The gold standard monetary policy has been around for centuries, with its roots dating back to 13th century China. The first recorded use of a gold standard was in the Chinese province of Fujian, where gold coins were used as a medium of exchange.
The gold standard gained popularity in Europe during the 18th and 19th centuries, with many countries adopting it as their monetary policy. This led to a period of economic stability and growth, known as the "Great Moderation."
However, the gold standard also had its drawbacks, including the lack of flexibility in monetary policy. As noted in the article, "the gold standard limited the ability of governments to implement expansionary monetary policies during times of economic downturn." This led to the Great Depression of the 1930s.
The gold standard was officially abandoned in the United States in 1933, marking the end of an era in monetary policy.
The Rise, 1660-1819
In the 19th century, money consisted of either specie (gold, silver, or copper coins) or specie-backed bank issue notes. The UK and some of its colonies were already on a Gold Standard.
The Napoleonic Wars had a significant impact on the economy, but by the mid-19th century, the turbulence had subsided. Portugal joined the Gold Standard in 1854.
The UK's economic and political dominance, as well as its access to London's financial markets, made it an attractive option for other countries.
US Implementation
The US implementation of the gold standard was a complex and tumultuous process. The country's first experiment with a fiat currency, the greenback, was introduced during the Civil War to help finance the war effort.
In 1862, the US government issued nearly $450 million in greenbacks, which were not backed by gold or silver. This led to inflation and a national debt of $2.76 billion by 1866.
The government attempted to move to a gold standard after the Civil War by reducing the amount of money in circulation and destroying greenback bills. However, this process was hindered by the continued over-issuance of silver dollars and silver certificates due to political pressures.
Here is a list of key events in the US implementation of the gold standard:
The US implementation of the gold standard was marked by controversy and conflict, with different factions advocating for either a gold or silver standard.
Pre-Civil War
The United States established a national bank with the First Bank of the United States in 1791.
The Second Bank of the United States was created in 1816, but its charter was not extended in 1836 due to President Andrew Jackson's opposition to banking institutions.
In 1834, the Coinage Act increased the gold-silver ratio to 16.0, which was later finalized to 15.99 in 1837.
Gold discoveries in California in 1848 and Australia lowered the gold price relative to silver, causing silver money to be driven out of circulation.
The Independent Treasury Act of 1848 placed the U.S. on a strict hard-money standard, requiring gold or silver coins for business transactions with the government.
Government accounts were separated from the banking system, but the mint ratio continued to overvalue gold.
Silver coins 50 cents and below were reduced in silver content in 1853 and could no longer be requested for minting by the general public.
In 1857, the legal tender status of Spanish dollars and other foreign coinage was repealed, and American banks suspended payment in silver.
U.S. Politics
In 2011, the Utah legislature passed a bill to accept federally issued gold and silver coins as legal tender to pay taxes. This move was driven by anxiety over the policies of President Barack Obama.
Ron Paul, a former congressman, has been a long-time advocate of a gold standard and has also expressed support for using a standard based on a basket of commodities that better reflects the state of the economy.
The Arizona Legislature passed SB 1439 in 2013, which would have made gold and silver coin a legal tender in payment of debt, but the bill was vetoed by the Governor.
In 2015, some Republican candidates for the 2016 presidential election advocated for a gold standard, based on concern that the Federal Reserve's attempts to increase economic growth may create inflation.
1792-1862: The Bimetallic
The Bimetallic Standard was established in 1792 with the Coinage Act, which fixed the dollar as equivalent to 24.75 grains of gold and 371.25 grains of silver.
The first circulating US coins were produced by the Mint in March 1793, with 11,178 copper coins. These coins were in denominations of half cent and cent in copper, half dime, dime, quarter, half dollar, and dollar in silver, and quarter eagle ($2.50), half eagle ($5), and eagle ($10) in gold.
The first US Gold Eagle coins produced by the Philadelphia Mint in 1795 had a face value of $10 and contained 247.5 grains of pure gold. This was a significant milestone in the history of US currency.
Paper money, backed by gold and silver reserves, was also printed and circulated by banks and the US Treasury during this time. However, there was no legal-tender paper money prior to the American Civil War.
Large silver finds in Mexico and South America caused a decline in the market value of silver relative to gold, resulting in an influx of silver flowing to the US mint for coinage. Gold coins began to leave circulation as their metal content became worth more than their face value.
The Coinage Act of 1834 reduced the gold value of one dollar to 23.2 grains of gold, an effort to bring gold coins back into circulation.
