data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b0ca2/b0ca25249e77a84393dad84d59183823af09fb88" alt="Two businessmen shaking hands and exchanging car keys in a dealership. Symbolizes a successful deal."
The Biden tax reform has brought significant changes to the 1031 exchange process. The new rules aim to prevent tax avoidance and ensure fairness in the tax system.
Under the new rules, the 1031 exchange is now limited to real estate investments, excluding personal property and intangible assets. This change affects investors who previously used 1031 exchanges to defer taxes on personal property sales.
The new law also eliminates the ability to use a 1031 exchange for a property that will be used as a primary residence or a vacation home. This change applies to properties held for personal use, rather than investment purposes.
The Biden tax reform has introduced a new requirement for investors to use a qualified intermediary to facilitate the 1031 exchange. This adds an extra layer of complexity and cost to the process, which may deter some investors.
Biden's Tax Proposals
President Biden's budget proposes hard limits on IRC Section 1031, which allows for the deferral of taxes on real estate transactions as long as the Exchanger continues to reinvest in real estate.
This proposal would permit deferrals of gain up to an aggregate amount of $500,000 for individuals and $1 million for married couples filing jointly annually for similar real estate exchanges.
The White House emphasizes that this tax increase would affect only the top 1% to 2% of individual taxpayers, but both big and small investors would be impacted.
Investors could save over $40 billion in taxes in the next three to four years if 1031 Exchanges were to remain in place, according to the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation.
The proposal would bring in an additional $19B to the federal budget, as getting rid of 1031s would eliminate the "sweetheart deal" that allows real estate investors to put off paying taxes indefinitely.
This isn't the first time that scrapping 1031 exchanges has been proposed, as the Obama administration also mooted it, but it didn't mean the end of 1031s.
The Biden budget also proposes a 25% minimum income tax on the top 0.01% of earners, which would presumably impact a number of real estate billionaires.
Biden also called on Congress to hike the income tax rate to 39.6% for individuals making more than $400K a year, or $450K for couples, up from the current 37%.
Impact of 1031 Exchanges
1031 Exchanges have a significant impact on the US economy. Two studies, one from Ernst & Young and another from Ling Petrova, demonstrate this impact.
The Ernst & Young study, updated in 2022, shows the macroeconomic contribution of 1031 Exchanges to the US economy in 2021. You can read the summary and full study online.
Ling Petrova's microeconomic impact study highlights the effects of repealing or limiting Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchanges in real estate. The study's findings are worth considering.
Investors could save over $40 billion in taxes in the next three to four years if 1031 Exchanges remain in place, according to the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation.
Impact Studies
Two studies have been conducted to analyze the impact of 1031 Exchanges on the US economy.
The Ernst & Young Macroeconomic Impact Study, updated in 2022, shows the economic contribution of the Like-Kind Exchange Rules to the US economy in 2021.
This study provides a summary and full report, as well as an infographic, for further reference.
The Ling Petrova Microeconomic Impact Study, released in 2021, examines the economic impact of repealing or limiting Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchanges in real estate.
Both studies offer valuable insights into the effects of 1031 Exchanges on the economy.
1031Sustaining American Businesses, updated for 2022, is another resource that provides information on the topic.
Effect on Exchanges
The 1031 Exchange has a significant impact on the US economy, with two studies highlighting its effects. A macroeconomic study by Ernst & Young found that the 1031 Exchange contributed to the US economy in 2021.
Investors can save over $40 billion in taxes in the next three to four years if the 1031 Exchange remains in place, according to the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation. This is money that could be reinvested into other real estate properties.
Both big and small investors can benefit from performing a 1031 Exchange, and it's not just about the tax savings. The Mortgage Bankers Association and the National Association of Realtors appealed to halt the elimination of the exchange, citing its importance to the real estate industry.
The 1031 Exchange is not just a benefit for investors; it also has a broader impact on the economy. A microeconomic study by Ling Petrova found that repealing or limiting Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchanges in Real Estate would have significant effects.
The White House's tax proposal to do away with 1031 Exchanges would impact both big and small investors alike, and it's not just a theoretical concern. The proposal has already been met with opposition from industry groups and individuals who rely on the exchange.
Tax Proposal Effects
The proposed tax changes have significant implications for real estate investors. Repealing section 1031 would tax cash flow, not wealth, and would not raise significant revenue.
If section 1031 is repealed, it would cause a decline in real estate values, a drop in manufacturing, and economic stagnation. This is because like-kind exchanges promote transactional activity that results in jobs and taxable income.
Repealing section 1031 would have a chilling effect on real estate, manufacturing, and other business transactions. This would lead to a substantial decrease in economic activity, resulting in fewer jobs across various industries.
Investors could save over $40 billion in taxes in the next three to four years if 1031 Exchanges were to remain in place. This money would be reinvested into other real estate properties, driving the economy.
Repealing section 1031 would also cause a decline in real estate values, as investors would be forced to pay taxes on their gains, rather than being able to defer them through a 1031 Exchange.
Here are some potential effects of repealing section 1031:
- Decline in real estate values
- Drop in manufacturing
- Economic stagnation
- Substantial increase in depreciation deductions
- Reduced income tax revenue
- Fewer jobs in real estate, construction, title insurance, mortgage, and other related industries
The proposed budget would permit deferrals of gain up to an aggregate amount of $500,000 for individuals ($1 million for married couples filing jointly) annually for similar real estate exchanges. Any gains from 1031 Exchanges above this limit would be recognized in the year the Exchanger transfers the real property and subject to tax.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the downside of a 1031 exchange?
A 1031 exchange is not immune to market downturns, which can negatively impact your investment portfolio if the value of the replacement property drops significantly
Sources
- https://www.ipx1031.com/1031-tax-reform-updates/
- https://www.accruit.com/blog/understanding-how-bidens-proposed-budget-impacts-1031-exchanges
- https://www.my1031pros.com/post/the-impact-of-eliminating-the-1031-exchange-why-the-biden-administration-is-targeting-the-1031-exch
- https://www.tfsproperties.com/did-bidens-tax-proposal-end-up-affecting-1031-exchanges/
- https://www.bisnow.com/national/news/capital-markets/biden-budget-proposes-end-to-1031-exchanges-118036
Featured Images: pexels.com