG Targeted by Mutual Liquidators

Liquidators are investigating KPMG's sign-off on financial statements.

The VBS Mutual liquidators are taking a closer look at the auditing firm's role in the bank's alleged looting.

KPMG is being sued by the VBS liquidators for R863mn, with the liquidators blaming the firm's negligence for the alleged looting.

Colleagues Standing in White Long Sleeve Shirts Discussing and Reading a Financial Report
Credit: pexels.com, Colleagues Standing in White Long Sleeve Shirts Discussing and Reading a Financial Report

Liquidators are investigating KPMG's sign-off on financial statements, while two former executives also pursue a lawsuit against the firm.

This suggests that KPMG's auditing process may have been flawed, potentially contributing to the bank's financial woes.

The VBS liquidators are seeking compensation from KPMG for its alleged role in the bank's alleged looting.

Curator Seeks Loan Recovery

The curator of VBS Mutual Bank is taking action to recover a significant loan from Brian Shivambu, who has not serviced the loan and is in arrears of more than R2.7-million.

The loan is a serious issue that highlights the bank's problems with loan management, which was a contributing factor to its severe liquidity crisis.

The curator is seeking to recover the loan from Shivambu, who has not made any repayments, further straining the bank's finances.

This is just one of the many challenges the curator faces in trying to stabilize the bank and recover from the alleged looting of VBS Mutual Bank's assets.

Corruption and Scams

Credit: youtube.com, VBS Corruption | Shareholders call for VBS Mutual Bank to be restored: Robert Livhoyi

A staggering R1,894,923,674 was transferred from VBS Mutual Bank to 53 individuals between 2015 and 2018, with R16,148,569 going to Brian Shivambu, the younger brother of EFF leader Julius Malema.

The report found that Brian Shivambu paid back R4.55 million and admitted to receiving VBS money, while EFF leader Julius Malema was sued for allegedly admitting to benefiting from corruption at VBS, but later withdrew the lawsuit.

VBS was used as a slush fund for corrupt politicians, local government leaders, and their business cronies through a pyramid scheme, with the bank's owners bribing officials in some of South Africa's poorest municipalities.

The bank's chairperson, Tshifhiwa Matodzi, was sentenced to 15 years in prison for multiple counts of fraud, racketeering, money laundering, and theft.

Thembi Simelane, the embattled Justice Minister, received a R586,000 loan from VBS Mutual Bank through a company that provided the loan, and she took the loan due to being unable to borrow money from a commercial bank on better terms.

Simelane's Loan Terms Offered

Credit: youtube.com, VBS fraud I Minister Thembi Simelane allegedly secured a R500 000 loan

Simelane says she was offered better loan terms by the VBS fixer than a bank.

She had proof of the transaction, which she used to resist claims of a conflict of interest.

Brains Behind South Africa's $130m Fraud

The brains behind South Africa's $130m bank scandal was Tshifhiwa Matodzi, the chairperson of VBS Mutual Bank.

Matodzi was found guilty of 33 counts, including corruption, theft, fraud, money laundering, and racketeering.

He was sentenced to 15 years in prison, with the court ordering that the sentences run concurrently.

Matodzi was accused of masterminding the looting, with the support of a team of highly qualified accountants and lawyers, and a dizzying network of apparently fraudulent shell companies and subcontractors.

The scam stretched from impoverished rural villages all the way to government circles, and defrauded ordinary South Africans.

VBS was allegedly transformed into a slush fund for corrupt politicians, local government leaders, and their business cronies.

Lamborghini Logo badge on Hood of Black Glossy Sports Car
Credit: pexels.com, Lamborghini Logo badge on Hood of Black Glossy Sports Car

The bank's owners were accused of bribing local officials in some of South Africa's poorest and most dysfunctional municipalities.

It was only once VBS was put under the control of South Africa's central bank that investigators discovered the full extent of the alleged looting and political intrigue.

Matodzi was the first person to be found guilty and sentenced in the VBS case.

The South Africa's elite Hawks police unit is also "pursuing other suspects" in the VBS case.

ANC and Government Involvement

The ANC's involvement in the VBS Mutual Bank scandal is a complex issue. The bank's chairman, Tshifhiwa Matodzi, was a close ally of the ANC's Limpopo provincial chairperson, Danny Msiza.

The government's role in the scandal is also a matter of concern. The bank's auditor, KPMG, was accused of turning a blind eye to the bank's irregularities, and the auditor-general, Kimi Makwetu, was criticized for not taking action sooner.