Rollout in Europe and the US
The rollout of the gold standard in Europe and the US was a gradual process that began in the late 19th century. The German Empire was one of the first countries to transition from a silver-based currency to a gold-based one in 1873.
The Coinage Act of 1873 suspended the minting of the standard silver dollar, leading to a decline in the market value of silver relative to gold. This change was a significant shift, as the US had previously been on a bimetallic standard, where both gold and silver were accepted as currency.
The German Empire's transition to a gold standard was a turning point for the international monetary system. The gold standard became the basis for the international monetary system, with countries pegging their exchange rates to the gold standard.
Here's a list of countries that switched to a gold standard in the late 19th century:
- 1816, British Empire: one pound from 111.37 g silver to 7.32238 g gold; ratio 15.21
- 1873, German Empire: one North German thaler or 13⁄4 South German gulden of 16.67 g silver, converted to 3 German gold marks of 3/2.79 = 1.0753 g gold; ratio 15.5
- 1873, Latin Monetary Union franc: from 4.5 g silver to 9/31 = 0.29032 g gold; ratio 15.5
- 1873, United States dollar, by the Coinage Act of 1873: from 24.0566 g silver to 1.50463 g gold; ratio 15.99
- 1875, Scandinavian Monetary Union: Rigsdaler specie of 25.28 g silver, converted to 4 krone (or krona) of 4/2.48 = 1.6129 g gold; ratio 15.67
- 1875, Netherlands: the Dutch Guilder from 9.45 g silver to 0.6048 g gold; ratio 15.625
- 1881, Ottoman Empire: the Ottoman lira
- 1892, Austria-Hungary: the Austro-Hungarian florin of 11.11 g silver, converted to two Austro-Hungarian krone of 2/3.28 = 0.60976 g gold; ratio 18.22
- 1897, Russian Empire: the ruble from 18 g silver to 0.7742 g gold; ratio 23.25
The gold standard was not firmly established in non-industrial countries, but it played a significant role in stabilizing international price relationships and facilitating foreign borrowing.
Causes and Effects
The gold standard monetary system was a significant development in the 19th century, and it's fascinating to explore its causes and effects.
The California gold rush of 1849 and the Australian gold rushes of 1851 significantly increased world gold supplies, pushing the gold–silver ratio below 15.5, which led to France and the United States adopting the gold standard along with Great Britain.
France's actions in maintaining the French franc at either 4.5 g fine silver or 0.29032 g fine gold stabilized world gold–silver price ratios close to the French ratio of 15.5. The United States dollar was also bimetallic de jure until 1900, worth either 24.0566 g fine silver, or 1.60377 g fine gold (ratio 15.0).
As a result of this shift, the benefits of the gold standard were first felt by a larger bloc of countries, including Britain, France, and the emerging United States. The benefits of the gold standard were first felt by this larger bloc of countries, with Britain and France being the world's leading financial and industrial powers of the 19th century.
By the 1860s, the gold–silver ratio had reverted to 15.5, but this bloc of gold-utilizing countries continued to grow, providing momentum to an international gold standard. Several international monetary conferences in the last third of the 19th century began to consider the merits of an international gold standard, albeit with concerns on its impact on the price of silver should several countries make the switch.
Here are some key countries that adopted the gold standard during this period:
- Portugal and several British colonies commenced with the gold standard in the 1850s and 1860s
- France was joined by Belgium, Switzerland, and Italy in a larger Latin Monetary Union based on both the gold and silver French francs.
19th Century Rush Effects
The 19th century gold rush had a significant impact on the global economy, particularly in the area of currency and trade. The gold standard, which was initially adopted by Britain and its colonies, began to spread to other countries.
France and the United States were two notable countries that maintained a bimetallic standard, where their currencies could be backed by either gold or silver. This allowed them to stabilize the world gold-silver price ratios.
The California gold rush of 1849 and the Australian gold rushes of 1851 led to an increase in world gold supplies, causing the gold-silver ratio to drop below 15.5. This pushed France and the United States into adopting the gold standard, joining Britain.
By the 1860s, the gold-silver ratio had reverted to 15.5, but this didn't stop the spread of the gold standard. Countries like Portugal and several British colonies began to adopt the gold standard in the 1850s and 1860s.
Here's a list of some of the countries that adopted the gold standard during this time:
- Portugal
- Belgium
- Switzerland
- Italy
These countries joined the Latin Monetary Union, which was based on the gold and silver French francs. This marked a significant shift towards an international gold standard, which would have far-reaching consequences for global trade and finance.
