Stock Buyback vs Dividend: Understanding the Pros and Cons

Stock buybacks and dividends are two popular ways companies reward their shareholders. Companies can use their excess cash to buy back their own shares, reducing the number of outstanding shares and potentially increasing the value of each remaining share.

Share buybacks can be a strategic move to boost earnings per share, as seen in Apple's case where it repurchased over $25 billion worth of its own stock between 2012 and 2013. This move helped increase the company's earnings per share by 25%.

However, not all companies use their excess cash for share buybacks. Some prefer to distribute their cash to shareholders through dividends, providing a regular income stream. For instance, Johnson & Johnson has consistently paid dividends to its shareholders since 1944.

Expand your knowledge: What Are Stock Market Shares

A stock buyback, also known as a share repurchase, is when a company uses some of its cash to buy back its own shares on the open market.

This can be a way for a company to return excess cash to its shareholders. In the US, public companies are generally managed to maximize return for shareholders, so if a company is generating more cash than it needs, it might choose to return that excess cash to its shareholders through a buyback.

A company might choose to buy back its own stock if it feels the stock is undervalued, making it a good investment. Investors often perceive a buyback as an expression of confidence by the company.

There are several reasons a company might decide to buy back its own stock. These reasons include the belief that the stock is undervalued, a windfall of excess cash, or a desire to offset the dilution caused by generous employee stock-option plans.

Here are some key points to consider about share buybacks:

Stock buyback programs are a way for companies to raise their stock price by reducing the number of shares outstanding. This is because the remaining shares will be worth more, just like if a pie is cut into fewer slices, each slice will be bigger.

If this caught your attention, see: Stock Options vs Shares

Shareholders benefit indirectly from a buyback or repurchase program, as the goal is to raise the company's stock price. But it's not always a straightforward process.

The announcement of a share-repurchase program can sometimes give the stock a boost, before the company has bought any shares. This is because investors get excited about the potential for increased value.

However, sometimes there's unfavorable news or a shift in the market while the company is buying its own shares, which can cause the stock to trade lower. This can be frustrating for investors.

Generally speaking, a share-repurchase program will tend to boost the stock's price over time. This is because buybacks tend to improve some of the metrics that investors use to value a company.

A fresh viewpoint: How Are Stock Speculators Different from Stock Investors

Companies that engage in share buybacks may be buying back their shares at a high valuation, getting fewer shares for their money, and leaving less cash in reserve when their business slows.

If this caught your attention, see: What Are Stock Shares

Critics argue that companies tend to repurchase shares after a period of success, when they have plenty of cash, which can be a cyclical price peak. This can leave companies with less cash in reserve when their business slows.

Investors should also be cautious if the buyback appears motivated by management's desire to improve its valuation metrics, as this can be a form of metric manipulation.

A company that uses buybacks to create the appearance of quick growth in earnings per share may not be a company worth owning.

Here are some potential drawbacks of share buybacks:

In some cases, companies may use buybacks as a way to artificially increase earnings per share, which can lead to hefty bonuses for executives. Additionally, companies may buy back shares directly from insiders looking to cash in on lucrative stock options.

For another approach, see: Companies with Share Buybacks

Companies have two main options to distribute wealth back to shareholders: share buybacks and dividends. Share buybacks and dividends are two common ways companies can distribute profits to their shareholders.

You might like: Why Do Stock Splits Happen

Dividends are a more profitable option for investors than share buybacks. Unlike buybacks, which can start or stop at any time, most U.S.-based companies have a firm dividend policy.

Dividends offer shareholders the flexibility to collect cold, hard cash or buy more company shares through DRIPs. Shareholders have zero control over when company management decides to waste money on buybacks.

Higher dividend payments prevent companies from retaining too much cash, which can be wasted on foolish ventures like share repurchases. Instead, the company is focused on executing its business and keeping shareholders happy with steadily increasing dividends.

Here are some key differences between dividends and share buybacks:

Dividends are a great way for companies to attract long-term investors and decrease share price volatility. They're a "thank you" to shareholders and improve company visibility.

Boosting earnings per share (EPS) is a key reason companies opt for share buybacks, as it increases the ownership stake of existing shareholders and makes each share more valuable.

By reducing the number of outstanding shares, companies can increase EPS and make their stock more attractive to investors.

Share buybacks can also provide more flexibility for companies to adjust the amount and timing of capital returns based on market conditions and internal priorities.

This flexibility is particularly useful during times of financial stress, when a company may need to adjust its capital structure or support its stock price.

Companies may repurchase shares to prevent hostile takeovers or dilution of ownership, providing an added layer of security for existing shareholders.

A buyback can also signal to the market that the company believes its stock is undervalued, potentially attracting more investors and boosting the stock price.

Here are some key reasons why companies might choose to buy back their own shares:

Share buybacks can be a more tax-efficient way to return capital to shareholders compared to dividends, as shareholders have more control over when to realise the gains from selling their shares.

However, companies need to balance their use of dividends and share buybacks with other capital allocation decisions, such as investing in growth opportunities or maintaining a strong balance sheet.

The choice between stock buybacks and dividends is a strategic decision that requires careful consideration.

Investors need to think about their risk tolerance and income needs when evaluating these options.

Companies must balance their capital allocation decisions to maximize shareholder value, as the increasing popularity of stock buybacks over the past 20 years reflects the evolving dynamics of the corporate landscape.

The changing preferences of investors are driving this shift, and companies must adapt to stay competitive.

Ultimately, the right choice between stock buybacks and dividends depends on the company's specific circumstances and goals.

Investors should carefully evaluate these options and consider their own financial needs before making a decision.

A fresh viewpoint: Taxable Benefit vs Capital Gains Stock Options