Understanding Hedge Fund Replication and Its Benefits

Hedge fund replication is a strategy that allows investors to gain exposure to the performance of a hedge fund without actually investing in it. This is done by creating a portfolio of stocks, bonds, or other securities that mimic the hedge fund's investment strategy.

A key benefit of hedge fund replication is that it allows investors to access the same investment opportunities as hedge funds, but with lower fees. This is because hedge fund managers charge high fees, often in the range of 1-2% of assets under management, plus a performance fee of 10-20%.

Replicating a hedge fund's strategy can be complex, as it requires identifying the underlying securities and weights that make up the fund's portfolio. However, with the help of advanced analytics and data tools, investors can create a highly accurate replica of a hedge fund's performance.

Related reading: Renaissance Technologies Fees

Replication models are used to analyze hedge fund performance and create clones that mimic their returns. The fixed-weight model is one such approach, which uses an ordinary least squares algorithm to constrain regression coefficients to sum to one, giving an optimized portfolio where beta coefficients are interpreted as factor weights.

The fixed-weight model is used in a study that analyzes 1495 hedge funds with monthly returns from August 1996 to September 2008. The study compares the performance of clones developed using this model to the original funds and clones constructed from general factors.

The ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) is an example of a replication model that tracks the performance of the Merrill Lynch Factor Model – Exchange Series. This model uses factors such as the S&P 500, Russell 2000, and MSCI Emerging Markets to replicate the risk and return characteristics of the hedge fund asset class.

The barriers to entry in the asset management industry are not particularly high, which explains why there are thousands of investment products competing for the attention and assets of investors.

I've noticed that many investment products try to copy successful strategies, but not all strategies can be copied easily. U.S.-focused private equity funds, for example, provide the same exposure to the U.S. economy as the S&P 500, but smoothened valuations of private assets are difficult to replicate in public markets.

A unique perspective: Types of Private Investment Funds

There have been various attempts to replicate hedge funds given their high fees and offer these as ETFs to even retail investors. Two ETFs that provide exposure to the broader hedge fund indices are the ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) and iMGP DBi Hedge Strategy ETF (DBEH).

The ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) manages $32 million of assets and charges 0.95% per annum, compared to $33m and 0.85% per annum for the iMGP DBi Hedge Strategy ETF (DBEH). The fees for these ETFs are high compared to plain-vanilla ETFs, but low when contrasted to traditional hedge funds that typically charge more than 1.5% plus a performance fee.

Here's a comparison of the two ETFs:

It's worth noting that hedge fund replication ETFs have reasonably well replicated hedge fund index returns, but it's questionable if these hedge fund indices are worth replicating.

Factor replication strategies are based on the idea of "hedge fund beta" – identifying the market risk exposures that comprise hedge fund returns.

Funds that utilize factor replication strategies can have much lower minimums than traditional hedge funds, making them more accessible to investors.

The ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) is an example of a fund that uses factor replication to track the performance of the Merrill Lynch Factor Model – Exchange Series.

This model is designed to provide the risk and return characteristics of the hedge fund asset class, with a high correlation to an index that tracks hedge fund industry performance.

The HFRI Fund Weighted Composite Index, which makes up the index tracked by the ETF, is composed of 2,000 equally weighted constituent funds.

The replication model used by the ETF includes factors such as the S&P 500, Russell 2000, MSCI EAFE, MSCI Emerging Markets, ProShares UltraShort Euro ETF, and 3-month Treasury Bills.

The ETF has an expense ratio of 0.95% and has provided a total return of 2.6% on an annualized basis since its inception in 2011.

Factor replication allows investors to gain exposure to the hedge fund asset class at a lower cost and with more transparency than traditional hedge funds.

By using a weighted basket of public market instruments to replicate the returns of hedge funds, factor replication strategies can provide a more efficient and accessible way to invest in this asset class.

A fresh viewpoint: Investment Strategies for Hedge Fund Managers

The rolling window model uses a 24-month rolling window regression to estimate the portfolio weights of the risk factors. This makes it a more dynamic model compared to the fixed weight model.

