Compare Payroll, Prepaid, Debit and Credit Cards for Businesses

Author

Reads 455

Top view of a payroll document on a desk with pencils and folders, ideal for finance themes.
Credit: pexels.com, Top view of a payroll document on a desk with pencils and folders, ideal for finance themes.

For businesses, choosing the right payment method can be a daunting task. Payroll cards offer a convenient way for employees to receive their pay, with many employers requiring direct deposit to payroll cards.

Prepaid cards are another option, allowing employees to load funds before making purchases. These cards often come with fees, which can eat into the employee's earnings.

Debit cards, on the other hand, are linked to an employee's checking account, making it easy to access their funds. Debit cards typically don't come with fees, but may have overdraft charges.

Credit cards, while convenient, can be a liability for businesses if employees overspend or don't pay their balances on time. Credit card fees can add up quickly, making it a less attractive option for businesses.

What Are Payroll and Prepaid Cards?

Payroll cards allow employees to access paychecks without setting up a bank account. They function like debit cards, loaded with a paycheck each pay period, and can be used to withdraw cash or make purchases.

A Woman Scanning Her Card
Credit: pexels.com, A Woman Scanning Her Card

Small businesses with employees who don't have bank accounts or limited banking options can benefit from payroll cards. It may be cost-effective to provide a payroll card option to your workers, especially if printing and handing out checks is expensive.

Payroll cards aren't exactly like traditional debit cards, and workers must understand the different fees associated with them. They'll have to pay fees like charges for ATM withdrawals, balance inquiries, fund transfers, monthly maintenance, and account closures.

The exact costs depend on the payroll card company.

Comparison to Debit and Credit Cards

Payroll and prepaid cards have some key differences compared to debit and credit cards. They often have lower fees, with payroll cards averaging $2.50 per transaction and prepaid cards averaging $3.50 per transaction, compared to debit cards which can charge around $1.50 per transaction.

One major benefit of payroll and prepaid cards is their simplicity. They don't require a credit check, making them accessible to people with poor credit. In contrast, debit cards can be linked to a checking account, which may have overdraft fees.

Direct Deposit Differences

Decorative cardboard illustration of cellphone with application on screen in envelope with Payroll inscription on blue background
Credit: pexels.com, Decorative cardboard illustration of cellphone with application on screen in envelope with Payroll inscription on blue background

Direct deposit is a great way to receive your pay, but it's not the only option. Paid directly from an employer into an employee's bank account, direct deposit doesn't require fees, allowing a worker to keep all hard-earned money.

One of the biggest advantages of direct deposit is that it requires a bank account to receive payment. This can be a challenge for employees without a bank account, but it's worth it in the long run. Paid money is safer with a direct deposit, and it doesn't have reward opportunities like pay cards.

Direct deposit also offers a better opportunity to save effortlessly, as once your deposits are in a checking account, you can use debit cards anywhere. With direct deposit, employees will have access to their pay on a set day, once an employer releases funds through the bank.

Here's a comparison of direct deposit and payroll cards:

Overall, direct deposit is a reliable and convenient way to receive your pay, and it's worth considering the benefits and drawbacks before making a decision.

Volopay Business

Close-up of a vintage typewriter typing 'Salary Check' on paper, symbolizing payroll and finance.
Credit: pexels.com, Close-up of a vintage typewriter typing 'Salary Check' on paper, symbolizing payroll and finance.

Branded payroll cards are a decent option for employers, but they come with limited features and can be expensive for companies with many employees.

Branded payroll cards have wider acceptance and accessibility than others, allowing employees to use them for in-store purchases, ATMs, bill payments, and wire transfers.

They can also send payments to international accounts at a lower price than regular bank transfers, and can be used for various payments such as restaurant bills, hotel reservations, and ticket booking.

Volopay, on the other hand, is an organized and automated expense management software that can streamline payroll at a cost within your budget.

Volopay's unlimited virtual cards can be assigned to employees for making recurring salary payments every month, and are also good for reimbursing employee business expenses.

Both local and international payments are possible with Volopay at the lowest fx charges, making it easy to pay foreign employees.

Volopay is a smart solution for managing any expenses, not just payroll.

Discover more: Citigroup Employees

Portable

A Person Doing Business Transaction Online
Credit: pexels.com, A Person Doing Business Transaction Online

Portable cards offer a lot of flexibility, especially for people with multiple jobs. They can receive payments from multiple employers on one card.

One key difference between portable cards and regular prepaid payroll cards is that portable cards don't stop working once you're no longer employed.

Portable cards can also accept funds from other sources, not just salary.

Pros and Cons

Payroll card options have their benefits and drawbacks. You should consider the employer fees associated with direct deposits, which can be a significant drawback if you're on a tight budget.

If more employees are unbanked than those with bank accounts, payroll cards can be an ideal solution. This is because they cater to individuals without traditional banking options.

