Health Insurance Processing Claims Wrong: Causes of Mistakes and Fixes

Health insurance claims processing can be a complex and frustrating process, with mistakes happening all too often. Inaccurate or missing information can lead to delayed or denied claims.

According to a study, up to 80% of claims are rejected due to incomplete or inaccurate information. This can be due to various reasons, including human error, outdated software, or lack of communication between healthcare providers and insurance companies.

A common cause of mistakes is the use of outdated or incorrect patient information. This can lead to claims being denied due to lack of coverage or incorrect billing.

In some cases, claims are also delayed due to the need for additional documentation or verification. This can cause unnecessary stress and financial burden on patients.

For more insights, see: Fehb and Medicare Part B

Denied claims can be a nightmare for patients and healthcare providers alike. A majority of consumers who experience denied claims report difficulty understanding what their health insurance covers (65%), what they'll owe out of pocket (57%), and their Explanation of Benefits (EOBs) (52%).

Suggestion: Claims Processing Issues Health Insurance

Consumers with denied claims are more likely to experience other types of insurance problems, with about 4 different types of insurance problems occurring on average in a year. They're at least twice as likely to have experienced other insurance problems, such as reaching the limit on covered services or not being able to find an in-network provider.

Medical claim errors can result in significant financial and operational costs for healthcare providers, including a buildup of open claims, patient dissatisfaction, and reputational damage. In fact, 80% of medical bills in the US contain errors, and the repercussions of these errors can be major and wide-ranging, slowing down the revenue cycle and interrupting cash flow.

Here are some common reasons for healthcare claim denials:

Automated claims processing can be faulty, even with the best rules and edits in place.

Claims processing rules and edits are only as good as the auto-adjudication system they're integrated into. If there's no rule or edit to signal that a service should be covered, a claim may be incorrectly denied.

Related reading: Understanding Insurance Claims

Automation issues can creep up in health insurance companies of all sizes, causing many types of incorrect claim denials. This requires consistent attention from technical specialists and claims analysts.

To minimize mistakes, it's essential to track and report claim denials to the insurer. Direct outreach may prompt the health insurer to examine their claims processing procedures, rules, or edits.

Here are some potential issues that may arise with automated claims processing:

Consumers who experience denied claims are more likely to encounter other insurance problems. On average, insured adults with denied claims experience about 4 different types of insurance problems in a year.

Denials can be frustrating and costly. According to Experian State of Claims 2022, 42 percent of providers said the number of denials had increased, and two years later, 77 percent of providers said the number of denials had increased.

Common reasons for healthcare denials include errors in paperwork, omissions, or mix-ups. Your healthcare provider may also question whether your procedure, test, or prescription drug is medically necessary.

You might like: Cigna Prior Authorization Denied

The rate of claim denial can depend on the health insurance company and the type of healthcare plan. At least 15 percent of all claims submitted are initially denied, with higher rates among Medicare Advantage and Medicaid Managed Care plans.

If you notice a high volume of wrongfully denied claims from one specific payer, it could be due to outdated claims processing procedures and programs. Larger insurers have technology-driven processes to increase claims payment accuracy, but smaller insurers may use outdated procedures.

Automated claims processing can also be faulty, leading to incorrect claim denials. If you're noticing repeated denials for a specific service, track the denials and inform the insurer of the problem.

People with denied claims report more difficulty understanding coverage. A majority of consumers who experienced denied claims report difficulty understanding what their health insurance covers (65%), what they'll owe out of pocket (57%), and their EOBs (52%).

Check this out: Health Insurance Fraud Reporting

Most common reasons for healthcare denials include errors in paperwork, omissions, or mix-ups. Your healthcare provider questioning whether your procedure, test, or prescription drug is medically necessary is also a common reason.

Your healthcare provider may want you to try a less expensive option before it pays for the requested service, medication, or treatment, known as step therapy or "fail first." This can be frustrating, especially if you're in a situation where time is of the essence.

Inconsistent diagnosis and treatment codes can also lead to denied claims. It's like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole – you can't receive treatment for pneumonia if you have a diagnosis of a broken leg.

According to the Experian State of Claims 2022, 42 percent of providers said the number of denials had increased. Two years later, 77 percent of providers said the number of denials had increased.

Here are some common reasons for healthcare denials:

Consumers with denied claims are more likely to experience problems with their insurance. A majority of consumers who experienced denied claims report difficulty understanding what their health insurance covers (65%), what they'll owe out of pocket (57%), and their EOBs (52%).

These challenges are not limited to understanding coverage. Consumers with denied claims were more likely to experience other types of insurance problems, such as reaching the limit on covered services, not being able to find or access an in-network provider, and prior authorization problems.

In fact, insured adults with denied claims experienced about 4 different types of insurance problems in a year, compared to those who did not experience denied claims. This suggests that denied claims can be a symptom of a larger issue with the insurance system.

It's worth noting that many consumers who experience denied claims struggle to resolve the problem on their own. Only 29% of consumers whose problems included a denied claim said their biggest problem was resolved satisfactorily, compared to 59% of those whose problems did not include a denied claim.

Here are some common problems experienced by consumers with denied claims:

Incorrect patient information can lead to denied claims. One of the most common patient information errors is with the sex of the patient. Those who identify as anything other than the biological sex they were assigned at birth should be identified by their preferred sexual identification for claims purposes.

Incorrect patient information can be a simple mistake, but it can have serious consequences. A patient's name, DOB, or insurance ID number being incorrect can also lead to denied claims.

Patient information errors can be avoided by double-checking the information provided. This is especially important when dealing with sensitive information like patient sex.

Explore further: Health Insurance Claim Denied What Next

Healthcare claims can be denied for a variety of reasons, and it's essential to understand the common causes to avoid unnecessary stress and financial burden.

One of the primary reasons for denied claims is errors in paperwork, omissions, or mix-ups, which can occur even with the most careful attention to detail. This can lead to incorrect or incomplete information being submitted to the insurance company.

According to research, 80% of medical bills in the US contain errors, making it crucial for healthcare facilities to take proactive measures to minimize claim errors.

Common types of claim errors include mismatched diagnosis/treatment codes, incorrect patient information, and duplicate billing. For instance, a claim will be denied if the codes used to identify your diagnosis and treatment are inconsistent.

Automated claims processing can also be faulty, and even reputable health insurers can make mistakes. This can lead to incorrect claim denials, which can be time-consuming and costly to resolve.

In some cases, healthcare insurers may deny claims due to a lack of coverage or because the service is deemed unnecessary. However, this is often a result of inadequate communication between the healthcare provider and the insurance company.

To avoid denied claims, it's essential to ensure that all necessary documentation is complete and accurate, and that the insurance company has all the required information. This includes verifying patient information, diagnosis, and treatment codes.

Here are some common reasons for denied claims:

By understanding the common causes of denied claims, healthcare providers and patients can take steps to prevent errors and ensure that claims are processed correctly.