Bank Runs Out of Money: Causes, Prevention, and Protection

Author

Reads 982

Two ATMs on city street with people using them and bank poster nearby.
Credit: pexels.com, Two ATMs on city street with people using them and bank poster nearby.

A bank run out of money can be a stressful and unpredictable situation for customers. This can happen when a large number of depositors withdraw their money at the same time, causing a liquidity crisis.

The causes of a bank run can be attributed to a loss of confidence in the bank's ability to meet its financial obligations. This can be triggered by rumors of the bank's financial instability or poor management practices.

A bank's inability to meet its depositors' withdrawal demands can lead to a freeze on withdrawals, making it difficult for customers to access their funds. This can have serious consequences for individuals and businesses that rely on their deposits for daily operations.

In the event of a bank run, it's essential to stay calm and informed. Knowing the causes and prevention strategies can help mitigate the impact of a bank run.

What is a Bank Run?

A bank run occurs when a large number of customers suddenly withdraw their deposits from a bank due to fears that the institution is on the brink of collapse.

A man wearing a mask using an ATM machine outdoors for cash withdrawal.
Credit: pexels.com, A man wearing a mask using an ATM machine outdoors for cash withdrawal.

This mass withdrawal can create a self-fulfilling prophecy, as the bank may struggle to return the funds, ultimately leading to its failure.

In traditional banking systems, institutions hold only a small portion of their assets in cash, reserving the majority in available-for-sale or held-to-maturity instruments like government bonds and loans.

A bank run can wipe out shareholders, bondholders, and depositors beyond the insured amount, leading to a financial crisis and economic recession.

Multiple bank runs can create a banking panic, which can lead to the instability of the entire banking system.

Regulators must step in to ensure an orderly return of depositor funds and mitigate a broader panic.

A wave of bank runs is one of the major contributing factors to the Great Depression, after Americans lost faith in the banking system due to a wave of bank failures.

Causes and Prevention

A bank run occurs when public fear causes customers to withdraw their money en masse, putting pressure on the bank's liquidity.

Credit: youtube.com, Bank Runs Explained in One Minute: How Banks Become Insolvent and Fail

This can happen even if the bank is not actually insolvent, and it's often fueled by panic rather than a rational assessment of the bank's financial situation.

In fact, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) was created in 1933 to help reduce the likelihood of bank runs by insuring deposits up to $250,000 per depositor, per FDIC-insured bank, per ownership category.

The FDIC has been successful in preventing depositors from losing a penny of insured funds since its establishment.

A bank may limit withdrawals or suspend them altogether to deal with the panic, but in extreme cases, a complete shutdown may be necessary, as seen in the US bank holiday on March 6, 1933.

Causes of a Run

A bank run can occur due to a loss of customer trust, which can create panic and lead to a rush of withdrawals. This can happen even if the bank is not actually insolvent.

Public fear and perception of rising risk can perpetuate a cycle that triggers even more withdrawals, putting a strain on the bank's ability to manage its daily reserves.

Steel Heavy Doors of Vault
Credit: pexels.com, Steel Heavy Doors of Vault

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) was created to help reduce the likelihood of bank runs by insuring up to $250,000 per depositor, per FDIC-insured bank, per ownership category.

Economic uncertainty, fueled by geopolitical tensions, trade wars, and the lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, has left many people feeling uneasy about the stability of financial institutions.

In the United States, a bank run can be a major destabilizing force due to the fractional-reserve banking system, where banks only keep a small portion of their assets in cash.

If a bank completely runs out of cash, it can become insolvent and fail, causing a bank to collapse that wouldn't have otherwise.

The recent high-profile bank run at Silicon Valley Bank was triggered by the bank's announcement of a $1.8 billion loss, which caused major venture capital firms to urge startups to pull their money out of the bank.

Low-Interest Rates

Low-Interest Rates can make it less appealing to keep money in a savings account. This can lead to customers withdrawing their funds during a crisis, increasing the likelihood of a bank run.

Credit: youtube.com, How Low Can Interest Rates Go? A One Minute Perspective on "Modern-Day" Central Banking Limits

Central banks have maintained low-interest rates to stimulate economic growth, but this policy has its drawbacks. Low-interest rates can make savings accounts less attractive, causing people to withdraw their money.

Customers may be more inclined to withdraw their funds if they perceive a crisis, which can exacerbate the likelihood of a bank run.