Causes of the Great Depression
The gold standard played a significant role in the lead-up to the Great Depression. In 1925, the British Gold Standard Act was passed, reintroducing the gold standard and fixing the price of gold at $4.86 per pound sterling. This decision was made by Chancellor of the Exchequer Winston Churchill, who was trying to restore the pre-war exchange rate.
The decision to fix the price of gold was a mistake that had far-reaching consequences. By pegging the pound to gold, the UK was essentially limiting its ability to implement monetary policies to stimulate the economy.
The gold standard also led to a reduction in the money supply, as the government was required to hold gold reserves to back up the currency. This reduction in the money supply contributed to deflation, which in turn led to a decrease in spending and investment.
A key event that highlights the flaws of the gold standard is the 1926 general strike in the UK. This strike was sparked by high levels of unemployment and poverty, which were exacerbated by the gold standard.
The UK's decision to leave the gold standard in 1931 was a belated attempt to address the economic crisis. However, by this point, the damage had already been done, and the Great Depression had taken hold.
Here's a summary of the key events leading up to the Great Depression:
The gold standard's limitations were finally acknowledged, and the UK was able to adopt a more flexible monetary policy. However, the damage had already been done, and the Great Depression continued to ravage the global economy.
U.S. Stock Fluctuations, 1862-1877
The U.S. gold stock fluctuated significantly between 1862 and 1877. In 1862, the U.S. had a gold stock of 59 tons, which rose to 81 tons by 1866.
Gold production increased while gold exports decreased during this period. The decrease in gold exports was considered by some to be a result of changing monetary conditions.
The net import of gold meant that the foreign demand for American currency to purchase goods, services, and investments exceeded the corresponding American demands for foreign currencies. In the final years of the greenback period (1862–1879), the net import of gold continued.
Here's a breakdown of the U.S. gold stock fluctuations between 1862 and 1878:
These fluctuations had a significant impact on the U.S. economy, leading to changes in monetary conditions and the demand for gold.
Abandonment of the
The abandonment of the gold standard was a significant event in economic history.
The gold standard was first abandoned in the United States during the Civil War, when the government suspended payments of obligations not legally specified in specie and introduced paper money, known as "greenbacks".
The United Kingdom abandoned the gold standard at the outbreak of World War I, replacing gold sovereigns and half sovereigns with Treasury notes.
The Bank of England successfully ended the gold standard in the UK through appeals to patriotism, urging citizens not to redeem paper money for gold specie.
The British Gold Standard Act 1925 introduced the gold bullion standard, ending the circulation of gold specie coins and compelling the authorities to sell gold bullion on demand at a fixed price.
Keynes argued against resumption of the gold standard, citing deflationary dangers, but the decision to fix the price at a pre-war exchange rate was made, leading to depression, unemployment, and the 1926 general strike.
The pound left the gold standard in 1931, and a number of currencies pegged to sterling instead of gold.
International Impact
The gold standard monetary system had a significant international impact. It was adopted by many countries around the world, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada.
The gold standard required countries to back their currency with gold reserves, which led to a high degree of economic stability and predictability. This stability made international trade and investment easier and more attractive.
The gold standard also led to the creation of the gold exchange standard, which allowed countries to use their foreign exchange reserves to settle international transactions. This standard was adopted by many countries, including the United States.
The gold standard was eventually abandoned by many countries, including the United States, in the mid-20th century. This was due in part to the Great Depression and the need for governments to implement expansionary monetary policies.
The abandonment of the gold standard led to a significant increase in international trade and investment, as countries were no longer constrained by the need to back their currency with gold.
Theoretical and Practical Aspects
The Gold Standard was a monetary system where a country's money supply was linked to gold, with countries having to convert fiat money into gold on demand.
This limited the amount of fiat money in circulation to a multiple of the central banks' gold reserves, with most countries having legal minimum ratios of gold to notes/currency issued.
Commodity money, such as gold and silver, was convenient to store and transport in large amounts, but it didn't allow governments to manipulate the flow of commerce as easily as a fiat currency does.
Countries that left the gold standard earlier than others recovered from the Great Depression sooner, such as Great Britain and the Scandinavian countries, which left the gold standard in 1931.
The use of the Gold Standard meant that any correction of an economic imbalance would be accelerated, normally without the need to wait for substantial quantities of gold to be transported from one country to another.
Representative money and the gold standard protected citizens from hyperinflation and other abuses of monetary policy, as seen in some countries during the Great Depression.
