Shareholder Value Explained: A Comprehensive Guide

Author

Posted Nov 4, 2024

Reads 836

Stock Market Trading App Displaying Financial Data
Credit: pexels.com, Stock Market Trading App Displaying Financial Data

Shareholder value is a measure of a company's financial performance that's of great interest to investors, and it's not just about the company's profits. It's a way to evaluate how well a company is using its resources to create value for its shareholders.

Shareholders are essentially the owners of a company, and their value is directly tied to the company's performance. In fact, research has shown that companies with high shareholder value tend to outperform those with lower shareholder value.

To understand shareholder value, let's take a look at its key components. The most common metric used to measure shareholder value is the market value of a company, which can be calculated by multiplying the number of outstanding shares by the current stock price.

Definition and Interpretation

Shareholder value is a term that can be used to refer to three main concepts. The market capitalization of a company is one of them, which is calculated by multiplying the number of outstanding shares by the current share price.

Credit: youtube.com, Shareholders and Stakeholders Compared in One Minute: Definition/Meaning, Explanation and Examples

The concept of shareholder value was introduced by Milton Friedman in 1970, also known as the Friedman doctrine. It emphasizes that a company's primary goal is to increase the wealth of its shareholders by paying dividends and/or causing the stock price to increase.

The term shareholder value was further refined by Alfred Rappaport in 1986 to mean that planned actions by management and the returns to shareholders should outperform certain benchmarks, such as the cost of capital concept.

Shareholder value is essentially the equity portion of a company's capitalization, as opposed to long-term debt. It can be calculated by multiplying the number of outstanding shares by the current share price, but this value can fluctuate based on various factors such as dividends and the issuance of shares.

Definition

The concept of shareholder value is multifaceted. It can refer to the market capitalization of a company, which is the total value of outstanding shares.

Credit: youtube.com, definitions and interpretation clause

Shareholder value is often associated with the idea that a company's primary goal is to increase the wealth of its shareholders. This concept was introduced by Milton Friedman in 1970, who argued that the sole responsibility of a business is to increase its profits.

There are different types of shareholder value, including the idea that planned actions by management should outperform certain benchmarks. This concept was introduced by Alfred Rappaport in 1986.

In a publicly traded company, shareholder value is the part of its capitalization that is equity, as opposed to long-term debt. This can be calculated by multiplying the number of outstanding shares by the current share price.

Shareholder value can be augmented by dividends, but issuing shares or stock options can lower it.

Interpretation

Interpretation is a crucial step in understanding the nuances of a concept. It involves breaking down complex information into manageable parts, making it easier to grasp.

The process of interpretation can be subjective, as it's influenced by personal experiences and perspectives. However, by considering multiple viewpoints, we can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the concept.

Credit: youtube.com, INTERPRETATION MEANING PART 1

According to our previous discussion, a key aspect of interpretation is identifying patterns and connections between ideas. This can be achieved by analyzing the relationships between different components of the concept.

A good example of this is the way we interpret the concept of "definition." By examining the various definitions provided, we can see how they relate to each other and how they contribute to a deeper understanding of the concept.

Interpretation also involves considering the context in which the concept is being applied. This means taking into account the specific circumstances and factors that affect its meaning.

For instance, in the case of the concept of "definition", the context in which it's being used can significantly impact its interpretation.

Agency Theory

Agency theory is the study of problems that arise when there's a disconnect between two cooperating parties: a principal and an agent. This can happen when there's a division of labor, a physical or temporal disconnect, or when the principal hires an agent for specialized expertise.

If this caught your attention, see: Which Expression Has a Value of 15 When N 7?

Credit: youtube.com, Differences between Agency Theory and Stakeholder Theory.

The principal-agent information gap is a significant issue, as agents can't be monitored perfectly by the principal, leading to agency costs. Agency costs include the costs to the principal of monitoring, the costs to the agent of bonding with the principal, and the residual loss due to the disconnect between the principal's interests and the agent's decisions.

Shareholder value theory aims to reform the governance of publicly owned firms to decrease the principal-agent information gap. This can be achieved by having an independent board, where the head of the board is someone other than the CEO, and the board is independently chosen.

An independent board can objectively monitor CEO undertakings and risk, which is essential for making informed decisions about investments. By making firms' finances available to scrutiny, shareholders can make informed choices about with whom to invest.

Here's a summary of the key points about agency theory:

  • Agency theory studies problems between a principal and an agent.
  • Agency costs include monitoring costs, bonding costs, and residual loss.
  • Shareholder value theory aims to reduce the principal-agent information gap.
  • An independent board can objectively monitor CEO undertakings and risk.

Management and Governance

Management should prioritize shareholder interests when making decisions, focusing on delivering shareholder returns and managing to achieve them. This principle is often referred to as Value-Based Management (VBM).

Credit: youtube.com, Should 'Shareholder Value' Rule Business Thinking?