Rebalancing in the rolling window model is done each month for every clone. This is a key feature that allows the model to adapt to changing market conditions.

The rolling window model requires the calibration of the 24-month rolling window regression and renormalization factor. This is a critical step that affects the performance of the model.

As a result, the first 47 months are excluded from the performance comparison of the funds and clones. This is a trade-off made to ensure the accuracy of the model.

The rolling window model is suitable for investors who want to actively rebalance their portfolios. This approach can help capture the non-stationary nature in the hedge fund return series.

Convertible arbitrage is a relative value strategy that focuses on capturing inefficiencies in the convertible bond market. Around $40 billion was under management in convertible arbitrage funds as of 2010.

This strategy involves going long a convertible bond and taking a short position in the underlying stock. Hedging only equity risk is more characteristic of convertible arbitrage hedge funds.

The convertible bond market is very illiquid, making it difficult to buy or sell these bonds quickly. The majority of the positions are held by convertible arbitrage funds.

A convertible arbitrage clone is formed using factors such as Large Cap US Stocks: S&P 500 Total Return, Bond: Lehman Corporate AA Intermediate Bond Index, and High Yield Bond: Merrill Lynch High Yield Master 2 Index.

Explore further: Bond Fund

Emerging market replication models aim to capture the performance of emerging markets by tracking a specific index, such as the MSCI Emerging Market Index.

These models often include factors like currency fluctuations, as seen in the U.S. Dollar Index Return, which can significantly impact emerging market investments.

Investors seeking to replicate emerging market returns can also consider including high-yield bond markets, such as the Merrill Lynch High Yield Master 2 Index, in their models.

Credit spreads, like the spread between the Lehman Corporate Bond Index and the Lehman Treasury Index, can also provide valuable insights into emerging market conditions.

By incorporating these factors, replication models can help investors tap into the opportunities emerging from emerging markets.

A different take: Viking Global Investors

Managed futures funds have a history of performing well in trending markets, capturing both uptrends and downtrends. They returned over 35% during the technology downturn between September 2000 and December 2002.

The managed futures strategy has a very low correlation to broad market indices, making it a valuable addition to a diversified portfolio. It returned over 16% in 2008 when most other strategies ended the year in negative territory.

Managed futures funds have the ability to capture returns across a range of asset classes, including equities, commodities, fixed income, and currencies. This flexibility results in high variation in performance between different managers.

The best performing managed futures fund in 2012 returned over 13%, while the worst performer lost over 27%. Despite this variation, the strategy has a history of performing well over the long term, returning over 8.6% annualized with 12.2% volatility between September 2000 and September 2010.

The managed futures strategy has been replicated using a variety of factors, including the Currency: U.S. Dollar Index Return, Treasury Rates: Lehman Treasury Index, Commodity: Goldman Sachs Commodity Index Total Return, Large Cap US Stocks: S&P 500 Total Return, and Market Volatility: CBOE Volatility Index.

Recommended read: Managed Futures Fund

A total of 1495 hedge funds were analyzed using a modeling approach that involves fixed-weight and rolling-window models.

The data used for the analysis was obtained from the Hedge Fund Research Database and covers a period from August 1996 to September 2008.

The sample includes funds belonging to various categories, such as convertible arbitrage, dedicated short bias, and long/short equity.

The factors used in the model were selected based on the characteristics of the underlying hedge fund category.

The performance of the clones developed using these factors was compared to the funds and the clones constructed from a general set of factors listed in Section 2.1.

Three data selection procedures were used in the construction of the hedge fund clones, offering investors a choice between different clone models.

The clones constructed from factors specific to each hedge fund category, known as clone2, were compared against those of the top performing funds.

Clone1 represents the clones that used the general set of factors listed in Section 2.1, previously used by Hasanhodzic and Lo (2007).

Factor replication strategies aim to identify the market risk exposures that comprise hedge fund returns, allowing funds to monitor monthly hedge fund returns and replicate them with weighted baskets of public market instruments.