Deposit Insurance

Deposit insurance is a safety net that protects customers' deposits in case a bank fails. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) was formed in the United States after the Great Depression to ensure customers get their money back if a bank becomes insolvent.

Insurance on customer deposits guarantees that customers will get their money back up to the insured amount. This guarantee helps restore public confidence in the banking system.

The FDIC may facilitate a resolution, such as an acquisition by a bank with high capital reserves, to backstop a vulnerable bank and its customers. The customers can then access their deposits under the combined bank.

A less desirable option is for the FDIC to seize the vulnerable bank and conduct an auction of the assets to raise funds to return to depositors. Any shortfall will be covered by a change in deposit insurance premiums paid by the industry.

Preparation and Protection

Woman using an ATM machine while wearing protective gloves indoors.
Credit: pexels.com, Woman using an ATM machine while wearing protective gloves indoors.

Having an emergency fund can help you weather a bank run, but it's also essential to keep your money in a safe and secure place. Emergency funds can provide a cushion in case of unexpected expenses or financial setbacks.

You can safeguard your finances by keeping your money in an FDIC-insured bank or credit union. FDIC insurance protects your deposits up to $250,000, and credit unions have their own federal deposit insurance through the NCUSIF.

Money kept in a high-yield savings account earns interest, which is more than you'll get by keeping cash under your mattress.

Protecting Your Money

Having an emergency fund is crucial in case of a bank run, where many people withdraw their money at the same time. This can happen due to modern bank runs, which are often caused by economic downturns.

You can keep your money safe in a bank, even during a bank run, if it's FDIC-insured and within the FDIC's limits and guidelines. This means your money is protected up to $250,000 per account and owner.

Credit: youtube.com, How YOU can protect your money & prepare for troubling times | Economy Update PART 3

Keeping your money under your mattress or at home can be risky, as you could lose it all in the event of a fire or theft. This is because there's no guarantee you'll be able to recover the funds, unlike money that's kept in an FDIC-insured bank.

Even if your bank experiences a run on deposits, your money would remain safe as long as it's FDIC-insured. You can also consider keeping a portion of your funds in a separate FDIC-insured bank if you're a big saver.

Signature

Signature Bank's collapse in March 2023 highlights the importance of being prepared and protected in the financial world.

The bank's stock experienced a sharp decrease in value, and its customers withdrew billions in funds, sparking a run on deposits.

Signature Bank held nearly $88 billion in deposits, with nearly nine-tenths being uninsured.

The bank accepted deposits in cryptocurrency, which has been in a tailspin since the collapse of crypto exchange FTX in November 2022.

The FDIC transferred the bank's deposits and assets into the newly formed Signature Bridge Bank, making all deposits, both insured and uninsured, whole.

Banking System and Crisis

Credit: youtube.com, Can banks Run out of Money? History of Bank Runs.

The banking system is designed to be resilient, but it's not foolproof. A bank run can occur when a large number of depositors withdraw their money at the same time, causing a liquidity crisis.

In the United States, the Federal Reserve plays a crucial role in maintaining financial stability, but even they have limits to their power. The Fed can provide emergency loans to banks, but it can't just print money out of thin air.

A bank run can happen at any time, but it's more likely to occur during economic downturns or periods of high inflation. The 2008 global financial crisis was a prime example of this, with many banks facing massive withdrawals.

The FDIC, or Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, is a government agency that insures bank deposits up to $250,000. This means that if a bank fails, depositors with insured accounts will get their money back.

In the event of a bank run, banks can use various strategies to manage the situation, such as raising interest rates on deposits or selling assets to raise cash.

Notable Examples

Credit: youtube.com, What if a Bank Runs Out of Money

Silicon Valley Bank experienced a massive run on deposits in March 2023, with customers withdrawing $42 million after the bank's stock prices plummeted.

The bank's CEO, Greg Becker, announced a loss of nearly $2 billion in assets, triggering the rush to withdraw funds. This led to a negative balance of $958 million for the bank.

The FDIC covered all of the bank's deposits, which were mostly uninsured, with 94 percent of deposits not protected by insurance.

History

The history of these notable examples is a long and fascinating one. The first recorded instance of this phenomenon dates back to the early 19th century.

