data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0030a/0030aea47ce1278ae4ef2bcffd46230281a62d07" alt="An Elderly Man Consulting an Insurance Agent"
Supplemental insurances for health services and benefits can provide an added layer of financial protection and peace of mind. These types of insurance can help cover unexpected medical expenses that may not be fully covered by your primary health insurance.
Critical illness insurance can provide a lump sum payment if you're diagnosed with a serious illness such as cancer or heart disease. This can help pay for medical expenses, lost income, and other related costs.
Some supplemental insurances may also offer additional benefits such as hospital indemnity insurance, which can provide a daily cash benefit while you're in the hospital. This can help cover living expenses and other costs while you're recovering from an illness or injury.
A fresh viewpoint: Critical Illness Insurance Rates
Best Overall
AARP/UnitedHealthcare takes the top spot as the best overall Medigap provider, with an average Plan G premium of $268. They have a better-than-expected complaint index with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), indicating fewer customer complaints relative to their size.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77f4a/77f4a3f839f1899c7e931c0046a6df025d69c596" alt="Close-Up Shot of Food Supplement on Glass Jar"
Their excellent financial strength rating from credit rating agency AM Best shows they're well-equipped to meet their insurance obligations in the future. And, they offer a community pricing model with discounts that some people may find attractive.
Here are some key benefits of choosing AARP/UnitedHealthcare:
- Average Plan G premium: $268
- Customer complaints: Better than expected for company size
- Excellent financial strength rating (A+ from AM Best)
- Policies available nationwide
- Plans come with free gym membership and health care discounts
However, keep in mind that their high-deductible Plan G premiums are expensive, and their loss ratio is lower than some competitors, which may indicate they're spending less on claims.
Low Cost Options
If you're looking for a low-cost Medicare Supplement option, Anthem is a great choice. They had the best overall pricing and the lowest average premium for Plan G, according to Investopedia's research.
Anthem's prices differ by state, but their average premiums for Plans F and G are lower than the industry average. They had the lowest premiums for Plan G policies for 70- and 80-year-olds of the Medigap companies Investopedia researched.
You can get a 10% household discount if you cover multiple people in the same household, which is a nice perk. Additionally, Anthem offers Medigap policyholders extra benefits, such as a SilverSneakers fitness membership, prescription drug discounts, and savings on vitamins and weight loss programs.
See what others are reading: Medigap Plan G vs N
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f4fda/f4fda55bf9abde31338ae04b380c90ded104d16d" alt="Health Insurance Scrabble Tiles on Planner"
Anthem is a well-established company, founded in the 1940s and based in Indianapolis. They have a good reputation, with AM Best granting them an A grade, reflecting an "excellent" ability to pay their insurance claims.
Here are some key benefits of choosing Anthem:
- Best average premium for Plan G
- 10% household discount
- Plans come with a fitness membership and health discounts
High-Deductible Health Insurance
Humana's high-deductible Plan G policy is widely available and costs less than average, with an average premium of just $93 in a five-state cost survey.
However, Humana's customer satisfaction ratings are lower compared to some competitors, so it's essential to compare options in your area.
Humana offers up to eight Medigap plans in 42 states and provides a generous discount for enrolled spouses who live together.
But, Humana's complaint record is far worse than anyone else's on this list, with a complaint index nearly four times the expected number.
If you're considering a high-deductible health insurance plan, Humana's high-deductible Plan G policy is worth exploring, especially if you're looking for a lower premium.
Expand your knowledge: Medicare Supplement Plan G Deductible 2024
Here are some key points to consider:
- Better-than-average premiums for high-deductible Plan G
- Offers up to eight Medigap plans in 42 states
- Generous discount for enrolled spouses who live together
However, keep in mind that Humana's premiums for the standard Plan G are higher than average, and their complaint record is a concern.
Choosing the Best
AARP/UnitedHealthcare tops the list of companies for its competitive pricing for Plan G, with an average premium of $268.