This approach can result in much lower minimums than traditional hedge funds. ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) is an example of a fund that uses factor replication, seeking to track the performance of the Merrill Lynch Factor Model – Exchange Series.

The replication model used by HDG includes factors such as the S&P500, Russell 2000, and MSCI Emerging Markets, and targets a high correlation with an index that tracks hedge fund industry performance.

The expense ratio of HDG is 0.95% and its total return from inception to the quarter ended December 31, 2021 is 2.6% on an annualized basis.

Copycat funds, on the other hand, aim to mimic the actual holdings of hedge funds by screening publicly available information from select hedge funds and building portfolios from the identified securities.

Check this out: Hedge Fund Market Wizards

The Guru Index ETF is an example of a fund that uses this approach, seeking to track the performance of the Solactive Guru Index, which is comprised of the top U.S. listed equity positions reported on Form 13F by a select group of entities.

The Guru Index ETF has a total return of 14.2% on an annualized basis from inception to the quarter ended December 31, 2021, and an expense ratio of 0.75%.

Related reading: Dsp Gold Etf Fund of Fund

Hedge fund replication strategies are typically evaluated based on their ability to match the performance of a benchmark hedge fund, such as the CSOP CSI 300 Hedge Fund Index.

A key metric used to measure this performance is the tracking error, which measures the difference between the strategy's returns and the benchmark's returns.

Tracking error is usually expressed as a percentage of the strategy's returns.

A lower tracking error indicates that the strategy is more closely tracking the benchmark.

Readers also liked: Multi Strategy Hedge Funds List

For instance, a tracking error of 2% means that the strategy's returns are 2% different from the benchmark's returns.

To further evaluate the performance of a hedge fund replication strategy, investors also look at the Sharpe ratio, which measures the strategy's risk-adjusted returns.

A higher Sharpe ratio indicates that the strategy is generating excess returns relative to its risk.

The Sharpe ratio is calculated as the ratio of the strategy's excess returns to its volatility.

For example, a Sharpe ratio of 1.5 indicates that the strategy has generated 1.5 times its volatility in excess returns.

In addition to these metrics, investors may also consider the strategy's information ratio, which measures the strategy's excess returns relative to its tracking error.

A higher information ratio indicates that the strategy is generating more excess returns relative to its tracking error.

Suggestion: Fixed-income Relative-value Investing

Factor replication strategies are based on the idea of “hedge fund beta” – identifying the market risk exposures that comprise hedge fund returns.

Funds that utilize factor replication strategies can have much lower minimums than traditional hedge funds.

The ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) is one such example, seeking to track the performance of the Merrill Lynch Factor Model – Exchange Series.

This replication model uses a weighted basket of public market instruments to replicate hedge fund returns.

The model includes factors such as the S&P500, Russell 2000, MSCI EAFE, MSCI Emerging Markets, and 3-month Treasury Bills.

The ProShares Hedge Replication ETF has a total return of 2.6% on an annualized basis from its inception on July 12, 2011 to the quarter ended December 31, 2021.

The expense ratio of the fund is 0.95%.

Replication strategies are based on the idea of "hedge fund beta" – identifying the market risk exposures that comprise hedge fund returns.

By monitoring monthly hedge fund returns and using weighted baskets of public market instruments, funds can aim to replicate them.

Funds that utilize factor replication strategies can have much lower minimums than traditional hedge funds.

The ProShares Hedge Replication ETF (HDG) seeks to track the performance of the Merrill Lynch Factor Model – Exchange Series, a replication model.

This model is designed to provide the risk and return characteristics of the hedge fund asset class.

It targets a high correlation with an index that tracks hedge fund industry performance, the HFRI Fund Weighted Composite Index, which is made up of 2000 equally weighted constituent funds.

The replication model used by HDG includes factors such as the S&P500, Russell 2000, MSCI EAFE, MSCI Emerging Markets, ProShares UltraShort Euro ETF, and 3-month Treasury Bills.

According to fund documents, the total return based on market price from the fund's inception on July 12, 2011 to the quarter ended December 31, 2021 is 2.6% on an annualized basis.

The expense ratio of the fund is .95%.