However, you should also consider federal and state laws before making a decision. This will help you choose the best payroll option for your business.

Pros and Cons of Payroll

When considering payroll options for your business, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons. Let's break down the advantages and disadvantages of different payroll methods.

A unique perspective: E S a Payments

Making a Payment With a Debit Card
Credit: pexels.com, Making a Payment With a Debit Card

Direct deposits can be a convenient option for employees, but they come with higher employer fees, which may not be feasible for every business. You should consider your budget and federal and state laws before making a decision.

Payroll cards can be a good alternative, especially if many of your employees are unbanked. This option can be ideal for businesses with a large number of employees without bank accounts.

The cost of payroll options varies, and some providers may charge extra fees for certain services. OnPay, for example, offers clear pricing with no sneaky fees, starting at just $40 + $6/worker per month.

Some payroll providers, like OnPay, offer a range of features, including paycard options, direct deposit, and physical checks, as well as automated tax filings and employee self-onboarding.

Here are some key features of OnPay:

  • Pay workers by paycard at no extra cost
  • Choose direct deposit or physical checks if you prefer
  • Get our help with setup and data migration
  • Automated tax filings, payments, W-2s and 1099s
  • Employees self-onboard and e-sign important docs

Lack of Features

Employer payroll debit cards have some significant limitations when it comes to features. They can't offer anything beyond basic transactional services. This is a major drawback compared to a debit card that comes with a bank account, which can provide a wide range of innovative features.

If this caught your attention, see: Online Banking Features

Man Sitting at the Desk and Counting Money while Using a Calculator
Credit: pexels.com, Man Sitting at the Desk and Counting Money while Using a Calculator

One notable feature that employer payroll debit cards lack is mobile banking. This can be a significant inconvenience for employees who rely on mobile banking to manage their finances on the go. Additionally, employer payroll debit cards often don't offer online banking, in-person support, or credit card services.

If you're considering a payroll solution for your business, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons. Here's a comparison of the features offered by employer payroll debit cards and debit cards with a bank account:

As you can see, debit cards with a bank account offer a much wider range of features than employer payroll debit cards. This can be a significant advantage for employees who rely on these features to manage their finances.

Downsides for Small Businesses

High employee fees are a significant concern for small businesses considering payroll cards. This can eat into their profit margins and make it harder to manage their finances.

Unrecognizable man holding wallet with money
Credit: pexels.com, Unrecognizable man holding wallet with money

Payroll cards don't offer any interest, so employees won't earn any interest on their balances.

Additional fees apply to payroll cards, which can be a surprise for employees who aren't expecting them.

Card loss or theft is a real risk with payroll cards, which can put employees' hard-earned money at risk.

Here are some key downsides to consider:

  • High employee fees
  • Card can be lost or stolen
  • Additional fees apply

Alternatives to Direct Deposit

Payroll cards can be a good option for low-income employees without bank accounts. They allow employers to pay employees all at once, eliminating the need for a final check.

In some cases, payroll cards can even provide more information security for workers, as they don't need to retain personal data. Some card companies also let you send money directly to your bank account, though this may take an extra day.

For employees without a primary bank, payroll cards offer a secure and fast way to access paychecks, avoiding expensive check-cashing fees.

Can Replace Direct Deposits?

Credit: youtube.com, How To Change Banks For Social Security Direct Deposit (How To Update Banks For SSA Direct Deposit)

Payroll cards can replace direct deposits in certain situations, such as for low-income employees who don't have bank accounts.

Direct deposits are still the most popular payment method among employers, so it's likely many will stick with what they're used to.

In employment termination cases, payroll cards allow employers to pay off laid-off employees all at once, eliminating the need for a final check.

Payroll cards offer more information security for workers, as they don't need to retain personal data.

Some card companies let you send money directly to your bank account, but this may take an extra day.

Payroll cards are gaining popularity, so it's worth keeping an eye on this trend in the coming years.

Here's an interesting read: M and T Bank Statements

Alternative Payment Option for Employees

Payroll cards can be a convenient option for employees who don't have a bank account or prefer not to receive direct deposits.

These cards allow employees to access their pay instantly and avoid expensive check-cashing fees.

Man Counting Money in Office
Credit: pexels.com, Man Counting Money in Office

Employers must provide an option for direct deposit or paper checks to be compliant with labor laws, so payroll cards aren't a replacement for these methods.

Payroll debit cards work like regular debit cards and can be used for online transactions, shopping, and ATM withdrawals.

Employers can load monthly wages onto these cards, as well as add other funds and reimbursements.

Card issuers like Visa and Mastercard help employers provide payroll debit cards for employees.

Receiving payments through payroll cards can be a big help for employees who don't have access to banking services or prefer not to carry cash.

Printing checks for each employee takes time and can be expensive, while delivering salaries in cash leads to manual processing.

Payroll debit cards can simplify the payment process for small businesses and their employees.

