Understanding ETNs vs ETFs: A Comprehensive Guide

ETNs and ETFs are two popular investment products that offer exposure to various assets, but they work in different ways. ETNs are exchange-traded notes, which are debt securities that track an underlying index or asset.

ETNs are issued by banks and other financial institutions, and their value is determined by the market. They are often used to gain exposure to hard-to-invest-in assets or to hedge against market volatility.

In contrast, ETFs are exchange-traded funds, which hold a basket of securities that track an underlying index or asset. ETFs are traded on an exchange and offer flexibility and diversification.

One key difference between ETNs and ETFs is that ETNs are debt obligations, while ETFs are securities that hold the underlying assets themselves.

Recommended read: What Are Etfs

ETNs and ETFs are two popular investment products that can be a bit confusing, especially for beginners. An ETN, or exchange-traded note, is a financial instrument that tracks a particular strategy or index, offering investors exposure to parts of the market that would be difficult to package with an ETF.

ETNs can track commodities, volatility indexes, or even leverage the market, allowing investors to target a specific return profile. For example, a 3x Nasdaq-100 ETN would aim for a 3% rise if the NDX rises 1%.

One of the main benefits of ETNs is tax efficiency. Since ETNs have no portfolio holdings and usually pay no interest or dividends, investors only pay capital gains if they sell the ETN for a profit. This can be especially useful for commodity investments, which often have complicated tax issues.

Some common ETN strategies include:

On the other hand, an ETF, or exchange-traded fund, is a basket of investments like stocks or bonds that can be traded easily and often have lower fees. ETFs let you invest in many securities all at once, making them a popular choice for investors.

Here's a quick comparison of ETNs and ETFs:

As you can see, ETNs and ETFs have their own strengths and weaknesses. ETNs offer tax efficiency and unique investment opportunities, while ETFs provide a simple way to invest in a basket of securities.

An exchange-traded note (ETN) is a debt instrument that doesn't represent ownership of the underlying asset or index.

The return on an ETN relies on the institution's promise to repay based on the underlying asset's performance. This means investors don't own shares of any company or asset, but instead own the debt of a financial institution.

ETFs, on the other hand, work like a basket of investments, letting you invest in many securities all at once. They often have lower fees than other types of funds.

An ETF provider considers the universe of assets, including stocks, bonds, commodities, or currencies, and creates a basket of them with a unique ticker. This basket is what investors buy a share of.

Check this out: Real Asset Etfs

Buyers and sellers trade ETFs throughout the day on an exchange, just like buying and selling stocks. This allows investors to decide when to buy or sell ETFs, rather than waiting for a specific date.

Investors in an ETF that tracks a stock index may get dividend payments for any dividend stocks in the index. However, the price of ETFs fluctuates like those of stocks, and the longer-term returns for an ETF will vary from those of its underlying asset due to expenses.

The amount of money invested in an ETN is tied to a specific index or asset. When the ETN matures, the investor receives back the value of the underlying asset, minus any fees.

Readers also liked: What Are Etfs vs Stocks

You have a range of investment options to choose from, including ETFs and ETNs. Both offer lower expense ratios compared to actively managed mutual funds.

ETFs are passively managed investments that simply track an index, while ETNs are similar to debt investments that allow you to loan money to a financial institution with the promise of repayment based on the performance of the index.

Check this out: Etf vs Managed Fund

ETFs can be traded like stocks and offer periodic dividends, while ETNs have distributions at maturity and may be callable before maturity. ETNs also have the potential for tax benefits, as investors only owe taxes when the ETN matures or is sold.

Here's a brief comparison of ETFs and ETNs:

This comparison can help you decide which investment option is best for you.

International investment options can provide a great way to diversify your portfolio and reduce risk.

Commodity ETFs, such as those that track gold or crude oil, can be a good choice for international investing, but it's essential to understand what's inside them.

These ETFs can contain physical commodities, futures contracts, or equity in companies that produce, transport, and store goods, which can impact tax implications and risk levels.

ETNs, on the other hand, offer niche access to areas like commodities, currencies, and emerging markets.

International ETFs, which include investments in foreign stocks, bonds, and individual countries or country blocs, can be an easy and less risky way to find these foreign investments.

Investing in China, for example, can be done through China ETFs, which provide a convenient way to access the Chinese market.

Discover more: Foreign Etfs

Bond investments can be a great way to earn regular income, as they typically offer fixed interest payments.

Unlike individual bonds, bond ETFs don't have a maturity date, so they can be held for a long time.

Bond ETFs are an excellent, lower-risk complement to stock ETFs, making them a great addition to a diversified portfolio.

These funds generate regular cash payments to investors from the interest earned by individual bonds within the fund.

Bond ETFs can be a smart choice for those seeking predictable income and lower volatility.

See what others are reading: Stock Bonds and Mutual Funds

In January 2024, the Securities and Exchange Commission approved a handful of spot Bitcoin ETFs that directly track the price of Bitcoin, making it more accessible to the average investor.

These ETFs can be bought and sold directly in brokerage accounts, offering a convenient way to invest in Bitcoin.

Most crypto ETFs, however, still hold futures contracts or the stock of companies that deal in or invest in the cryptocurrency markets.

This limited availability of direct exposure to other cryptocurrencies makes Bitcoin ETFs a more straightforward option for investors.

For another approach, see: Grayscale Bitcoin Cash Trust

Sector investments can be a great way to diversify your portfolio and track business cycles.

