Bitcoin multisig wallets are a type of digital wallet that allows multiple users to control and manage a shared Bitcoin address.
This setup provides an extra layer of security and accountability, as all parties must agree on transactions before they can be executed.
A multisig wallet typically requires a minimum number of signatures to authorize a transaction, which can range from 2 to 5 or more, depending on the setup.
This means that even if one user loses their private key or is compromised, the remaining users can still access and manage the funds.
What is a Multi-Sig Wallet?
A multisig wallet is a smart contract-based wallet that requires two or more digital signatures to agree on the validity and execution of transactions.
It involves creating multiple private keys held by different individuals or entities, making it a more secure option compared to traditional wallets.
The number of signatures required to sign a transaction depends on the specific configuration and use case of the wallet.
For instance, a “3-4” wallet implies the multisig wallet is shared by four signatories, requiring three out of four participants to sign for each transaction.
This robust security mechanism minimizes the risk of unauthorized or fraudulent use of community funds.
Benefits and Advantages
Bitcoin multisig offers unbeatable security by equally distributing the power between signing authorities, eliminating "key person" risks common with single-signature wallets.
Even if one key is compromised, an attacker still needs access to other keys to gain control of the wallet. This ensures malicious members within the team cannot run off with the assets.
Multisig wallets enable trustless transactions due to their decentralized nature. Community members can track the wallet on block explorers, and see precisely when trusted parties move assets.
No one can move assets without the permission of all the signing members, so the community can track any suspicious activity in real time.
Transaction speed is also improved with multisig wallets, but the article doesn't provide more information on this topic.
Some popular wallets that have implemented multisig include:
- Armory
- CarbonWallet
- Copay
- Bitgo
- Blocktrail
- GreenAddress
- Casa
- Electrum
- Xapo
- Coinkite
- Coinb.in
Types of Multi-Sig Wallets
A 2-of-3 multisig wallet requires any 2 signatures out of a total of 3 to authorize a transaction, making it useful for situations where multiple parties must approve a decision.
The Bitcoin protocol supports multisig through special scripts called P2SH (Pay to Script Hash), where funds are locked by a redeem script, and the conditions for spending it are defined.
Multisig wallets are implemented by various wallets, including Armory, CarbonWallet, and Copay.
You can set up a 1 or 3-of-4 multisig wallet, which provides distributed backup, allowing the wallet owner to spend funds at will, but if they lose access to their key, they can recover it with the help of trusted friends or organizations holding the remaining keys.
A common type of multisig is m-of-n, where m is the number of signatures required and n is the total number of public keys associated with the address.
Creating and Managing a Multi-Sig Wallet
Creating a multi-sig wallet involves multiple parties setting up their own wallets and generating their cryptographic key pairs. This is useful in situations where you want to distribute control of funds across different devices or people to reduce risks.
You can create a 2-of-3 multisig wallet, for example, by gathering or generating 3 bitcoin addresses on different machines. Each address will have a public key, which you can get using the validateaddress RPC command.
A 2-of-3 multisig wallet requires any 2 signatures out of a total of 3 to authorize a transaction. This is useful in situations where multiple parties must approve a decision or where you want to distribute control of funds across different devices or people to reduce risks.
To create a multi-sig wallet, you can use a tool like Ledger and Unchained. Here's a step-by-step guide:
- Create an Individual account on Unchained and go to the “Keys” tab.
- To create your first key, choose “Ledger” from the options and export your extended public key (xpub) from your Ledger device via the prompt.
- Once done, you’ll see the extended public key on the screen. Click on “Next” to confirm and create your first key. Repeat this process for the number of key holders in your multisig wallet.
- Now, go to the “Vault” tab, choose the keys you’ve added, and create your multisig wallet.
Some popular wallets that have implemented multisig include Armory, CarbonWallet, Copay, Bitgo, and Blocktrail.
Here are some examples of how multi-sig wallets can be used:
- A 2-of-2 multisig wallet between two partners in a business to prevent either partner from spending the funds unilaterally.
- A 3-of-5 multisig wallet for a company to secure their Bitcoin holdings by requiring approval from multiple executives.
- A 2-of-3 multisig wallet for a DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization) to manage their treasury and require at least two members' approval for transactions.
Remember, a multi-sig wallet is only as strong as its private key's protectors, so it's essential to keep your private keys secure!
Security and Authentication
Using a multisig wallet can prevent problems caused by the loss or theft of a private key, keeping your funds safe even if one key is compromised.
Imagine storing each private key in a different place or device, like a mobile phone, laptop, and tablet. This makes it much harder for a thief to access your funds using just one key.
Malicious attacks are less likely to succeed if you use a multisig wallet, as a hacker would most likely only have access to a single device and key.
If you lose one of your private keys, you can still access your funds using the other keys, which is a big advantage of multisig wallets.
Creating a multisig wallet that requires two keys can also create a two-factor authentication mechanism, ensuring that only someone with access to both keys can make a transaction.
However, using a 2-of-2 multisig address can be dangerous, as you won't be able to access your funds if one of the keys is lost. It's safer to use a 2-of-3 setup or a third-party 2FA service.
The private keys needed to spend from a wallet can be spread across multiple machines, eliminating any one of those machines as a single point of failure.
Real-World Applications
Bitcoin multisig wallets are a secure way to manage your Bitcoin holdings. Corporations can use them to secure their Bitcoin holdings by requiring approval from multiple executives.