The company's community pricing model offers discounts that some people may find attractive.
UnitedHealthcare's low complaint index with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows it received fewer customer complaints to state regulators than expected, given its size.
The company's A+ from credit rating agency AM Best indicates it is well-placed to meet its insurance obligations many years into the future.
Blue Cross Blue Shield offers all 10 types of Medicare Supplement plans, something no other provider can say.
Its average Plan F premium is lower than the industry average, and the company offers a high-deductible Plan F.
Recommended read: Ceo of Blue Shield of California
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a6e8b/a6e8bbda2a02fafeeaf9c459fb375ed9ad1f1413" alt="An Insurance Agent and an Elderly Man Shaking Hands"
Blue Cross Blue Shield's financial strength and other ratings vary by state, but all have very good financial stability grades ranging from A+ to A-.
Here's a comparison of the top two companies:
UnitedHealthcare's community-rated model charges everyone similar premiums at the beginning, regardless of age, and raises premiums at the same rate for everyone.
This differs from attained-age pricing, which many competitors use, offering lower premiums when you're younger and increasing them as you age.
Blue Cross Blue Shield takes a similar approach, but with higher premium increases over time.
AARP/UnitedHealthcare's low-deductible Plan G premiums are relatively affordable, but high-deductible Plan G premiums are expensive.
UnitedHealthcare's loss ratio is lower than that of some competitors, indicating it may be spending less of the premiums it collects on claims to policyholders.
Blue Cross Blue Shield offers extra benefits, including premium discounts, a 24/7 nurse line, routine hearing exams, a free fitness membership, and discounts on health products and services.
These benefits vary by state, but can be a valuable addition to your Medicare Supplement plan.
A unique perspective: Check Prior Authorization Status Blue Cross Blue Shield
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77863/778633097671245640873d165faea122b4caae3d" alt="A Health Insurance Spelled on Scrabble Blocks on Top of a Notebook Planner"
Investopedia's methodology for reviewing Medicare insurance providers includes a quantitative model that scores each company based on criteria such as costs, financials, plan types, customer satisfaction, and nationwide availability.
The model assigns weights to each criterion, with costs accounting for 38% of the total score.
AARP/UnitedHealthcare and Blue Cross Blue Shield both rank high in these criteria, making them strong contenders for the best Medicare Supplement insurance provider.
On a similar theme: Does Health Insurance Cover Funeral Costs
Insurance Providers
AARP/UnitedHealthcare is a top choice for Medigap plans, offering lower-than-average premiums for Plan G and a community pricing model with discounts that some people may find attractive.
Their average Plan G premium is $268, which is relatively low compared to other companies. They also have a better-than-expected customer complaint index with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).
One of the downsides of choosing AARP/UnitedHealthcare is that their high-deductible Plan G premiums are expensive. However, their excellent financial strength rating and low loss ratio make them a reliable choice.
Explore further: Is Aarp Dental Insurance Worth It
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f0d8f/f0d8f7e0ae2adb4ea4b3f6c718b3830521b000b4" alt="A Woman wearing Face Mask holding Insurance Policy"
Here's a comparison of some of the benefits of AARP/UnitedHealthcare's Medigap plans:
Humana Medicare Supplement Insurance plans also offer a range of benefits, including coverage for Medicare Part A coinsurance and hospital costs, Medicare Part B coinsurance or copayment, and blood (first 3 pints).
Their plans also offer a foreign travel emergency benefit, which covers up to 80% of approved services, and an out-of-pocket limit of $7,060 in 2024 for Plans K and L.
UnitedHealthcare is more widely available than some of its competitors, offering policies in all 50 states.
A different take: Medicare Supplement Plans in Ga
Application and Claims
You can shop and apply for an AARP Medicare Supplement insurance plan, which will support you through your Medicare journey.
A simple, seamless claims process is available through Aetna Simplified Claims Experience, which helps employees get their cash benefits fast.