The U.S. stock market is divided into 11 sectors, each made up of companies operating within that sector.

Sector ETFs provide a way to invest in specific companies within those sectors, such as health care, financial, or industrial sectors.

Some sectors tend to perform better during expansion periods and others during contraction periods, making sector ETFs useful for investors tracking business cycles.

Sector ETFs can carry higher risk than broad-market ETFs, but they can also give your portfolio exposure to an industry that intrigues you, such as gold ETFs or marijuana ETFs.

Investing in a sector ETF can be less risky than investing in a single company, as it spreads your investment across multiple companies within that sector.

Sector ETFs are a type of Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) that tracks a specific industry or sector.

Check this out: What Are Some Etfs Similar to Money Market Funds

Niche Access allows investors to tap into specific areas of the market that might otherwise be inaccessible. ETNs can provide a way to invest in commodities, currencies, and emerging markets.

Investing in niche areas can be beneficial for those who want to diversify their portfolio. ETNs offer a way to gain exposure to these areas without having to purchase individual securities.

One of the benefits of ETNs is their potential tax benefits. Since ETNs do not pay periodic dividends, investors only owe taxes when the ETN matures or they sell it on the exchange.

ETNs can also provide access to strategies and markets that might be difficult to access with traditional investments. This can be especially useful for retail investors who want to take advantage of certain strategies.

Here are some examples of niche areas that ETNs can provide access to:

By investing in niche areas, you can potentially gain exposure to industries that are performing well during certain business cycles.

Mutual funds are a type of investment vehicle that's often compared to ETFs. They typically have higher fees than ETFs, which can eat into your returns.

Mutual funds are usually actively managed, which means a human manager is making decisions about where to invest your money. This can lead to more turnover within the fund, resulting in capital gains and taxes for investors.

One of the downsides of mutual funds is the tax implications. When investors sell a mutual fund, the manager may need to sell securities to raise cash, incurring capital gains and taxes for investors.

Mutual funds often have a more complex management structure than ETFs, with a human manager making decisions about investments.

You might like: Hedge Fund vs Private Equity vs Venture Capital

Finding the right investments for your portfolio can be a daunting task, but understanding the basics can make all the difference. It's essential to be aware that costs can vary widely from fund to fund, depending on the issuer, complexity, and demand.

Consider your investing style before buying. If you prefer a hands-on approach, mutual funds might be the way to go. However, if you're looking for a more passive approach, ETFs could be a better fit.

Be cautious of funds that may not stack up on merit – some ETFs can be gimmicky and may not provide much diversification. Just because an ETF is cheap doesn't mean it fits with your broader investment thesis.

ETFs and ETNs have similar characteristics, but they also have some key differences. Here's a quick comparison:

Ultimately, it's essential to do your research and consider your individual needs before making a decision. By understanding the differences between ETFs and ETNs, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your investment goals.

ETNs tend to have lower tracking errors than some ETFs.

One key reason for this is that ETNs don't actively track the underlying index, which eliminates tracking error.

Prices can move too fast for some ETFs to keep up, causing tracking errors.

ETNs, on the other hand, pay investors the full value of the index at maturity, minus the expense ratio.

This eliminates the need for the fund to actively track the underlying instrument, allowing market forces to take over.

The issuer's agreement to pay the full value at maturity ensures that ETNs track the underlying index without error.

On a similar theme: Class B Shares Mutual Funds

ETNs can be riskier than ETFs due to the credit risk of the issuer. This means that if the issuer defaults, the ETN is worthless.

ETNs can have long maturity dates, ranging from 10 to 30 years, and can be delisted from major exchanges, making it difficult for investors to sell their notes. Trading on the pink sheets, an over-the-counter market, can be very thin, and notes may trade at a great discount to their indicative value.

Liquidity risk is a significant concern for ETN investors, as they may struggle to cash in certain ETNs with low liquidity. Volatility risk is also a factor, as returns could be more volatile relative to other investments without the smoothing effect of dividends.

Here are some key risks to consider:

ETNs can be created with long maturity dates, often between 10 to 30 years, which can be a significant risk for investors.

Market conditions can quickly move against ETNs, causing their value to plummet. This happened in 2018 with an inverse volatility index ETN issued by Credit Suisse, which fell by more than 90% when the volatility index spiked.

ETN investors should be aware of liquidity risk, as ETNs can trade on major exchanges but may have low liquidity, making it difficult to sell them.

Volatility risk is also a concern, as ETNs do not pay dividends and their value can be highly volatile.

ETNs can be both called and delisted, which can result in closure risk for investors.

An ETN's closing indicative value and intraday indicative value can differ significantly from its market price, resulting in price deviation risk.

Here are some key risks to consider when investing in ETNs:

It's worth noting that about 80% of ETNs have either matured, been redeemed, or delisted, which can be a concern for investors.

ETNs have fewer investor protections than ETFs. One key difference is that ETNs are registered under the Securities Act of 1933, which requires explicit disclosures about material risks in plain English.

ETFs, on the other hand, are registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, which provides greater user protections. For example, ETFs have a board of directors that has discretion over changes in the fund.

ETNs, however, have no board of directors, and issuers must create new versions of the notes to make changes. This lack of oversight can make it harder for investors to understand and navigate the risks associated with ETNs.

As a result, investors in ETNs may be more vulnerable to unexpected changes or risks.

On a similar theme: Risks of Etfs