The ANC's provincial treasurer, Andile Ramavhoya, was also implicated in the scandal, and the party's leadership was accused of failing to address the issue.

Ramaphosa Requests Report

The Lombard Bank Building in Sliema, Malta
Credit: pexels.com, The Lombard Bank Building in Sliema, Malta

President Ramaphosa has asked Justice Minister Thembi Simelane for a report on the allegations surrounding VBS Bank's collapse.

Thembi Simelane is under scrutiny for taking a loan from a company embroiled in the scandal that triggered the bank's collapse.

This move suggests that Ramaphosa is taking the matter seriously and wants to get to the bottom of the allegations.

The VBS Bank scandal has been a major source of controversy in South Africa, with many calling for accountability from those involved.

Senior ANC Officials Arrested

Several senior ANC officials were arrested in a series of raids in 2018, including former ANC MP Makhosi Khoza's husband, Nhlanhla Mabhena.

The arrests were related to the VBS Mutual Bank scandal, which involved the looting of billions of rands from the bank.

ANC officials were accused of receiving bribes from VBS Mutual Bank in exchange for government contracts.

The VBS Mutual Bank scandal was exposed in 2018, revealing that the bank had been looting billions of rands from its clients.

The ANC has a history of corruption and nepotism, with many officials accused of using their positions for personal gain.

The party's leadership has been criticized for not doing enough to address corruption within its ranks.

ANC Committee Clears Maneli, Mogale-Letsie

Canadian Maple Leaf on Wall with McDonalds Logo
Credit: pexels.com, Canadian Maple Leaf on Wall with McDonalds Logo

The ANC dispute committee has cleared two former mayors, Maneli and Mogale-Letsie, in the VBS scandal.

This decision comes after the Gauteng PEC's step-aside ruling against them was deemed "harsh" and "extreme" by the ANC committee.

The ANC committee's decision to clear Maneli and Mogale-Letsie has been made public, sparking debate about the handling of the VBS scandal.

The Gauteng PEC's ruling against the two former mayors was a significant move in the ANC's efforts to address the scandal.

The ANC's handling of the VBS scandal has been closely watched, with many wondering what the outcome will be for those involved.

Financial Losses and Liquidations

Millions of rands have been lost due to the VBS Mutual Bank liquidations. The bank's liquidator is now targeting individuals who allegedly profited from the scheme, as well as former president Jacob Zuma.

The liquidators are investigating the auditing firm KPMG, specifically looking into its sign-off on financial statements. Two former executives are also pursuing a lawsuit against KPMG.

A staggering R80m loss has been found in the Community Scheme Ombud Service investment, with a forensic report concluding that the investment was reckless.

Millions Lost, More Liquidations

Credit: youtube.com, 🎓 Finance ABC: What is Liquidation? (With The Biggest Recent Liquidation Stories)

Millions have been lost in the wake of recent financial struggles, and the situation is only getting worse with more liquidations on the horizon.

The bank's liquidator has been actively pursuing individuals who allegedly profited from the situation.

Millions of people have been affected by the financial losses, and the situation is a stark reminder of the importance of financial responsibility.

Two more people have been targeted by the liquidator, who are accused of making a profit from the bank's struggles.

The bank's woes have also led to the liquidation of former president Jacob Zuma, who was allegedly involved in the scandal.

Homes Ombud Posts R80m Loss

The Homes Ombud has posted an R80m loss.

A forensic report found the Community Scheme Ombud Service investment was reckless. This led to the significant financial loss.

The R80m loss is a staggering amount, and it highlights the importance of responsible investing.

Court Proceedings and Orders

The court proceedings against VBS Mutual Bank were a long and complex process. The bank's former CEO, Andile Ramavhunga, was one of the key figures involved in the scandal.

Credit: youtube.com, VBS Mutual Bank case: defence 'willing to go to ConCourt'

The bank's financial woes began in 2016, when it reported a R1.5 billion loss due to a massive money laundering scheme. The scheme involved the bank's executives and some of its clients.

The South African Reserve Bank (SARB) took control of VBS Mutual Bank in 2018 due to its financial instability. The SARB appointed a curator to manage the bank's affairs and protect the interests of its depositors.

The curator's report revealed that the bank had been involved in a massive scheme to launder money and embezzle funds. The report also highlighted the bank's poor governance and lack of internal controls.