Under the Gold Standard, countries with a balance of payments surplus would receive gold inflows, while countries in deficit would experience an outflow of gold, which would correct the imbalance.
A rise in interest rates under the Gold Standard would speed up the adjustment process by making borrowing more expensive and attracting money from abroad, improving the capital account of the balance of payments.
Pros and Cons
The gold standard monetary system has been a topic of debate for many years, with proponents and critics presenting various arguments. Here are some of the key points to consider.
One of the main benefits of the gold standard is that it prevents financial repression, a mechanism used by governments to transfer wealth from creditors to debtors. Economist Michael D. Bordo notes that the gold standard acts as a stable nominal anchor, reducing the risk of inflation and financial instability.
In contrast, critics argue that the gold standard can limit the ability of governments to respond to economic crises. For example, a gold standard would restrict the Federal Reserve's ability to print money and address unemployment.
However, a gold standard can also provide price stability, as it ties the value of money to the value of gold. This can help reduce uncertainty in international trade and promote economic growth.
On the other hand, some argue that the gold standard can lead to short-term price swings, as seen in historical data. Additionally, the gold standard can limit the ability of governments to finance national defense, which could harm national security.
Here's a summary of the main pros and cons of the gold standard:
Monetary Systems
The gold standard monetary system is based on the idea that a country's currency is pegged to the value of gold. This means that the value of the currency is directly tied to the value of gold.
In a gold standard system, a country's central bank issues currency in exchange for gold reserves. This limits the amount of currency that can be printed and helps prevent inflation.
The gold standard has been used in various forms throughout history, with the first recorded example being the Lydian stater in ancient Lydia around 560 BC. This coin was made of electrum, a naturally occurring alloy of gold and silver.
The gold standard was widely used in the 19th and early 20th centuries, with many countries pegging their currency to the value of gold. However, the system was eventually abandoned due to its limitations and the challenges of maintaining a stable gold price.
In a gold standard system, the value of the currency is directly tied to the value of gold, which can be a challenge to maintain, especially during times of economic stress or gold supply shortages.
Modern Era
In the modern era, the gold standard monetary system has largely been abandoned. The US abandoned the gold standard in 1971, citing the need for greater monetary flexibility.
The collapse of the Bretton Woods system in 1971 marked the end of the gold standard's international influence. The system was unsustainable due to the large trade deficits of the US.
Today, most countries use fiat currency, which is not backed by any physical commodity. This has led to a significant increase in global trade and economic growth.
Modern Production
In the modern era, gold production has seen significant growth. An estimated total of 174,100 tonnes of gold have been mined in human history, according to GFMS as of 2012.
This staggering amount is roughly equivalent to 5.6 billion troy ounces. To put that into perspective, it's about 9,261 cubic metres (327,000 cu ft) of gold, or a cube 21 metres (69 ft) on a side.
Gold production has been a long-standing practice, with varying estimates of the total volume mined due to its history spanning thousands of years. Some nations are also not transparent about their gold output, making it difficult to account for the gold mined.
The world's gold production for 2011 was approximately 2,700 tonnes. Interestingly, annual gold output growth has kept pace with world population growth, with a doubling in this period.
Trying to Return
In the aftermath of World War I, many countries faced high inflation, and the scramble to get back to the Gold Standard's conversion rates was a major challenge.
The Gold Standard was a monetary system where currencies were pegged to the value of gold, and countries tried to return to this system in the 1920s. Australia returned to the Gold Standard in April 1925, but suspended it again in December 1929.
To deflate prices and get back to pre-WWI levels, countries implemented tight monetary policies, causing high unemployment. The United States, for example, suspended the Gold Standard in March 1933, while the United Kingdom suspended it in September 1931.
The return to the Gold Standard was not a smooth process, and countries faced various challenges. Some, like Germany, returned to the Gold Standard as early as September 1924, while others, like Japan, took longer, returning in December 1930.
Here's a list of some countries and their return to the Gold Standard:
The devaluation of currencies was also a significant issue. Some countries, like Greece, devalued their currency in April 1932, while others, like the United States, devalued in April 1933.
Frequently Asked Questions
What would happen if the US returned to the gold standard?
Returning to a gold standard could reduce the US trade deficit and military spending by limiting excessive money printing, but it may also restrict the country's ability to finance national defense. This dual impact highlights the complex trade-offs of reverting to a gold standard.
What currencies are still on the gold standard?
No country currently uses the gold standard for its monetary system. The last country to abandon it was Switzerland in 1999.
Featured Images: pexels.com