A company may set up a 3-of-5 multisig wallet, requiring at least three directors to sign off on a transaction. This adds an extra layer of security to prevent unauthorized transactions.
Corporate Treasury Management
Corporate treasury management is a key area where Bitcoin multisig wallets can provide a secure solution. A company can set up a 3-of-5 multisig wallet, requiring at least three directors to sign off on a transaction.
This setup ensures that no single individual has control over the company's Bitcoin holdings. In fact, corporations can secure their Bitcoin holdings by requiring approval from multiple executives.
Multisig wallets can help prevent unauthorized transactions and provide an added layer of security for a company's digital assets. For instance, a company may set up a 3-of-5 multisig wallet, requiring at least three directors to sign off on a transaction.
This approach can provide peace of mind for company executives and stakeholders, knowing that their digital assets are protected from potential misuse.
Crypto Inheritance Planning
Multisig wallets offer a robust solution for inheritance planning. They allow a Bitcoin holder to set up a wallet where trusted family members or friends hold keys, ensuring that funds are recoverable upon the holder's death.
Using a multisig wallet can reduce the risk of a single entity having control over shared funds, which is a major concern in web3 communities. A multisig wallet paired with a Ledger hardware wallet device increases security and decentralization.
Trusted family members or friends holding keys in a multisig wallet can ensure that funds are recoverable upon the holder's death. This is a more secure option than relying on a single entity to manage and protect the funds.
Multisig wallets are a great way to share and manage funds, especially in web3 communities. They are key components of effective community security, but only if the private keys are secure.
Advanced Topics
In a Bitcoin multisig setup, you can have multiple private keys, but only a certain number of them are required to authorize a transaction. This number is called the "threshold".
Having multiple private keys adds an extra layer of security, as a single compromised key won't be enough to authorize a transaction. For example, if you have a 2-of-3 multisig setup, a hacker would need to steal two keys to gain control of your funds.
The threshold can be set to any number, depending on the level of security you need. However, having a higher threshold means you'll need more signatures to authorize a transaction, which can be inconvenient.
History and Origins
Bitcoin's Multisig feature was introduced by BIP11, which allowed for up to 3 co-signers in m-of-n standard transactions.
These transactions used P2SH addresses, which start with the character '3'.
The m-of-n standard has been superseded by P2WSH multisig addresses, which allow up to 20 co-signers and start with "bc1q".
Address Dynamics
A multisig wallet uses a P2SH (Pay-to-Script-Hash) address, which is generated by hashing a redeem script.
The redeem script defines the policy, such as 1-of-2, and is used to verify if the number of signatures matches the quorum. To spend funds, the redeem script and valid signatures must be provided.
The script hash is used to generate the P2SH address, which starts with a "3" (for example, 3FZbgi29cpjq2GjdwV8eyHuJJnkLtktZc5). Funds sent to this address are locked until the correct script is provided later.
Creating a multisig address involves gathering or generating multiple public keys, and then hashing the script that includes these public keys and the m-of-n signature requirement. This hashed script becomes the P2SH address.
Here's a breakdown of the P2SH address dynamics:
To spend funds from a P2SH address, the owner(s) must provide the original multisig script and the valid signatures needed to satisfy the multisig requirement. The Bitcoin network checks that the hash of the script matches the P2SH address and verifies the signatures using the OP_CHECKMULTISIG opcode.
Lightning Network
The Lightning Network is a game-changer for Bitcoin transactions. Multisig is a fundamental component of it, allowing two parties to lock funds in a multisig contract.
By using multisig contracts, parties can settle their final balance on-chain after multiple transactions, reducing fees and increasing scalability. This is a key benefit of the Lightning Network.
Payment channels are a crucial part of the Lightning Network, enabling multiple transactions to be processed off-chain.
Disadvantages and Limitations
Setting up a multisig wallet requires some technical knowledge, especially if you don't want to rely on third-party providers.
You may need to seek legal recourse if something goes wrong, but since blockchain and multisig addresses are relatively new, this can be a challenge.
Transaction speed is often slow due to the need for confirmation from many parties.
This can be a problem for communities that need quick or frequent transactions, so some funds can be moved to a hot wallet and the bulk of the funds can be kept in the multisig wallets.
Fund recovery can be complex in multisig wallets, especially if one key holder loses access or becomes unresponsive.
Users must import multiple recovery phrases from different devices, which can be a hassle.
Examples in Practice
Bitcoin multisig wallets have been implemented in various real-world applications. One notable example is the cold storage wallet of the Bitfinex exchange, which is a single 3-of-6 multisig address containing 141,177 BTC, valued at $1.5 billion as of December 2017.
The keys to this wallet are presumably kept very safe by Bitfinex's operators. This highlights the importance of secure key management in multisig wallets.
Bitcoin multisig wallets can offer solutions to a variety of practical problems. Here are some real-world applications:
- Bitfinex's cold storage wallet
- Other corporate use cases
- Individual use cases
Sources
- https://academy.binance.com/en/articles/what-is-a-multisig-wallet
- https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/understanding-bitcoin-multisignatures-deep-dive-enhanced-martins-xbx4f
- https://empoweredlaw.com/multisignature-in-bitcoin-what-it-is-what-it-isnt/
- https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Multi-signature
- https://www.ledger.com/academy/what-is-a-multisig-wallet
Featured Images: pexels.com