The curator's report led to the arrest and prosecution of several VBS Mutual Bank executives, including its former CEO and some of its board members.

Individual Cases and Investigations

VBS Mutual Bank's individual cases and investigations are a significant part of its history. The bank's collapse in 2009 was a result of a combination of factors, including reckless lending and a lack of oversight.

Credit: youtube.com, VBS bank heist | VBS Mutual Bank suspects to appear in court

One of the most notable cases was that of the bank's former CEO, Daniel Mthembu, who was accused of embezzling R22 million. He was eventually convicted and sentenced to 10 years in prison.

The bank's board of directors was also criticized for its handling of the crisis. They failed to take decisive action to address the bank's financial woes, which ultimately led to its collapse.

The bank's collapse had a devastating impact on its customers, who lost millions of rand in deposits. Many were left without access to their money, and some even lost their homes.

The South African Reserve Bank was heavily criticized for its role in the bank's collapse. It was accused of failing to regulate the bank properly, which allowed its reckless lending practices to continue unchecked.

The VBS Mutual Bank scandal led to a significant overhaul of the country's banking regulations. The new regulations aimed to prevent similar scandals from happening in the future.

Financial Disputes and Freezing of Assets

Credit: youtube.com, VBS retail depositors can access up to R100,000 on Friday

The court has attempted to freeze VBS's R80 million, which is a significant amount of money.

The community schemes service claims that the money meant for VBS was diverted into an FNB account.

This highlights the complexity of financial disputes, where assets can be frozen to prevent further losses.

KPMG Sued for R863mn

The auditing firm KPMG is facing a massive lawsuit of R863mn from the liquidators of VBS Mutual Bank.

KPMG's negligence is being blamed for the alleged looting of the bank, according to filed court documents.

The liquidators are investigating KPMG's sign-off on financial statements, which may have contributed to the bank's downfall.

Florence Radzilani, a former VBS mayor, is also suing KPMG, although her claim is for a much smaller amount of R38-million.

Radzilani is seeking compensation for defamation, loss of income, and reputational damage.

Brian Shivambu Ordered to Pay R1.8m

Brian Shivambu, the younger brother of Floyd Shivambu, has been ordered to pay R1.8m for an unpaid VBS loan.

Credit: youtube.com, Reaction to Brian Shivambu's decision to pay back VBS money

This order was made in relation to an application by the liquidator of the VBS Bank, which granted a R4-million loan to Brian Shivambu's company.

The liquidator's application is part of a larger case involving the flow of money from VBS Bank, which suggests that the EFF's second-in-command may have benefited from the proceeds of a crime.

Brian Shivambu's company was granted a R4-million loan by the VBS Bank, which has now been deemed unpaid and resulted in the order to pay R1.8m.

Fuel Scheme Lost Millions

The fuel scheme at VBS lost the PIC millions.

Forensic investigation revealed significant anomalies in withdrawals made by top executives.

The PIC's former boss and two executives allegedly took gifts from the bank in exchange for turning a blind eye to the scheme.

The scheme was approved by top executives, despite its questionable nature.

This case highlights the risks of financial mismanagement and the importance of oversight.

Court Seeks to Freeze R80m

Apple Logo
Credit: pexels.com, Apple Logo

The court is seeking to freeze R80m, a significant amount of money that's at the center of a financial dispute.

This move is in response to allegations that the money meant for VBS went into an FNB account instead.

The court's decision to freeze the assets highlights the importance of transparency and accountability in financial transactions.

A court bid to freeze R80m is underway, with the community schemes service at the forefront of the case.

The service claims that the money was meant for VBS, but it ended up in an FNB account, raising questions about the legitimacy of the transaction.

The freezing of assets is a common practice in financial disputes, aiming to prevent the dissipation of assets before a final judgment is made.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is VBS Mutual Bank?

VBS Mutual Bank is a South African bank registered and regulated by the South African Reserve Bank, established in 1982 as a mutual bank. It operates under the Mutual Banks Act of 1993, offering financial services to its clients.

What are the allegations against VBS?

VBS is accused of theft, fraud, corruption, and organized crime, with multiple individuals facing charges. The allegations involve serious financial misconduct and breaches of the law.

Greg Brown

Senior Writer

Greg Brown is a seasoned writer with a keen interest in the world of finance. With a focus on investment strategies, Greg has established himself as a knowledgeable and insightful voice in the industry. Through his writing, Greg aims to provide readers with practical advice and expert analysis on various investment topics.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.