In Texas, insurance companies have a responsibility to act in good faith when handling claims. If they fail to do so, they may be considered to be acting in bad faith.
Bad faith insurance claims can arise when an insurance company denies a claim without a valid reason or delays payment. This can cause significant financial hardship for policyholders.
To qualify as a bad faith insurance claim in Texas, the insurance company must have acted with a deliberate intent to mislead or deceive the policyholder.
What is Bad Faith Insurance Claim?
Bad faith insurance claims in Texas can be a real challenge for policyholders.
Insurance companies are supposed to act in good faith when handling claims, but sometimes they step out of line.
It's not just about denying a claim, but also about how and why they do it.
Types of Bad Faith Insurance Claim
In Texas, you've got two main ways to call out an insurance company that isn't playing fair: Common Law Bad Faith and Statutory Bad Faith.
Common Law Bad Faith is based on how things have been done over the years, like an age-old tradition of fairness.
Statutory Bad Faith, on the other hand, is the specific set of rules written down to keep insurance companies in check.
These two types of bad faith claims give you tools to hold your insurance company accountable if they're not treating you fairly.
Proving Bad Faith Insurance Claim
Proving bad faith insurance claims in Texas requires more than a simple error. The plaintiff must show that the insurance company engaged in unreasonable or grossly negligent conduct which was a cause of recognized damages.
To prove bad faith, you'll need to gather evidence, like a puzzle. This could be emails, letters, or notes from phone calls where the insurance company promised one thing and did another.
Keep records of all communications with your insurance company, including emails, letters, and phone calls. This will help you track any delays and the reasons given for them.
A simple delay is not enough to prove bad faith, but if the insurer barely conducts any investigation and just summarily denies the claim, it could be liable for engaging in bad faith conduct.
If the insurance company deliberately lies to you about your claim, such as saying it's not covered when it actually is, they could be liable for bad faith for the policy benefit as well as damage caused, including potentially attorneys fees.
Get a copy of your insurance policy and highlight any sections relevant to your claim and the insurer's actions. This will help you understand your policy and the insurance company's obligations.
Carrier Warning Signs
Lack of communication is a significant warning sign that an insurance carrier may be acting in bad faith. This can manifest as an insurer being unresponsive or giving the policyholder the runaround, making it difficult to reach them or get updates on the claim.
If an insurer denies a claim without providing a clear explanation, it may be a sign of bad faith. This is in direct violation of the insurer's duty to provide reasoning for the denial.
Lowball settlement offers are another tactic used by insurance carriers to avoid paying out valid claims. If a policyholder suspects their insurer is pressuring them to accept a settlement that is unfair or too low, it could be an indication of bad faith activity.
What Constitutes an Act?
A bad faith act by an insurance company can be as simple as denying a valid claim without a good reason.
Saying no to your claim when the facts clearly support that they should say yes is a classic example of a bad faith act.
Taking too long to make a decision on your claim is another red flag, as it can be a deliberate attempt to delay payment.
Not being clear about why they denied your claim is also a sign of bad faith, leaving you in the dark and unable to understand what went wrong.
Insurance companies have a responsibility to be transparent and fair in their dealings with policyholders, and failing to meet this standard can have serious consequences.
Carrier Warning Signs
Lack of communication is a major red flag, as insurers are required to acknowledge claims, begin investigations, and pay out accepted claims within specific statutory periods in Texas.
Denying claims without explanation is another sign of bad faith, as insurers must provide reasoning for claim rejections.
Lowball settlement offers are a common tactic to pressure policyholders into accepting unfair settlements.
Delays in handling claims, repeated requests for the same information, or long periods of silence from the insurer can all be tactics to pressure you into giving up or accepting a lower settlement.
If the insurer becomes unresponsive or is incredibly slow in its claim investigation, it may be attempting to delay payment.
Misrepresentation, such as an insurance agent giving you incorrect information about your policy's coverage, is a form of bad faith.
