What Is a Mutual Bank and How Does It Work

Author

Reads 3.6K

A contemporary city skyline featuring tall buildings and a prominent bank at dusk.
Credit: pexels.com, A contemporary city skyline featuring tall buildings and a prominent bank at dusk.

A mutual bank is a type of financial institution owned by its customers, not shareholders. This unique ownership structure sets it apart from traditional banks.

Mutual banks operate on a not-for-profit basis, meaning they don't aim to maximize profits for shareholders. Instead, they focus on serving their customers' financial needs.

In a mutual bank, decision-making power lies with the customers, not outside investors. This ensures that the bank's priorities align with the needs of its members.

What is a Mutual Bank

A mutual bank is a type of bank that operates differently from traditional banks. It's owned by its depositors, not shareholders, which means that profits go back to the depositors, not investors.

Mutual banks prioritize security and stability, which is why they've historically been conservative in their investments. This approach allowed them to remain stable during the Great Depression, while many commercial banks and savings and loan associations failed.

In Australia, several building societies converted to banks in the 1980s, but were required to demutualize, or give up their mutual status. However, a change in regulation in 2011 allowed some building societies to convert to banks while retaining their mutual status.

Credit: youtube.com, Who owns your bank? The Mutual Bank

Mutual savings banks have a single purpose: to protect deposits, make limited investments, and provide depositors with interest. They don't have stockholders, so any profits beyond running costs go to the depositors.

Here are some key facts about mutual banks:

  • Owned by depositors, not shareholders
  • Prioritize security and stability
  • Conservative in investments
  • Profits go to depositors, not investors

Benefits of Mutual Banks

Mutual banks are unique in their approach to banking. They prioritize customers over traditional shareholders, focusing on providing excellent service.

This customer-centric approach sets mutual banks apart from traditional shareholder-owned banks. At Home Bank, for example, they have a gifting program that demonstrates their commitment to their customers.

By investing in customer service, mutual banks aim to build strong relationships with their customers, which can lead to long-term loyalty and trust.

No Direct Ownership

Mutual banks are not owned by any one individual or entity. Instead, they are owned by their depositors.

Their depositors have no vote in how the bank operates, setting them apart from other financial institutions. This unique structure allows mutual banks to prioritize their customers' needs above all else.

Unlike credit unions, mutual institutions are for-profit and pay state and federal taxes. This means they provide benefits to their depositors in the form of competitive interest rates on deposits and loans.

Prioritizing Customers Over Shareholders

Credit: youtube.com, What Are Mutual Savings Banks? - AssetsandOpportunity.org

Mutual banks put their customers first, making decisions that focus on their needs and happiness. This is in contrast to traditional shareholder-owned banks, where profits are distributed to shareholders.

At mutual banks, profits are reinvested in the bank to improve service and benefits for customers, rather than being paid out as dividends. This means customers get better rates on their deposits and loans, and access to more amenities.

At Home Bank, for example, they have a gifting program that demonstrates their commitment to prioritizing customers. This is just one way mutual banks show they care about their customers' well-being.

By not being owned by any one individual or entity, mutual banks are able to make decisions that benefit their customers, rather than just maximizing profits for a select few. This allows them to focus on building long-term relationships with their customers.

Mutual banks are owned by their depositors, who receive benefits in the form of competitive interest rates and access to amenities. This unique ownership structure sets mutual banks apart from other types of banks.

Community Focus

Credit: youtube.com, Community Banks: Community Focused

Mutual banks are chartered to benefit their local communities, prioritizing their communities over profits.

Their smaller footprint means they have a strong incentive to build meaningful relationships with customers and neighbors, as they are located right in town.

Mutual banks provide accessible banking services to local consumers and businesses in the form of deposits, loans, and other financial instruments.

Community-Based

Mutual banks are chartered to benefit their local communities. As such, their main purpose is to provide accessible banking services to local consumers and businesses in the form of deposits, loans, and other financial instruments.

They tend to invest in their communities by working with local organizations and businesses. This means that mutual banks often have a deep understanding of the local economy and can provide tailored financial solutions to meet the needs of their customers.

By serving a smaller area, mutual banks prioritize their communities. This smaller footprint allows them to build meaningful relationships with their customers and neighbors.

Mutual banks aim to be a connection to their community, much like your local bank is a connection to your neighborhood.

Banking in Australia

Credit: youtube.com, REGIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK : Test & Review in 2024 (is this bank reliable?)

In Australia, the banking landscape has undergone significant changes over the years. Several building societies converted to banks in the 1980s, but were required to demutualize in the process.

Some notable examples of building societies that converted to banks include Advance Bank, St. George, Suncorp, Metway Bank, Challenge Bank, Bank of Melbourne, and Bendigo Bank. These institutions were forced to demutualize when they converted to banks.

However, a change in regulation in 2011 meant that building societies and credit unions were no longer required to demutualize upon converting to banks. As a result, several institutions, including Heritage Bank, have converted while retaining their status and structure as mutual organizations.