Senior executives should set performance targets in terms of delivering shareholder returns, such as stock price and dividend payments. They should also consider the interests of other stakeholders, including employees, customers, and society.

A financial manager's main role is to maximize shareholder value by increasing wealth through metrics like share price, dividends, and capital gains. They can achieve this by optimizing areas like revenue growth, cost reductions, and working capital.

To maximize shareholder value, companies can use various tools, including Shareholder Value Maps that link departmental activities to one or several of the seven components of shareholder value. These components include revenue, operating margin, cash tax rate, and more.

Independent board members can enhance governance by objectively overseeing executives on behalf of shareholders. Annual director elections and proxy access empower shareholders to vote for governance that protects their interests.

Companies measure success in shareholder value maximization by increasing share price over time, providing regular dividend payments, and generating high returns on shareholder investments. Metrics like total shareholder return track performance.

Financial metrics that impact shareholder value include profitability, free cash flows, return on invested capital, and earnings per share. By monitoring and improving these metrics, corporations can quantify and maximize the value they create for shareholders.

Ultimately, directors must make judgments that aim to improve shareholder returns while considering what course of action is in the overall best interests of the corporation across multiple fronts.

Criticisms and Considerations

Credit: youtube.com, The Myth of Maximizing Shareholder Value

The sole concentration on shareholder value has been widely criticized, particularly after the 2007–2008 financial crisis. Critics argue that it doesn't provide a clear measure of social issues like employment, environmental issues, or ethical business practices.

A management decision can maximize shareholder value while lowering the welfare of third parties. The focus on shareholder value has also been criticized for lowering the overall rate of economic growth due to reduced business capital accumulation.

Marc Benioff, CEO of Salesforce, said that the obsession with maximizing profits for shareholders has brought us terrible economic, racial, and health inequalities; the catastrophe of climate change. The failure of the corporation to readily fit within the neoclassical economic model is a frequently-targeted flaw by critics.

The concept of shareholders and subsequently shareholder value was developed primarily for the purpose of shoehorning the insertion of the corporation into the neoclassical economic model, ignoring the fact that the neoclassical model was never designed to operate with the number of inputs the modern corporation requires.

Limitations of Neoclassical Economics Modelling

Credit: youtube.com, Critique of Neoclassical Economics | Jonathan Newman

The neoclassical economic model, a cornerstone of contemporary economics, has its limitations. This model was originally created in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, before the proliferation of corporate organization.

One of the main criticisms of the neoclassical economic model is its failure to accurately represent the modern corporation. Anthropologist Karen Ho argues that the concept of shareholders was developed primarily to shoehorn the corporation into this model.

The neoclassical model hinges on the idea of the owner-entrepreneur being directly involved in the management and operation of their enterprise. However, the modern shareholder typically has limited or no connection to the regular operations of a corporation.

Adam Smith, a founding figure of neoclassical economics, noted that managed corporations were not viable due to this issue. He stated that directors of joint stock companies, being managers of other people's money, cannot be expected to watch over it with the same vigilance as partners in a private copartnery.

This limitation of the neoclassical economic model has significant implications for how we understand corporate interest and shareholder value. Critics argue that the failure to accurately represent the key neoclassical owner-entrepreneur concept leads to an inaccurate assumption that corporate interest remained identical to shareholder interest.

Additional reading: Outline of Corporate Finance

Criticism

Credit: youtube.com, Ethical Considerations in Business Analysis | iCert Global

The sole concentration on shareholder value has been widely criticized, particularly after the 2007-2008 financial crisis. This focus on shareholder value can benefit the owners of a corporation financially, but it doesn't provide a clear measure of social issues like employment, environmental issues, or ethical business practices.

Critics argue that a focus on shareholder value can lead to a neglect of more profitable long-term strategies, resulting in reduced economic growth and increased inequality. Marc Benioff, CEO of Salesforce, said that "[...] the obsession with maximizing profits for shareholders has brought us: terrible economic, racial and health inequalities; the catastrophe of climate change."

The short-term nature of shareholder value theory is one of the features focused on by critics. They argue that this fixation on the short term leads to neglect of more profitable long-term strategies, causing companies to underinvest in areas like R&D that are vital for innovation and sustainable growth.

From above of United States currency folded in roll placed on USA flag illustrating concept of business profit and wealth
Credit: pexels.com, From above of United States currency folded in roll placed on USA flag illustrating concept of business profit and wealth

Critics also point out that the reliance on the process of assessing stock is vulnerable to manipulation and speculation. Speculating on the firm's stock price is in the interest of managers that receive stock compensation and may therefore cause them to focus on speculating on the stock price rather than maximizing real production.

The failure of the corporation to readily fit within the neo-classical economic model is a frequently-targeted flaw by critics. Anthropologist Karen Ho argues that the concept of shareholders and subsequently shareholder value was developed primarily for the purpose of shoehorning the insertion of the corporation into the neoclassical economic model, and ignores that the neoclassical model was never designed to operate with the number of inputs the modern corporation requires.

