
Insurance claim theft is a growing concern for many policyholders.
The average cost of a fraudulent insurance claim is $30,000.
It's essential to understand your coverage to avoid falling victim to insurance claim theft.
Insurance companies typically have a process in place to investigate claims, which can take several weeks or even months.
Preparing for and Responding to Theft
Save your receipts and document your purchases, it will make things easier if you ever have to file an insurance claim for stolen items.
It's a good idea to take an inventory of your personal property, which can be done by creating a checklist grouped by category, value, room in your home, etc.
Keep the original sales receipts for important items, especially if they are covered for Replacement Cost Value. This will help you prove ownership and value of the stolen items.
You should also take pictures of your things, create an inventory checklist, or make a video of your items, and store your records in a safe spot like a safe, online repository, or fire-proof box.
Here's a list of things to include in your inventory checklist, grouped by category:
- Furniture
- Electronics
- Jewelry
- Valuables
- Important documents
Remember, the more organized you are, the easier it will be to file an insurance claim if you ever need to.
Filing Your Claim

Filing your claim is a crucial step in the insurance claim process. You'll need to call your insurance company promptly after filing a police report to report your claim.
Using a pre-made inventory sheet as a checklist can help you quickly discern what's out of place or damaged. This will make it easier to provide the necessary information to your insurance company.
Your claims report should include the following information about your damaged or stolen property: the type of property, its value, and any relevant details about the damage or theft.
Don't get rid of any damaged property in your home, as your adjuster may need to review it to complete your claim.
Car Insurance and Theft
If your car is stolen, it's essential to inform your insurance company right away. This is the first step in the process of getting your car replaced or repaired.
You'll need to answer questions from your insurance company, such as where you last parked your car, if you filed a report with the police, and if you have a tracking device installed in your car. These questions are standard and help your insurance company investigate the claim.
Most insurance companies have a waiting period of anywhere from one week to one month to see if the car is recovered. If it's not, you're entitled to the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of your stolen car.
Is Theft Covered?

Comprehensive coverage is the key to protecting yourself against car theft. This type of coverage helps pay for damages to your car not caused by a collision with another car or object.
If your insurance policy includes comprehensive coverage, you're likely covered in case of vehicle theft. Comprehensive insurance is meant to cover damage caused by non-collision events.
Comprehensive insurance is an optional add-on, and not offered in most standard insurance policies. So, it's essential to check with your insurer to find out if you're covered in case of car theft.
Some examples of what comprehensive coverage might cover include natural disasters and storms, fires, theft, vandalism, and damage caused by animals.
Here are some examples of what comprehensive coverage might cover:
- Natural disasters and storms
- Fires
- Theft
- Vandalism
- Damage caused by animals
If your insurance policy offers only liability and collision, it will not protect you if your car is stolen. Review your policy and consult with a licensed insurance professional to learn more about your coverage.
Does Car Cover Stolen Car Belongings?

Your car's insurance may not cover the personal property stolen from it, especially if it's under comprehensive coverage. Instead, look to your homeowners or renters insurance for coverage.
In many cases, stolen items from a car are not covered under comprehensive insurance. This can catch people off guard, especially if they didn't realize they needed separate coverage.
You might be surprised to find that your car insurance doesn't automatically cover your belongings. It's essential to review your policies and understand what's covered and what's not.
Gap Insurance for Stolen Cars
If your car is stolen, comprehensive coverage can only pay up to the fair market value of the car at the time of theft.
You could owe more than what your car is worth if it can't be recovered and you financed or leased it.
Owing money on a stolen car is a stressful situation, but Loan/Lease Gap coverage can help by paying for the difference between what your car is worth and what you still owe on it.
This coverage can free you from making payments on a car you can no longer drive, giving you peace of mind.
Investigation and Eligibility
To investigate a potential insurance claim theft, you'll need to review your policy documents carefully. This will help you understand the specific terms and conditions of your coverage.
The insurance company will also investigate the claim, which may involve verifying the information you provided and checking for any inconsistencies. They may also request additional documentation or evidence to support your claim.
A common red flag for insurance claim theft is a sudden and unexpected increase in claims activity. If you've never filed a claim before and suddenly have multiple claims in a short period, it may raise suspicions.
My Property Stolen: Company Investigating Me
If your insurance company is investigating you after reporting your property stolen, it's not uncommon to feel frustrated or concerned. You'll likely be asked questions to verify your claim, and it's essential to be prepared.
You may be asked where you last parked your car, so having a clear answer to this question can help speed up the process. The police report you filed will also be a crucial piece of evidence.

Your insurance company will likely investigate the claim to determine if you were involved in the theft of your property. They may ask if you filed a police report, which is a necessary step in the process.
Keep in mind that most insurance companies have a waiting period of anywhere from one week to one month to see if your property is recovered. If it's not recovered, you're entitled to the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of your stolen property.
Here's what you can expect to be asked during the investigation:
- Where did you last park your car?
- Did you file a report with the police?
- Do you have a tracking device installed in your car?
Are You Deserving It?
The first settlement offer an insurance company makes is often not the best it can do. They might not mention additional money that may be available.
Your insurance policy may cover costs beyond the stolen vehicle, such as personal items within the car. This is why it's essential to review your policy carefully.
Insurance companies won't always reveal all the possible compensation you're entitled to. It's like they're holding back a secret.
A trusted network of experts and appraisers can help present a strong case for a higher settlement. This can make a big difference in the outcome of your claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does insurance go up after a theft claim?
Yes, insurance premiums often increase after a theft claim, as the insurance company must pay for the claim and pass on the costs to policyholders. This is a common practice in the insurance industry.
How do insurance companies value stolen items?
Insurance companies value stolen items at their replacement cost, which is the current price to buy a similar item of the same quality. This ensures you're reimbursed enough to replace the item with a new one of comparable value.
Sources
- https://www.homesite.com/insurance-resources/home-insurance-articles/what-to-expect-when-filing-a-theft-claim.htm
- https://www.erbelaw.com/blog/2024/3/22/my-property-was-stolen-why-is-my-insurance-company-investigating-me
- https://www.plymouthrock.com/resources/does-insurance-cover-a-stolen-car
- https://www.brehnelaw.com/stolen-vehicle-and-theft-claims/
- https://providenceprotects.com/blog/if-something-is-stolen-from-your-car-is-it-covered-by-your-auto-or-home-policy/
Featured Images: pexels.com