Portfolio Insurance: Protecting Your Investments

Author

Reads 11.8K

Research Paper on Trading Strategies Beside Calculator and Laptop
Credit: pexels.com, Research Paper on Trading Strategies Beside Calculator and Laptop

Portfolio insurance is a strategy that can help protect your investments from market downturns. By reducing your portfolio's exposure to risk, you can safeguard your wealth and ensure a more stable financial future.

One way to implement portfolio insurance is to use a stop-loss order, which automatically sells a portion of your portfolio when it falls below a certain threshold. This can help limit your losses and prevent significant declines in value.

In practice, stop-loss orders can be set at a percentage of your portfolio's value, such as 10% or 20%. This means that if your portfolio drops by 10% or 20%, the stop-loss order will kick in and sell a portion of your holdings to limit further losses.

By using portfolio insurance, you can enjoy greater peace of mind and confidence in your investment decisions.

What Is Portfolio Insurance?

Portfolio insurance is a strategy that helps protect your investments from market risks. It was developed by Mark Rubinstein and Hayne Leland in 1976.

Credit: youtube.com, Portfolio Insurance

This technique involves short-selling stock index futures to limit potential losses if the stocks in your portfolio decline in value. You don't have to sell off your actual stocks to achieve this protection.

Portfolio insurance can also refer to brokerage insurance, such as the kind offered by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC).

Benefits and History

Portfolio insurance can protect investors from unexpected market downturns. Unexpected developments, such as wars, shortages, or pandemics, can cause significant losses.

The benefits of portfolio insurance include avoiding most or all losses from a bad market swing. This can be achieved through SIPC insurance or a market hedging strategy.

Investors who hedge the market can let unneeded put options expire if the market continues to perform well.

Benefits

Unexpected market swings can be devastating to investors, but portfolio insurance can help mitigate losses. Unexpected developments like wars, shortages, or pandemics can plunge the entire market into free fall.

Person Holding Insurance Policy Contract
Credit: pexels.com, Person Holding Insurance Policy Contract

Portfolio insurance can protect investors from market downturns. Most or all of the losses from a bad market swing can be avoided through strategies like SIPC insurance or market hedging.

Investors who hedge the market can benefit from unneeded put options expiring. If the market continues going strong, underlying stocks continue gaining in value, and the investor can simply let the unneeded put options expire.

1987 Stock Market Crash

The 1987 Stock Market Crash was a pivotal event in financial history, and it's essential to understand what led to it. Both portfolio insurance and index arbitrage were implicated in the crash, with some research suggesting they played a significant role.

The Committee of Inquiry under the Chicago Mercantile Exchange found that larger forces like mutual funds, broker-dealers, and individual shareholders were more influential in the market selloff.

Portfolio insurance was heavily criticized for being oversold as a protection strategy, with some committee members believing its marketing was misleading.

The use of portfolio insurance was widely criticized after the crash, and its limitations were demonstrated.

Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance

Credit: youtube.com, What is a Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance (CPPI) strategy?

Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance (CPPI) is a type of portfolio insurance that allows an investor to maintain exposure to the upside potential of a risky asset while providing a capital guarantee against downside risk.

The CPPI strategy is based on two asset classes: a risky asset (usually equities or mutual funds) and a conservative asset (such as cash, equivalents, or treasury bonds). The percentage allocated to each depends on the "cushion" value, defined as the current portfolio value minus the floor value, and a multiplier coefficient.

CPPI can be thought of as a convex strategy, as opposed to a "concave strategy" like constant mix. This means that CPPI is designed to provide a higher return when the market is rising, while protecting the investor's capital when the market is falling.

A CPPI strategy typically consists of two accounts: a risk account and a safety account. The risk account is leveraged with futures holdings to protect against the downside of significant equity exposure.

For your interest: Investor Relations Strategy

Credit: youtube.com, What is Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance (CPPI) ?

The value of the multiplier is based on the investor's risk profile and is derived by first asking what the maximum one-day loss could be on the risky investment. The multiplier will be the inverse of that percentage.

CPPI is often implemented over five-year terms, with the cushion value growing over time to allow for more money to flow into the risky asset. However, if the cushion drops, the investor may need to sell a portion of the risky asset to keep the asset allocation targets intact.

The CPPI strategy can be complex, with the percentage of the portfolio invested in the risky asset varying over time. This can make it difficult to predict the average return and variance of a CPPI strategy.

A hypothetical CPPI strategy over a five-year investment time horizon would have underperformed the S&P 500 for several years after the 2008 financial crisis.

In a CPPI strategy, the value of assets in the risky portfolio is calculated as Vrisky=m⋅ ⋅ (V− − F), where Vrisky is the value of assets in the risky portfolio, V is the starting value of assets in the total portfolio, F is the asset level below which the total portfolio should not fall, and m≥ ≥ 1 is the multiplier.

Take a look at this: Time Consistency (finance)

Credit: youtube.com, What are Structured Products? (Part 2) CPPI Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance

The average return and variance of a CPPI strategy can be calculated using the formulas μ μ CPPI=F/Vert− − rTV+CeTr+Tmμ μ − − Tmr and σ σ CPPI2=C2e2T(r+mμ μ − − mr)(eTm2σ σ 2− − 1), respectively.

A CPPI strategy can be rebalanced at the end of each period to increase exposure on the outperforming asset and reduce exposure to the worst-performing asset. This can be done using a fixed ratio, such as 120:60:620, to maintain the original fixed weights.

A unique perspective: Buy and Hold Strategy

Key Concepts and Strategies

CPPI is a strategy that combines equity market exposure with conservative investments by allocating a calculated percentage to a risk account. This allows investors to balance potential gains with reduced risk.

A key feature of CPPI is the use of a multiplier to determine the amount of risk an investor is willing to take on. This helps to fine-tune the investment approach to suit individual risk tolerance.

Credit: youtube.com, Portfolio Insurance and Chasing Deltas in a Market Crash

Investors can rebalance their holdings on a monthly or quarterly basis, which helps to maintain their desired risk level and optimize returns.

Portfolio insurance is a hedging technique used by institutional investors to protect against market volatility. This involves using financial instruments like equities, debts, and derivatives to minimize potential losses.

Here are some common types of portfolio insurance strategies:

  • Short selling index futures to offset downturns
  • Buying and selling securities periodically to maintain a limit on the portfolio value
  • Using listed index options or buying index put options

The Securities Investor Protection Act (SIPA) provides a safety net for brokerage customers, offering up to $500,000 coverage for cash and securities held by a firm. This includes a $250,000 limit for cash only.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the disadvantages of portfolio insurance?

Portfolio insurance can limit potential returns and outcomes, reducing the possibility of higher returns. This is a key consideration for investors weighing the benefits and drawbacks of this strategy

How did portfolio insurance work?

Portfolio insurance worked by using computer models to adjust stock-to-cash ratios in response to changing market conditions, allowing the total portfolio value to fluctuate while the number of owned shares remained relatively stable. This strategy aimed to minimize losses and maximize gains in a dynamic market environment.

Does portfolio insurance still exist?

Yes, portfolio insurance still exists, but its cost has increased due to wider adoption by investors and financial institutions. The strategy's use of put options on the S&P 500 index has reached historically high levels in recent years.

Sheldon Kuphal

Writer

Sheldon Kuphal is a seasoned writer with a keen insight into the world of high net worth individuals and their financial endeavors. With a strong background in researching and analyzing complex financial topics, Sheldon has established himself as a trusted voice in the industry. His areas of expertise include Family Offices, Investment Management, and Private Wealth Management, where he has written extensively on the latest trends, strategies, and best practices.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.