The loss of growth and productivity is another criticism of shareholder value. Despite decades of research and dozens of studies, there is negligible strong evidence that shareholder value theory has produced better results for businesses.

Sustainability

Credit: youtube.com, Are We the Last Generation — or the First Sustainable One? | Hannah Ritchie | TED

Sustainability is a crucial aspect of business, and it's not just about being a good corporate citizen. Sustainability helps mitigate risks and ensures stable cash flows for long-term value creation.

However, it's essential to remember that social initiatives must have a clear link to financial returns and undergo the same ROI analysis as other projects. This means that sustainability efforts should be just as scrutinized as any other business decision.

In fact, a stable cash flow is just one of the benefits of prioritizing sustainability. CSR builds reputation and customer loyalty, which ultimately supports profitability.

Here's a key takeaway: sustainability is not a separate entity from financial performance, but rather a critical component of it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the benefits of high shareholder value?

High shareholder value can lead to increased profits and shareholder returns through future expansion efforts. It also reduces a company's financial risk, making it a more stable investment.

Sources

  1. The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits (nytimes.com)
  2. "Why the Stock Market is Rising Amidst a Pandemic and Record, Racialized Inequality" (americanethnologist.org)
  3. 1556-5068 (worldcat.org)
  4. 10.2139/ssrn.3541993 (doi.org)
  5. 10.1080/030851400360541 (doi.org)
  6. 1251799 (jstor.org)
  7. 10.1177/002224299806200102 (doi.org)
  8. "Market-Based Assets and Shareholder Value: A Framework for Analysis" (smu.edu.sg)
  9. 1097-0266 (worldcat.org)
  10. 10.1002/1097-0266(200101)22:2<125::aid-smj150>3.0.co;2-h (doi.org)
  11. Liquidated : an ethnography of Wall Street (worldcat.org)
  12. "The Economist Who Put Stock Buybacks in Washington's Crosshairs" (newyorker.com)
  13. 10.1023/A:1006438000855 (doi.org)
  14. "Making Sense Of Shareholder Value: 'The World's Dumbest Idea'" (forbes.com)
  15. 10.7312/star17015-011 (doi.org)
  16. "10. Maximizing Shareholder Value: The Goal that Changed Corporate America" (doi.org)
  17. "Greed Is Good. Except When It's Bad" (nytimes.com)
  18. "eBay v. Newmark: Al Franken Was Right, Corporations Are Legally Required To Maximize Profits" (litigationandtrial.com)
  19. 10.1108/eb054614 (doi.org)
  20. Valuation Methods and Shareholder Value Creation (google.com)
  21. "What is value-based management?" (mckinsey.com)
  22. Customer Value, Shareholder Wealth, Community Wellbeing: A Roadmap for Companies and Investors (google.com)
  23. 10.1016/0304-405X(76)90026-X (doi.org)
  24. "Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure" (fgv.br)
  25. "Corporations Don't Have to Maximize Profits" (nytimes.com)
  26. "Corporate Malfeasance and the Myth of Shareholder Value" (harvard.edu)
  27. "The Historical Context of Shareholder Value Capitalism" (harvard.edu)
  28. Customer Value, Shareholder Wealth, Community Wellbeing: A Roadmap for Companies and Investors (google.com)
  29. "The Misapplication of Mr. Michael Jensen: How Agency Theory Brought Down the Economy and Why it Might Again" (harvard.edu)
  30. Financial Management (google.com)
  31. Customer Value, Shareholder Wealth, Community Wellbeing: A Roadmap for Companies and Investors (google.com)
  32. "The 'Pernicious Nonsense' Of Maximizing Shareholder Value" (forbes.com)
  33. Creating Shareholder Value: The New Standard for Business Performance (google.com)
  34. Stakeholders vs. shareholders in corporate governance (uni-muenchen.de)
  35. 10.1111/j.1745-6622.1994.tb00247.x (doi.org)
  36. "Corporate Governance or Corporate Value Added?: Rethinking the Primacy of Shareholder Value" (uml.edu)
  37. Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies, University Edition (google.com)
  38. The CEO, Strategy, and Shareholder Value: Making the Choices That Maximize Company Performance (google.com)
  39. 279507 (ssrn.com)
  40. 10.1111/1468-0416.00038 (doi.org)
  41. 1354149 (ssrn.com)
  42. 10.1111/j.1475-6803.2010.01278.x (doi.org)
  43. Shareholder Value Maximization: Finance Explained (vintti.com)
  44. LinkedIn (linkedin.com)
  45. Saving Capitalism from Short-Termism: How to Build Long-Term Value and Take Back Our Financial Future (amazon.com)
  46. What Is Shareholder Value? (fool.com)

Carlos Bartoletti

Writer

Carlos Bartoletti is a seasoned writer with a keen interest in exploring the intricacies of modern work life. With a strong background in research and analysis, Carlos crafts informative and engaging content that resonates with readers. His writing expertise spans a range of topics, with a particular focus on professional development and industry trends.