Intimidation tactics, like threats to cancel your policy or take legal action against you, are clear signs of bad faith.
Don't be fooled by an insurer's friendly demeanor - they're for-profit businesses that will ultimately work for their own benefit and try to avoid paying out valid claims.
Consequences of Bad Faith Insurance Claim
If you're dealing with a bad faith insurance claim in Texas, it's essential to understand the potential consequences. You can recover up to three times the amount of actual damages if you prevail in court.
Insurance companies are tasked with disproving their violation, but it's often best to have a lawyer on your side. They can help you navigate the complex process and ensure you receive fair compensation.
You can recover reasonable and necessary attorney fees if you win your case. This can include costs associated with hiring a lawyer to represent you.
The court may also award other relief deemed proper, which can vary depending on the circumstances of your case. It's crucial to work with an experienced lawyer who knows how to advocate for your rights.
If you're successful in proving bad faith, you may be entitled to treble damages, which is three times the amount the insurance company should have paid you. This is typically awarded when the insurance company intentionally or knowingly acted in bad faith.
Attorney's fees, interest, and court costs are also recoverable in a bad faith insurance lawsuit. This can help offset the costs associated with pursuing your claim.
Punitive damages may also be awarded to punish the insurance company for its bad behavior. These damages can vary depending on the severity of the insurance company's actions.
Here are some of the potential damages you may be able to recover in a bad faith insurance lawsuit:
- Up to three times the amount the insurance company would have paid if it had processed the policyholder's claim properly
- Attorneys' fees, interest, and court costs
- Statutory penalties in the form of interest for delayed payments
- Punitive damages to punish the insurance company for its bad behavior
If you're dealing with a bad faith insurance claim, it's essential to work with an experienced lawyer who knows how to navigate the complex process. They can help you recover the compensation you deserve and hold the insurance company accountable for its actions.
Policyholder Rights
As a policyholder in Texas, you have certain rights that are designed to protect you from unfair treatment by your insurance company. You have the right to fair and honest treatment when making a claim.
The Consumer Bill of Rights, which is required to be included with your policy, outlines nearly 50 provisions that ensure you're treated fairly. However, for the sake of time, let's focus on some of the most essential rights.
Here are some of your rights as a policyholder:
- The right to fair and honest treatment when making a claim
- The right to reject any settlement amount, including unfair violations offered by the insurance company
- The right to an explanation in writing for why a claim or part of a claim was denied
- The right to refuse to provide an insurance company with information that does not relate to a claim
- The right to protection from discrimination
- The right to sue an insurance company that violated your rights
These rights are in place to prevent insurance companies from taking advantage of policyholders. If you feel like your rights have been violated, it's essential to know that you have the right to seek legal action.
Laws and Regulations
Texas has laws in place to protect consumers from bad faith practices by insurance companies. According to the Texas Insurance Code, Section 541.060, bad faith includes misrepresenting policy provisions or failing to attempt a prompt, fair, and equitable settlement.
The Texas Supreme Court recognized a common law claim for bad faith in 1983, as stated in English v. Fischer, 660 S.W.2d 521 (Tex. 1983). This claim requires proof that the insurance company denied or delayed the claim despite liability being reasonably clear.
Texas law identifies specific conduct that may give rise to a bad faith claim, including misrepresenting policy terms, failing to reasonably explain a denied claim, and refusing to pay a claim without conducting a reasonable investigation.
If you believe your insurance company has acted in bad faith, you may be entitled to recover damages, including treble damages, attorney's fees, interest, and court costs. To prove bad faith, you must show that the insurance company intentionally or knowingly acted in bad faith.
Here are some examples of bad faith conduct that may be considered under Texas law:
- Misrepresenting the terms of a policy
- Failing to reasonably explain why a claim was denied
- Denying a claim after failing to conduct a reasonable investigation
- Failing to render a decision within a reasonable period of time
- Refusing to reach a reasonable settlement
- Attempting to claim a full settlement has been reached when only a partial settlement has been reached
If an internal review doesn't lead to a fair outcome, you can file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), which oversees insurance practices and can intervene on your behalf.