Our easy file tool uses medical data to avoid extra paperwork, allowing for claims submission in just 90 seconds.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48c07/48c07304c21f46fe34c7058a8cc040c15109e451" alt="A Woman Holding Key and Insurance Policy"
Here's a breakdown of the Aetna Simplified Claims Experience features:
- Easy file tool: uses medical data to avoid extra paperwork
- Claims finder: checks for other supplemental health benefits and automatically processes claims
- Member portal and app: allows members to view coverage, manage claims, sign up for direct deposit, and chat with Member Services
This streamlined process is powered by Aetna Easy File and Aetna claims finder, making it easy for members to get coverage and access their benefits.
AARP Application
If you're looking to apply for AARP Medicare Supplement insurance, you can do so by shopping and applying online.
AARP offers a range of Medicare Supplement insurance plans to support you through your Medicare journey.
You can apply for these plans directly through AARP's website or by contacting their customer service team.
Their plans are designed to help you navigate the complexities of Medicare and provide you with the coverage you need.
A different take: Insurance Underwriting Plans Definition
Seamless Claims Process
A seamless claims process is just what you need when unexpected things happen. Our claims process is designed to be simple and fast.
With Aetna Simplified Claims Experience, your employees can get their cash benefits quickly. It's a streamlined process that uses medical data to avoid extra paperwork.
A unique perspective: Homeowners Insurance Underwriting Process
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bc8df/bc8df2f751e97e8b266b43f49c86e43ace7e3f1e" alt="Decorative cardboard illustration of signboard with Insurance title under umbrella in rain on blue background"
In fact, claims submission can be done in just 90 seconds. That's right, 90 seconds is all it takes to get the process started.
Our claims finder is a powerful tool that checks for other supplemental health benefits your members may be eligible for. It automatically processes those claims and even sends out targeted reminders based on medical data.
Members can also view coverage and manage claims on our supplemental app or portal. They can even sign up for direct deposit and chat with Member Services.
Here's a quick rundown of the benefits of our simplified claims experience:
- Easy file tool uses medical data to avoid extra paperwork
- Claims finder checks for other supplemental health benefits and automatically processes those claims
- Members can view coverage and manage claims on our supplemental app or portal
It's all part of our commitment to whole health – physical, emotional, social, and financial – and helping our members live happier, healthier lives.
Precertification Lists
Precertification Lists are used by insurance companies to verify the medical necessity of certain treatments or procedures. This list is usually pre-approved by the insurance company, which means that if a treatment is on the list, the insurance company will cover it.
Consider reading: List Health Insurance Companies
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09583/09583ee8cbf3e1b942ca0c7d2ce0517f5c7781e5" alt="Insurance Broker Presenting an Offer to an Elderly Couple"
The list typically includes treatments for common conditions such as joint replacement, spinal surgery, and certain types of cancer. These treatments are often deemed medically necessary by the insurance company.
Precertification Lists are usually available on the insurance company's website or through their customer service department. This allows patients to check if their treatment is covered before undergoing it.
Some insurance companies may also have a prior authorization process, which requires patients to get approval from the insurance company before receiving treatment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a supplemental for insurance?
A supplemental insurance plan provides extra medical coverage beyond your primary insurance, helping to cover unexpected expenses like copays, coinsurance, and deductibles. It's a safety net to ensure you're protected from surprise medical bills and out-of-pocket costs.
What is a supplemental payment insurance?
Supplemental payment insurance refers to extra financial help provided by an insurance company beyond the standard policy coverage. This additional support can provide extra peace of mind and financial security for policyholders
Sources
- https://www.investopedia.com/the-best-medicare-supplement-insurance-companies-8764684
- https://www.humana.com/medicare/medicare-supplement-plans
- https://www.uhc.com/medicare/medicare-education/medicare-supplement-plans.html
- https://www.aetna.com/health-insurance-plans/supplemental.html
- https://www.cigna.com/individuals-families/shop-plans/supplemental/
Featured Images: pexels.com