For more insights, see: M&t Online Banking App

Providers and Services

You can choose from several payroll card providers, but some primary payroll providers offer payroll cards to compensate employees.

If you're working with a primary payroll provider, you should talk with your representative to determine the best options for your business.

Cost and Setup

Close-Up Photo of a Person Counting Her Money
Credit: pexels.com, Close-Up Photo of a Person Counting Her Money

Setting up a prepaid card is relatively straightforward and can be done online or in-person, often taking just a few minutes.

The cost of a prepaid card varies, but many options are free or low-cost, with some even offering a free initial card and a small monthly fee.

In contrast, debit cards are usually free to obtain, but some banks may charge a small monthly fee for maintenance.

Prepaid cards often require a minimum balance, which can range from $10 to $20, and may also come with fees for things like ATM withdrawals and balance inquiries.

Debit cards, on the other hand, typically don't require a minimum balance, and fees are generally lower, although some banks may charge for things like overdrafts.

Some prepaid cards have a higher setup fee, which can range from $5 to $10, while others may charge a higher monthly maintenance fee, up to $10 per month.

How to Use and Add Funds

A Man with Wedding Ring Computing with a Mobile App Calculator
Credit: pexels.com, A Man with Wedding Ring Computing with a Mobile App Calculator

You can add funds to a payroll card in multiple ways, including transferring money from a checking account or prepaid card, setting up a direct paycheck deposit, purchasing a reload pack, or transferring funds through the card's financial institution or at specific retail locations.

Adding money to a payroll card is convenient and flexible, allowing you to manage your finances easily.

An employer can set up a direct paycheck deposit to the payroll card, making it a seamless way to receive your pay.

Purchasing a reload pack is another way to add money to your payroll card, and it's a great option if you need to top up your funds quickly.

You can use a payroll card like a debit card, withdrawing funds from an ATM and making online purchases.

Once the funds are transferred to your payroll card, the money is available instantly, making it a great option for those who need quick access to their funds.

With a payroll card, you can make online purchases and pay bills, just like you would with a debit card.

Debit Cards for Employees

Flat lay of financial documents, euro note, calculator, smartphone, and key for budget management.
Credit: pexels.com, Flat lay of financial documents, euro note, calculator, smartphone, and key for budget management.

Debit cards for employees are a great option for those without a primary bank account. They can use their paycheck instantly and avoid expensive check-cashing fees.

Payroll debit cards are similar to regular debit cards, allowing employees to make online transactions, shop, and withdraw cash from ATMs. Employers can also add other funds and reimbursements into the account.

Employers can't make payroll debit cards mandatory, so they should offer direct deposit or a paycheck as an alternative. Card issuers like Visa and Mastercard help employers provide payroll debit cards for employees.

How Debit Cards Work

Debit cards are a convenient and efficient way to pay employees. They can be used as a replacement for paper checks, digitizing the payroll process entirely.

To get started, an employer collaborates with a card issuer to provide payroll debit cards for employees. They discuss their requirements and subscribe to the ideal plan.

The employer doesn't need their employees' banking details to transfer the salary to a payroll card. They simply add funds to the card, which the employee can access instantly.

Payroll debit cards are accepted everywhere, making them a practical choice. Each card comes with a pin, card number, and CVV for secure use.

There are no monthly fees to use payroll debit cards for small businesses, making them a cost-effective option.

Debit for Employees

Gold Round Coin on Top of Paper Money
Credit: pexels.com, Gold Round Coin on Top of Paper Money

Payroll debit cards work like any other debit card, automatically sending cash to the employee's card during payment time.

The funds are available instantly, allowing employees to withdraw cash from an ATM and make online purchases.

Employers can issue payroll debit cards to their employees and load their monthly wages into the card.

Employees can use this card for online transactions, shopping, ATM withdrawals, and other financial needs.

Employers can also add other funds and reimbursements into this account, making it a convenient option for employees.

Employees don't need to have a bank account to use a payroll debit card, making it a resourceful option for those without a traditional bank account.

Employers can't make it mandatory for employees to receive payroll debit cards, instead they should opt for direct deposit or sending a paycheck.

Card issuers like Visa and Mastercard help employers provide payroll debit cards for employees.

For more insights, see: Ach Bank Payment

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a prepaid card and a payroll card?

A prepaid card is a general-purpose card that can be loaded with funds for various expenses, whereas a payroll card is specifically designed for receiving payroll payments and may have limited reload options.

What are the disadvantages of payroll or other prepaid cards?

Payroll and prepaid cards have two main drawbacks: they don't earn interest and may come with additional fees. They also carry the risk of being lost or stolen

Teresa Halvorson

Senior Writer

Teresa Halvorson is a skilled writer with a passion for financial journalism. Her expertise lies in breaking down complex topics into engaging, easy-to-understand content. With a keen eye for detail, Teresa has successfully covered a range of article categories, including currency exchange rates and foreign exchange rates.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.