Insurance Claim Process
The insurance claim process in Texas can be lengthy and complex.
In Texas, insurance companies are required to acknowledge receipt of a claim within 15 days.
You'll need to provide detailed documentation to support your claim, including policy information and evidence of damages.
The insurance company has 30 days to investigate and make a decision on your claim.
Be aware that the insurance company may request additional information or evidence during this time.
If your claim is denied, you have the right to appeal the decision.
Recovering from Bad Faith Insurance Claim
If you believe an insurance company has acted in bad faith or violated your rights, you have the right to sue them. You can recover damages, including up to three times the amount of actual damages.
Insurance companies will try to disprove their violation, but if you prevail, you can also recover reasonable and necessary attorney fees. This can be a significant advantage in a lawsuit.
If you're considering suing an insurance company, it's essential to speak with an attorney who has experience working with insurance companies. They can help you navigate the process and ensure you receive every penny you're entitled to.
Here are the types of damages you can recover if you prevail in a lawsuit:
- Up to three times the amount of actual damages
- Reasonable and necessary attorney fees
- Any other relief the court deems proper
Insurance Company Tactics
Insurance companies may use various tactics to delay or deny your claim, including delaying the handling of your claim, asking for the same information repeatedly, or going silent for long periods of time.
These tactics are designed to pressure you into accepting a lower settlement or giving up on your claim altogether. It's like a waiting game, where the insurer hopes you'll blink first.
Insurers may also threaten you with higher premiums, policy cancellation, or other consequences if you don't settle your claim quickly. This is considered a bad faith action.
If an insurer misleads you about your policy, plays dumb about your claim, or outright lies, it's a sign of dishonesty and bad faith. They might even try to commit fraud by intentionally deceiving you for their own gain.
Payment delays can cause significant financial strain, especially if your business has ongoing expenses like payroll, rent, and utilities. If your insurer becomes unresponsive or slow in investigating your claim, they may be trying to delay payment.
Threats
Insurance companies can sometimes use threats to try to coerce you into accepting a lowball settlement or even denying your claim. This is considered a bad faith action.
Threatening to cancel your policy or raise your premiums is a common tactic insurers use to intimidate policyholders. Don't let them bully you into settling for less than you deserve.
If an insurer tells you that you'll face consequences if you don't settle a claim, it's a sign that they're trying to strong-arm you. Don't let their threats dictate your actions.
Remember, you have the right to dispute a claim denial or lowball settlement. Don't be afraid to stand up for yourself and fight for what's rightfully yours.
Dishonesty and Fraud
Dishonesty and Fraud is a serious issue in the insurance industry. If an insurance company misleads you about your policy, that's a red flag.
Fraud takes it up a notch, involving intentional deception for gain. This can happen when an insurance company tries to pull a fast one to keep its money in its pocket.
Delay Tactics
Ever felt like you're being given the runaround by your insurer? Delays in handling your claim can be a tactic to pressure you into giving up or accepting a lower settlement.
Insurers might use repeated requests for the same information to wear you down. This can be frustrating and time-consuming, making it harder to get the compensation you deserve.
Delays in claim handling can also have a significant impact on your business, especially if you're still incurring expenses like payroll and rent despite the damage to your property.
Sources
- https://www.lemasterlawfirm.com/bad-faith-claims/
- https://www.gta-law.com/what-are-bad-faith-elements-tx/
- https://www.insuranceclaimrecoverysupport.com/texas-bad-faith/
- https://www.raiznerlaw.com/blog/damages-recoverable-in-a-bad-faith-insurance-case/
- https://johnslawgroup.com/insurance-claims/bad-faith-insurance-texas-your-rights/
Featured Images: pexels.com