The 1830s saw the rise of pioneers like Florence Nightingale, who revolutionized the field of nursing with her innovative approaches to patient care. She is still widely regarded as the founder of modern nursing.

The mid-20th century witnessed a significant shift in the way these examples were perceived and utilized. The 1950s and 1960s saw a surge in the development of new technologies that enabled widespread adoption and application of these examples.

The 1970s and 1980s were marked by a growing recognition of the importance of these examples in various fields, including education and healthcare.

Silicon Valley

Exterior of modern bank building with arched passages
Credit: pexels.com, Exterior of modern bank building with arched passages

Silicon Valley Bank experienced a run on deposits on March 9, 2023, when stock prices plummeted and customers withdrew $42 million from the bank, leaving it with a negative balance of $958 million.

The bank's CEO, Greg Becker, announced the bank had lost nearly $2 billion in assets, which triggered the rush to withdraw funds. This resulted in the FDIC covering all of the deposits, despite the fact that 94% of the bank's deposits were uninsured.

The bank was closed by state regulators the following day, marking the second largest bank failure in U.S. history. A temporary bridge bank was created, much of which was then acquired by First Citizens Bank on March 27.

The bank run started after Silicon Valley Bank announced it had sold $21 billion in Treasury bonds, resulting in a $1.8 billion loss. This caused major venture capital firms to worry about the bank’s financial condition.

Washington Mutual

Washington Mutual was the largest bank to fail in U.S. history, collapsing in the fall of 2008.

Credit: youtube.com, Do You Remember Washington Mutual? What happened to them?

Customers withdrew $16.7 billion in deposits during a nine-day bank run leading up to WaMu's collapse, which is around 9 percent of deposits held by the bank.

The bank was closed by the Office of Thrift Supervision on Sept. 25, 2008, and placed into receivership with the FDIC.

JPMorgan Chase acquired WaMu banking subsidiaries for $1.9 billion, and WaMu branches were converted to Chase branches.

United States

Silicon Valley Bank's closure in 2023 was the second largest bank failure in U.S. history. It was triggered by a run on deposits after the bank's CEO announced a $2 billion loss in assets.

In 1930, the Bank of United States failed due to a run on deposits that was sparked by a failed merger. This event helped create the Great Depression.

The FDIC covered all of Silicon Valley Bank's deposits, despite 94% being uninsured. This is a testament to the FDIC's commitment to protecting depositors.

Old cash register sitting in a decaying, abandoned building with peeling paint and debris.
Credit: pexels.com, Old cash register sitting in a decaying, abandoned building with peeling paint and debris.

The closure of Silicon Valley Bank led to the creation of a temporary bridge bank, which was later acquired by First Citizens Bank. This highlights the importance of swift action in times of financial crisis.

The Bank of United States' collapse in 1930 triggered a series of bank runs across the country, contributing to the Great Depression.

Mitigation and Prevention Measures

Bank runs can be a serious threat to the stability of the financial system. Several techniques have been used to help prevent or mitigate bank runs.

One of these techniques is using bank run mitigation measures. In a situation where a banking institution faces the threat of insolvency due to a bank run, it may use these measures to mitigate the run.

Banking institutions can use techniques such as preventing or mitigating bank runs to avoid financial instability. Several techniques have been used to help prevent or mitigate bank runs.

Bank run mitigation measures can include actions to prevent a bank run from occurring in the first place.

Borrowing and Deposits

Credit: youtube.com, How Banks Create Money - Macro Topic 4.4

Banks can borrow money from other banks or the central bank to prevent going bankrupt.

The Central Bank is known as the lender of last resort, loaning out money to struggling banks to prevent a wave of bankruptcies.

In 2023, the Federal Reserve introduced a new program called the Bank Term Funding Program (BTFP) to backstop institutions requiring liquidity.

The BTFP has a potential coverage of approximately $300 billion in deposits, based on a 2022 capital ratio of 12x at banks the Federal Reserve oversees.

The US Department of the Treasury guarantees the Federal Reserve for up to $25 billion under this program.

Elena Feeney-Jacobs

Junior Writer

Elena Feeney-Jacobs is a seasoned writer with a deep interest in the Australian real estate market. Her insightful articles have shed light on the operations of major real estate companies and investment trusts, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of the industry. She has a particular focus on companies listed on the Australian Securities Exchange and those based in Sydney, offering valuable insights into the local and national economies.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.