CMIA vs HIPAA: California's Stricter Medical Data Protection Law

California's CMIA law is a more stringent medical data protection law compared to HIPAA. It requires healthcare providers to implement robust security measures to safeguard patient data.

The CMIA law mandates the use of encryption for electronic protected health information, which is a more comprehensive requirement than HIPAA's guidelines.

Healthcare providers must also conduct regular risk assessments to identify vulnerabilities and implement corrective measures.

The California Provisions of the CMIA are quite comprehensive.

The CMIA was enacted in 1981 and applies to a broad array of healthcare organizations, including medical doctors, hospitals, clinics, and more.

One of the key provisions under the CMIA is that it was one of the most stringent medical privacy laws at the time.

To ensure patient privacy, it's essential to understand the differences between HIPAA and the California Confidential Health Information Act (CMIA). HIPAA doesn't cover employers or employment records, but the CMIA requires employers to protect the security and privacy of all employee information, including health-related data.

The CMIA strengthens patient privacy in California, particularly for those under an insurance plan. For instance, a teenager under their parent's insurance policy can now keep a medical procedure private from their parents.

Employers must protect sensitive services like drug treatment, STD tests, birth control, and mental health care from being disclosed without the individual's consent. The CMIA requires insurers to honor confidential requests from individuals, even if they don't prove "endangerment."

To comply with the CMIA, organizations must train their employees on the specific requirements and update their policies regularly. This will ensure that employees are knowledgeable about patient privacy compliance and can protect both the business and patients.

Here are some key provisions under the CMIA:

The CMIA applies to a broad array of healthcare organizations, including medical doctors, hospitals, clinics, and more. It's one of the most stringent medical privacy laws enacted in 1981.

CMIA takes a more restrictive approach to medical information disclosure than HIPAA.

CMIA prohibits healthcare providers, insurers, and contractors from disclosing medical information related to sensitive services to anyone other than the enrollee without express written authorization.

This means a subscriber or enrollee can request "confidential communications" for all communications regarding their medical information, including provider name and address.

CMIA's new bill also applies to communications that disclose medical information or provider name and address related to receipt of medical services by the individual requesting the confidential communication.

The CMIA's newest bill sets further restrictions on healthcare providers, insurers, and their contractors, who are now prohibited from disclosing medical information related to sensitive services to anyone other than the enrollee without the individual's express written authorization.

This means that a subscriber or enrollee can request "confidential communications" for all communications regarding the individual's medical information, which applies to communications that disclose medical information or provider name and address related to receipt of medical services.

Healthcare providers must now obtain written authorization from patients before sharing sensitive information, even with family members or caregivers, unless it's in the best interest of the patient and only essential information is shared.

This change aims to prioritize patient control over their medical information and provide them with more autonomy in managing their healthcare communications.

HIPAA is a federal law that establishes national norms for the privacy and security of protected health data (PHI).

HIPAA allows verbal consent in certain scenarios, whereas CMIA requires written consent from patients before disclosing their health information.

HIPAA only allows for civil penalties for violations, whereas CMIA provides for both civil and criminal penalties.

HIPAA is primarily enforced by the Department of Health and Human Services' Office for Civil Rights.

HIPAA applies to a broader range of entities than CMIA, including healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses, as well as their business associates.

HIPAA affords patients the right to scrutinize and acquire a copy of their PHI, but does not provide the right to access their medical records like CMIA does.

HIPAA has lower maximum penalties than CMIA for certain types of violations.

Civil penalties can be steep, with fines of up to $25,000 per victim for each incident of violation. This can add up quickly, especially if multiple individuals are affected.

Medical providers who breach patient confidentiality may also face financial liability for damages incurred by the victims.

The CMIA takes non-compliance seriously, with civil and criminal penalties in place to deter medical professionals from mishandling patient information. These punishments aim to protect patients' rights and provide a way for them to seek restitution if their privacy is breached.

Civil penalties can be steep, with fines of up to $25,000 per victim for each incident of violation. This can add up quickly, especially if multiple patients are affected.

Medical providers who violate the CMIA can be held liable for paying damages experienced by individuals as a result of the breach, including medical costs, mental/emotional trauma, or lost wages. This can be a significant financial burden.