Mutual savings banks in Australia prioritize security and have historically been conservative in their investments. This approach allowed them to remain stable during the Great Depression, while commercial banks and savings and loan associations failed.

One notable feature of mutual savings banks is that they have no stockholders. Instead, the entirety of profits beyond the upkeep of the bank belongs to the depositors of the mutual savings bank. This unique structure sets them apart from commercial banks.

Mutual savings banks were designed to stimulate savings by individuals, and their primary function is to protect deposits, make limited, secure investments, and provide depositors with interest.

Pittsfield Cooperative Plans Absorption

Illuminated Wells Fargo bank branch at night showcasing modern architecture and signage.
Credit: pexels.com, Illuminated Wells Fargo bank branch at night showcasing modern architecture and signage.

Pittsfield Cooperative Bank is planning to absorb Arrha Credit Union in Springfield, Massachusetts.

This move is a significant development in the community, with the credit union applying to merge into the cooperative bank.

Arrha Credit Union will be dissolved as a separate entity after the merger, with its assets and operations becoming part of Pittsfield Cooperative Bank.

The merged entity will be operated as a division of Ion Bank, according to the plans.

Security and History

Mutual banks have a long history of providing financial security to their depositors. They were first established in Scotland in 1810 by Rev. Henry Duncan as a friendly society to enable his poorest parishioners to hold savings accounts accruing interest.

These early savings banks were designed to uplift the poor and working classes, teaching them the virtues of thrift and self-reliance. The first incorporated US mutual savings bank was the Provident Institution for Savings in Boston, chartered in 1816.

Of the approximately 350 banks that have failed since 2007, only 12 were mutual banks, according to America's Mutual Banks. This is a testament to the stability and security of mutual banks.

Security

Steel Heavy Doors of Vault
Credit: pexels.com, Steel Heavy Doors of Vault

Security is a top priority for mutual banks. They tend to be more fiscally conservative than large commercial banks, choosing stable investments to support their depositors.

Only 12 mutual banks have failed since 2007, out of approximately 350 bank failures during that time. This is a testament to their cautious approach to banking.

Mutual banks don't have shareholders, which means they're not pressured to grow at the same rate as commercial banks. This autonomy allows them to prioritize the financial security of their depositors over short-term profits.

Their focus on stability has earned them a reputation as a safe and secure option for depositors.

History

The history of savings banks is a fascinating story that dates back to 1810 when Rev. Henry Duncan of the Ruthwell Presbyterian Church in Scotland established the first modern savings bank, the "Savings and Friendly Society". This institution was designed to help the poor and working classes save their money and accrue interest for sickness and old-age.

The Lombard Bank Building in Sliema, Malta
Credit: pexels.com, The Lombard Bank Building in Sliema, Malta

The concept of savings banks quickly spread to other parts of Europe and eventually to the United States, where the first incorporated US mutual savings bank, the Provident Institution for Savings in Boston, was chartered in 1816. This was a significant milestone as it was the first government legislation in the world to safeguard savings banks.

The oldest and largest mutual bank in the US, Eastern Bank of Boston, was chartered in 1818 in Salem, Massachusetts, as the Salem Savings Bank. It had approximately $10 billion in assets in 2015, making it a significant player in the banking industry.

In the 1970s, the industry was deregulated, leading to thousands of mutual savings banks converting into stock ownership companies, raising more than $40 billion. This trend continued, and by 2010, only about 600 mutual savings banks remained.

First Federal Bank & Trust, a mutual bank founded in 1935 in Sheridan, Wyoming, is a great example of a bank that has remained true to its mutual roots. As a mutual bank, it doesn't pay stockholders, and instead invests in the community.

Massachusetts Insurers Merge Under Single Holding Company

Male customer using Chase ATM machine in an urban indoor setting.
Credit: pexels.com, Male customer using Chase ATM machine in an urban indoor setting.

Cape Cod 5 in Hyannis, Massachusetts, and Fidelity Bank in Leominster, Massachusetts, are merging under the same holding company.

This merger brings two local banks together, creating a stronger financial presence in the region.

Cape Cod 5 and Fidelity Bank are combining under a single holding company, a move that will likely benefit both banks and their customers.

Their merger will likely lead to increased financial stability and security for the communities they serve.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a mutual bank and a regular bank?

Mutual banks are owned by customers, not shareholders, which can lead to lower fees and higher interest rates. They often serve smaller communities, offering a unique banking experience

Who owns mutual banks?

Mutual banks are owned by their depositors, who have a direct stake in the bank's operations and profits. This unique ownership structure is a key characteristic of mutual banks.

Greg Brown

Senior Writer

Greg Brown is a seasoned writer with a keen interest in the world of finance. With a focus on investment strategies, Greg has established himself as a knowledgeable and insightful voice in the industry. Through his writing, Greg aims to provide readers with practical advice and expert analysis on various investment topics.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.