Victims of severe breaches may even be eligible for punitive damage awards, intended to punish the medical professional and prevent future infringements. This serves as a strong deterrent against non-compliance.

Criminal prosecution is also a possibility under the CMIA, with potential sanctions including monetary fines and prison time, or both. The severity of the punishment will depend on the nature and scope of the breach.

Under the CMIA, you can bring a claim against someone who carelessly released confidential information. You can seek either nominal damages of $1,000.00 or actual damages, if any, sustained by you.

If you can prove that someone knowingly and willfully obtained, disclosed, or used your medical information, they could face an administrative fine of up to $2,500 per violation.

Here are the specific damages you can claim under CMIA:

These fines and damages serve as a reminder of the importance of protecting confidential information and the consequences of mishandling it.

To ensure compliance with the California Medical Information Act (CMIA), organizations must prohibit the disclosure of medical information without authorization, except as specified. This is a crucial requirement to protect patient confidentiality.

Healthcare providers must store medical records in a way that preserves confidentiality. This includes creating, maintaining, preserving, storing, abandoning, destroying, or disposing of records in a manner that protects patient information.

Organizations must also train employees who fall under both HIPAA and CMIA on the specific requirements to ensure privacy compliance and patient privacy. This includes understanding and monitoring the differences between the two acts and updating policies regularly.

Here are some key requirements to keep in mind:

To ensure compliance with the California Medical Information Act (CMIA), healthcare providers must prohibit the disclosure of medical information without authorization, except in specific circumstances. This includes medical information about patients, enrollees, or subscribers.

Healthcare providers, service plans, pharmaceutical companies, and contractors must also store medical records in a way that preserves the confidentiality of the information they contain. This means they need to handle medical records carefully to maintain patient privacy.

Organizations and covered entities must train their employees on the specific requirements of the CMIA, including data privacy and cybersecurity. This is crucial for protecting patient information and preventing data breaches.

Here are the key CMIA requirements:

Claims related to privacy and data breaches can be challenging to navigate. The burden of proof often falls on the individual, making it difficult to establish liability.

In cases where a data breach occurs, the company responsible may claim that the breach was caused by a third-party vendor or service provider. This can lead to a lengthy and complex investigation.

The average cost of a data breach can range from $3.86 million to $4.24 million, depending on the industry and the number of records affected. This financial burden can be devastating for small businesses.

Companies often rely on encryption and firewalls to protect sensitive data, but these measures are not foolproof. In fact, 61% of data breaches involve a combination of phishing and other social engineering tactics.

Data breach claims can be particularly challenging in cases where the breach occurred due to a failure to implement industry-standard security protocols. This can be a difficult issue to resolve, especially if the company claims that they were not aware of the breach until it was too late.

The lack of clear regulations and enforcement can make it difficult for individuals to hold companies accountable for data breaches. In some cases, companies may be able to avoid liability by claiming that they were not aware of the breach or that it was caused by a third-party vendor.

CMIA and HIPAA both require authorization from patients before sharing their protected health information. This means that healthcare providers must obtain explicit permission from patients before disclosing their medical records.

HIPAA has more stringent requirements for authorization, requiring that it be in writing and signed by the patient. CMIA, on the other hand, allows for verbal authorization in some cases.

Written Authorization is a crucial step in ensuring patients' medical data is handled with care. Medical providers must get written authorization from patients before releasing their medical data to any third party, apart from what the law allows or in urgent circumstances.

This means patients must explicitly give their consent in writing before their medical records can be shared with other clinicians, insurers, employers, or relatives. The authorization must be supported by the patient or a designated representative.

The authorization must plainly state the reason for disclosing the information and detail exactly what information will be shared and to whom. This transparency helps patients understand who will have access to their data and why.

Partnering with Accountable HQ can provide healthcare providers with the tools and information needed to navigate complex data security, privacy legislation, and risk management.

Their risk and compliance software-as-a-service platform can offer a comprehensive solution for compliance with the CMIA and other relevant privacy laws.

Accountable HQ's platform can help ensure peace of mind and compliance for healthcare providers and patients alike.

Partnering with them can be a great step towards protecting medical privacy rights and staying on top of regulatory requirements.